UK Supreme Court confirms legal advice privilege only applies to advice from lawyers

January 24 2013

The UK Supreme Court delivered its judgment in the Prudential case yesterday, confirming by a majority of five to two that legal advice privilege (LAP) cannot be claimed to protect confidential communications between accountants and their clients for the purpose of requesting or providing legal advice, even in tax matters.

Unlock this content.

The content you are trying to view is exclusive to our subscribers.

To unlock this content:

Take a Free Trial or Login

Topics

more across site & shared bottom lb ros

More from across our site

Indirect Tax

A taxing week: Advisers are struggling to keep pace with indirect tax complexity

ITR’s Indirect Tax Forum 2026 showed why harmonisation remains elusive, advisers must raise their game, and ‘everyone’s data is rubbish’

Tom Baker, June 26 2026

Direct Tax

Oslo, Norway - 24 September 2022: PricewaterhouseCoopers or PWC

PwC Australia to keep Kevin Burrowes as CEO beyond 2026: report

The firm’s board has reportedly asked Kevin Burrowes to continue until 2028 as the KPMG Australia scandal raises expectations of regulatory reform

Sam Sholli, June 26 2026

Direct Tax

This week in tax: A&M Tax launches Italy practice

A former Deloitte partner will lead the firm’s latest geographic expansion; in other news, Baker McKenzie added six tax lawyers to its partnership

Tom Baker, June 26 2026

Direct Tax

Exclusive: Fair Tax Foundation launches new accreditation for single-country businesses

The Fair Tax Mark now extends to domestic-only companies with turnover above €1m, with Thai travel operator Tripseed the first to be certified

Tom Baker, June 25 2026

Indirect Tax

External advisers didn’t know North American e-invoicing requirements: in-house leader

A technology provider had to be educated on technical requirements by Joseph Ribkoff’s IT team, a tax manager at the company said

Sam Sholli, June 24 2026

Indirect Tax

External providers offer accountability ‘if things go wrong’: in-house leader on ViDA

But businesses should remain flexible when choosing between internal and external resources to handle added ViDA complexity, ITR’s Indirect Tax forum also heard

Tom Baker, June 23 2026

Direct Tax

UK tax gap increases to £59.2bn

Non-compliance from small businesses continues to account for most of the gap, HM Revenue and Customs revealed

Tom Baker, June 23 2026

Direct Tax

Tom McDanell on tackling growth with patience

The new managing director of R&D tax relief consultancy ForrestBrown tells ITR about his priorities for the business, where he’s focusing his time and what makes tax cool

June 22 2026

Direct Tax

A taxing week: KPMG’s shabby scandal response can be improved by learning PwC lessons

PwC Australia’s response to its tax leaks scandal could give KPMG a useful case study, but so far there’s little sign of positive lessons learned

Sam Sholli, June 19 2026

Direct Tax

This week in tax: Judge denies ex-US Supreme Court advocate retrial bid

Tom Goldstein’s attempt to overturn his tax conviction was shot down; in other news, Deloitte promoted several tax partners in Italy

Tom Baker, June 19 2026