International Tax Review is part of the Delinian Group, Delinian Limited, 8 Bouverie Street, London, EC4Y 8AX, Registered in England & Wales, Company number 00954730
Copyright © Delinian Limited and its affiliated companies 2023

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

Global Tax 50 2016: Antoine Deltour and Raphaël Halet


Interview with the former PwC employees and whistleblowers.

 Antoine Deltour and Raphaël Halet

Antoine Deltour and Raphaël Halet are a new joint entry this year

Antoine Deltour and Raphaël Halet are new entries to this year's Global Tax 50 for their involvement in the infamous tax scandal, the LuxLeaks, which has been influential in political dialogue to tackle tax avoidance, improve transparency and protect whistleblowers.

Deltour and Raphael, both former PwC employees in Luxembourg, exposed secret tax rulings between multinational enterprises and the Luxembourg government that allowed the companies to pay very little tax. French journalist Edouard Perrin helped publicise the documents that Deltour and Raphael took from their former employers. The issue led to a court case between the whistleblowers, the Luxembourg government and PwC.

On June 29 2016, the trial came to a monumental end, when Luxembourg's Cite Judiciaire found both whistleblowers guilty of theft, violating trade secrets and secrecy laws. The judgment was immediately appealed by both parties, and reconvened on December 12, with further hearings on December 19 and 20.

Deltour and Halet spoke to International Tax Review about the trial and the fight for equality in international taxation.

During his two-year career as a financial auditor at PwC in Luxembourg, Deltour came across hundreds of tax rulings that were, as he described, of "low-substance". In a computer folder marked "Advance Tax Agreements", he uncovered sweetheart tax deals that were an "issue". Acting on instinct, Deltour copied the folder and began his own investigation into the documents. Not long after, he was approached by French journalist Edouard Perrin, who leaked the story to the media and public. For Halet, a former personal assistant in the tax policy services group at PwC, the media coverage helped inform public opinion about tax avoidance schemes in Europe.

The revelations have put pressure on politicians, the European Commission, members of parliament and governments to make changes to tax policy, although Halet said it is "not enough". Initiatives like the automatic exchange of tax information have been successfully implemented as a direct result of the LuxLeaks scandal, Deltour said, adding that he is proud that the LuxLeaks have helped to achieve greater tax transparency and tackle corporate tax avoidance.

However, the fight is not yet over for whistleblowers. There is still an urgent need for further whistleblower protections. Recommendations were issued by the European Commission on September 9 for further action, which have been submitted to the European Parliament. These recommendation call for precautionary measures and actions to protect the EU's financial interests on the protection of whistleblowers. In addition, the European Data Protection Supervisor (EDPS) published guidelines on processing personal information within a whistleblowing procedure. The guidelines were put together to comply with the Data Protection Regulation and include recommendations for the further protection of whistleblowers.

Halet stressed that the European Commission needs to adopt a directive that would create a pan-European fund to support whistleblowers and a European early warning agency. In the meantime, Deltour advised pending whistleblowers to get as much advice from attorneys and NGOs before exposing confidential information. He recommended remaining as an anonymous source, such as a John Doe.

For Deltour, if he had the chance to do anything differently, he said he regretted that the names of the companies and governments were mentioned while the issue was systemic and international. However, he does not regret publicising the scandal. Halet echoed Deltour's sentiment and added that the information revealed from the LuxLeaks "has allowed us to move forward" with strengthening tax policy. Halet's message to whistleblowers is: "When injustice becomes law, resistance becomes duty".

International tax awareness has been heightened throughout 2016, with public interest and understanding in tax matters becoming mainstream in the media. Unlike the US, the EU provides weak protection for whistleblowers and does not have a financial reward mechanism in place. In two tax dispute cases, the US Internal Revenue Service (IRS) granted the whistleblowers award payments under the IRS whistleblower informant programme. Other jurisdictions hungry for revenues may be wise to look at the benefits of a whistleblower programme, particularly given the influence of technology in making whistleblowing 'easier'.

Although there is a long way to go until there is equality in the international tax landscape, Halet reminds us to "never give up".

The Global Tax 50 2016

View the full list and introduction

The top 10 • Ranked in order of influence

1. Margrethe Vestager

2. The International Consortium of Investigative Journalists

3. Brexit

4. Arun Jaitley

5. Jacob Lew

6. Antoine Deltour and Raphaël Halet

7. Operation Zealots

8. Guy Verhofstadt

9. Theresa May (and the 'three Brexiteers')

10. Donald Trump

The remaining 40 • In alphabetic order

Kemi Adeosun

Piet Battiau

Elise Bean

Monica Bhatia

Allison Christians

Tim Cook

Rita de la Feria

Caroline Flint

Judith Freedman

Chrystia Freeland

Pravin Gordhan

Orrin Hatch

Meg Hillier

Mulyani Indrawati

Lou Jiwei

Paul Johnson

Stephanie Johnston

Chris Jordan

Pravind Jugnauth

Wang Jun

Jean-Claude Juncker

Kathleen Kerrigan

Christine Lagarde

Werner Langen

Jolyon Maugham

Angela Merkel

Narendra Modi

Will Morris

Michael Noonan

Grace Perez-Navarro

Platform for the Collaboration on Tax

Donato Raponi

Pascal Saint-Amans

Heather Self

Robert Stack

Tax Justice Network

The Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC)

Transparency International

US Committee on Ways and Means

Rodrigo Valdés

more across site & bottom lb ros

More from across our site

Developments included the end of Saudi Arabia’s tax amnesty, Poland’s VAT battle with the EU, the Indirect Tax Forum, India’s WTO complaint, and more.
Charlotte Sallabank and Christy Wilson of Katten UK look at the Premier League's use of 'dual representation' contracts for tax matters.
Shareholders are set to vote on whether the asset management firm will adopt public CbCR, amid claims of tax avoidance.
US lawmakers averted a default on debt by approving the Fiscal Responsibility Act, but this deal may consolidate the Biden tax reforms rather than undermine them.
In a letter to the Australian Senate, the firm has provided the names of all 67 staff who received confidential emails but has not released them publicly.
David Pickstone and Anastasia Nourescu of Stewarts review the facts and implications of Ørsted’s appeal at the Upper Tribunal.
The Internal Revenue Service will lose the funding as part of the US debt limit deal, while Amazon UK reaps the benefits of the 130% ‘super-deduction’.
The European Commission wanted to make an example of US companies like Apple, but its crusade against ‘sweetheart’ tax rulings may be derailed at the CJEU.
The OECD has announced that a TP training programme is about to conclude in West Africa, a region that has been plagued by mispricing activities for a number of years.
Richard Murphy and Andrew Baker make the case for tax transparency as a public good and how key principles should lead to a better tax system.