Stop the press: Not another tax named after a multinational

International Tax Review is part of Legal Benchmarking Limited, 1-2 Paris Garden, London, SE1 8ND

Copyright © Legal Benchmarking Limited and its affiliated companies 2025

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

Stop the press: Not another tax named after a multinational

Editor Joe Stanley-Smith introduces the February 2019 issue of International Tax Review

In an interview with a national newspaper, Rebecca Long-Bailey, a key member of the UK opposition party, Labour, suggested that her party could introduce an 'Amazon tax' if elected.

But wait, didn't the UK already introduce an Amazon tax in the October 2018 budget? Yes, it did. This was the name given to what you and I would call the digital services tax.

This brings me to one of my pet hates as a tax journalist: naming taxes after the multinationals they're ostensibly targeting. The phrase 'Google tax' stirs within me feelings of inexplicable rage.

Various countries including Italy have mooted taxes on advertising known as 'Google taxes'. In the UK, the Google tax is the diverted profits tax, which doesn't actually apply to Google.

In Russia, the term is widely used to mean the destination principle for VAT purposes applied on online e-services sales. France's digital service tax (on the same principles as the UK 'Amazon tax') is often referred to as the 'GAFA tax', an acronym for Google, Apple, Facebook and Amazon.

After exploding in a whirlwind of expletives when reading the headline, I settled in to read the newspaper article itself. Long-Bailey was actually rather measured in her interview: "It's not a case of black and white, 'right, well, let's tax online and give tax reliefs to high street retailers', because I don't think that's fair either," she said.

At no point did she reference an 'Amazon tax'. Nor, as far as I've been able to tell, did UK Chancellor Philip Hammond in his budget speech.

It seems I'd been taken in by one of the past decade's numerous unedifying journalistic trends: Clickbait.

All this time I've been angry with politicians for oversimplifying tax matters, and with tax policymakers for overcomplicating them, but should journalists take the blame? Are we the baddies?

Well, not ITR of course. Our reporters understand complex tax matters and have time to analyse issues. But time is not a luxury afforded to most of our contemporaries at mainstream publications. It's why I applaud the work of tax professionals, from Richard Murphy through to Grover Norquist and everyone in between, who make an effort to speak to the public about tax matters.

With the rise of fake news, alternative facts, clickbait and the five-second attention span, communicating complicated concepts like the taxation of the digital economy is important if we're to have rational debate on the subject.

Joe Stanley-Smith

Editor, International Tax Review
joseph.stanley-smith@euromoneyplc.com

more across site & shared bottom lb ros

More from across our site

Thanks to operational slickness and sheer force of will, A&M Tax will continue hoovering up talent across the globe
Setu Kamal became the first practising barrister to be added to the UK’s tax avoidance promoter list; in other news, UHY expanded its network in Canada
US President Donald Trump’s tariffs may get thrown out by courts in the future and taxpayers should already be planning for that possibility, BDO’s Dustin Stamper tells ITR
Awards
ITR is delighted to reveal the first shortlisted nominees for the Middle East Tax Awards
The firm has appointed Deloitte’s former tax leader for Thailand to lead the new operation, which builds on considerable Asian investment in recent months
The Donald Trump administration could use legislation from 1930 if the Supreme Court blocks its tariffs; in other news, China has updated its VAT refund procedures
Braun gives ITR an exclusive insight into WTS Digital’s UK launch of its AI product, which can free up more than 1,500 hours per month by reducing routine tasks
Long tells ITR about her varied role, why curiosity is a key characteristic for the tax professional, and what she’d be doing if she wasn’t working in tax
The choice facing governments is not whether to adopt AI in taxation, but how to do so in a way that upholds the principles of tax fairness, writes Neil Kelley
As ITR’s client data reveals discontent with German tax advisers’ cost management, Grant Thornton’s local TP head insists it’s a two-way street
Gift this article