IRS wins another LILO case but slips up in arguing economic substance

International Tax Review is part of Legal Benchmarking Limited, 1-2 Paris Garden, London, SE1 8ND

Copyright © Legal Benchmarking Limited and its affiliated companies 2026

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

Cookies Settings

IRS wins another LILO case but slips up in arguing economic substance

Joe Dalton
August 07 2013
john-hancock-logo-small.jpg

US life insurance company John Hancock has lost its Tax Court case concerning lease-in-lease-out (LILO) and sale-in-lease-out (SILO) transactions, meaning the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) continues its record of having won all cases on this issue. However, the IRS may have caused itself future difficulties by making an economic substance argument.

Unlock this content.

The content you are trying to view is exclusive to our subscribers.

To unlock this content:

Take a Free Trial or Login

Topics

NewsUnited StatesTax Disputes
JD
Joe Dalton
Contact
Joe Dalton worked at ITR between 2011 and 2013
more across site & shared bottom lb ros

More from across our site

Transfer Pricing
Australian Company Tax Return concept
IKEA announces intention to dispute A$171m ATO tax claim
The Australian Taxation Office believes the Swedish furniture company has used TP to evade paying tax it owes
Sam Sholli, January 07 2026
Indirect Tax
hmrc large
This month in indirect tax: UK supermarket loses VAT court battle
Supermarket chain Morrisons is facing a £17 million ($23 million) tax bill; in other news, Donald Trump has cut proposed tariffs
Sam Sholli, January 07 2026
Direct Tax
OECD building
Landmark pillar two side-by-side agreement reached
The controversial deal will allow US-parented groups to be carved out from key aspects of pillar two
Tom Baker, January 05 2026
Awards
ITR World Tax 2026 website - 1200x627.png
ITR World Tax 2027 and ITR Tax Awards 2026 opens for submissions
ITR invites tax firms, in-house teams, and tax professionals to make submissions for the 2027 World Tax rankings and the 2026 ITR Tax Awards globally
John Harrison, January 05 2026
Direct Tax
Federico Bertocchi .jpg
EU pillar two directive may violate freedom of establishment: academic
Pillar two was ‘weakened’ when it altered from a multinational convention agreement to simply national domestic law, Federico Bertocchi also argued
Sam Sholli, January 05 2026
Direct Tax
Gold and silver crypto currencies
Brazilian advisers warn of disputes over crypto transaction tax proposals
Imposing the tax on virtual assets is a measure that appears to have no legal, economic or statistical basis, one expert told ITR
Sam Sholli, December 23 2025
Direct Tax
trumpp large
A taxing week: Trump’s pillar two deal won’t save the project
The EU has seemingly capitulated to the US’s ‘side-by-side’ demands. This may be a win for the US, but the uncertainty has only just begun for pillar two
Sam Sholli, December 22 2025
Direct Tax
Business deal mergers and acquisitions
MHA acquires tax and consulting services firm in UAE
The £7.4m buyout marks MHA’s latest acquisition since listing on the London Stock Exchange earlier this year
Sam Sholli, December 22 2025
Direct Tax
2025
Editor’s picks: ITR’s top stories of 2025
ITR’s most prolific stories of the year charted public pillar two spats, the continued fallout from the PwC Australia tax leaks scandal, and a headline tax fraud trial
Tom Baker, December 22 2025
Direct Tax
EU flag large
This week in tax: EU nations drop US pillar two carve-out objections
The climbdowns pave the way for a side-by-side deal to be concluded this week, as per the US Treasury secretary’s expectation; in other news, Taft added a 10-partner tax team
Sam Sholli, December 19 2025
Gift this article