Romania: pharmaceutical giant's €12m VAT refund sets precedent for clawbacks

International Tax Review is part of Legal Benchmarking Limited, 4 Bouverie Street, London, EC4Y 8AX

Copyright © Legal Benchmarking Limited and its affiliated companies 2025

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

Romania: pharmaceutical giant's €12m VAT refund sets precedent for clawbacks

Sponsored by

EY_Logo_Beam_STFWC_Horizontal_Large_RGB_OffBlack_Yellow_EN.gif
Tablets and euro

The decision’s implications for pharmaceutical firms seeking to recover overpaid taxes on clawback payments are considered by Emanuel Bancila and Andrei Boian of Bancila, Diaconu and Associates, which is part of the EY Law network

The Romanian High Court of Cassation and Justice has ruled in favour of a pharmaceutical giant in a long-running dispute over VAT payments, awarding the company a €12 million tax refund. The taxpayer is also entitled to a 45% interest repayment and compensation of the inflation rate, which was over 50%. The case – in which Bancila, Diaconu and Associates (an EY-affiliated law firm), together with EY Tax Romania, advised and represented the company – revolved around the VAT treatment of clawback payments and marks a significant victory for pharmaceutical firms operating under similar price-volume agreements across the EU.

The decision follows a 2021 ruling by the Court of Justice of the European Union in the Boehringer case, which allowed pharmaceutical companies to apply to reduce their VAT base when they reimburse a portion of sales to governments under a price-volume agreement. The case set a precedent that EY teams in several other countries, including Hungary and Germany, have successfully applied to other pharmaceutical companies with local operations.

EY Law had approached several businesses regarding the opportunity to recover overpaid VAT in this regard, but the company in question was the first that was prepared to go to litigation with the Romanian tax authority.

Before taking the clawback opportunity, the pharmaceutical giant interested in being supported in another matter relating to bad debts. Almost in parallel to appointing Bancila, Diaconu and Associates and EY Romania on the first clawback-related matter, it turned its attention to the bad debts matter. The latter was resolved within six months, enabling the company to recover a significant amount of overpaid taxes.

Using a Romanian tax procedural code provision to good effect

EY Romania led the case and took a rarely used approach in attempting to reclaim overpaid taxes. Instead of adjusting past VAT returns for any impacted years – an approach recommended by many other practitioners but one that carries significant risks – the EY Romania legal team utilised a provision in the country’s tax code that allows businesses to request tax refunds without adjusting the VAT return. This has the advantage of not risking late-payment interest charges.

The litigation spanned six years; during which, a legislative change confirmed the VAT clawback position for future tax years. Nevertheless, the Romanian tax authorities do not recognise EU jurisprudence for past periods until the law is modified accordingly, which happened in March 2024. This enabled EY Romania to focus on the previous seven years, beyond the statute of limitations period.

The wider significance of the case

The ruling – in May 2024, with the grounds of the ruling communicated in December 2024 – is expected to have broader implications, with at least 15 other pharmaceutical companies pursuing retrospective VAT claims through EY Romania. The firm is also exploring the possibility of supporting the company in claiming beyond the seven-year period already repaid.

The case highlights the evolving VAT landscape for pharmaceutical companies in the EU and the increasing willingness of businesses to challenge tax authorities over retrospective claims. As more firms look to capitalise on this precedent, the decision could set the stage for further legal battles in the sector.

more across site & shared bottom lb ros

More from across our site

Effective audit management requires more than documentation; it’s the way taxpayers engage that can shape audit direction, manage procedural ambiguity, and preserve options for appeal or litigation
American advisers are falling short of client expectations when it comes to providing value-added services, but remaining tight-lipped won’t make the problem go away
Awards
The Social Impact Awards unveil new categories to reflect a changing legal and social landscape
Australia's approach to tax policy has undergone significant shifts in recent years, reflecting global trends and unique domestic considerations. These developments merit close attention from tax professionals
The UK has temporarily dodged the 50% rate due to a trade deal signed with the US in May; in other news, Ryan acquired a Northern Irish tax firm
Following a $28 million funding round, Aibidia wants to ‘double down’ on the US market via partnerships with the ‘big four’, the Finnish TP tech provider’s CEO tells ITR
The Luxembourg-based TP leader tells ITR about relishing the intellectual challenge of his practice, his admiration for Stephen Hawking, and what makes tax cool
The case to determine whether the tariff regime is constitutional will eventually find its way to the US Supreme Court, ITR has also heard
In other news, the Council of the EU pledged support to a CBAM simplification and exemption initiative, and Portugal issued new VAT filing guidance
While Brazil’s sweeping tax updates are a triumph for modernisation, Giuliano Gioia of Sovos warns that MNEs with a Brazilian footprint should be prepared for a short and sharp adjustment
Gift this article