This week in tax: HMRC reveals estimated £1bn R&D tax fraud

International Tax Review is part of Legal Benchmarking Limited, 1-2 Paris Garden, London, SE1 8ND

Copyright © Legal Benchmarking Limited and its affiliated companies 2025

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

This week in tax: HMRC reveals estimated £1bn R&D tax fraud

HMRC 2000x.jpeg

HMRC also substantially revises its fraud estimate for 2021/22, while Colombia prepares to host a Latin American tax summit that could be pivotal in the UN’s powerplay.

HM Revenue and Customs published its annual report for 2022/23 on Monday, July 17, with the revelation of an estimated £1 billion ($1.2 billion) of erroneous and fraudulent claims under the research and development tax relief scheme.

The revenue service also revised its 2021/22 estimate of error and fraud from £338 million to £1.1 billion. At the same time, HMRC reported it has improved on tax compliance and enforcement, with an estimated tax gap of 4.8%.

Investigative think tank TaxWatch has claimed this means HMRC has underestimated the scale of R&D tax fraud in the past. Nevertheless, HMRC said it has raised £34 billion in additional revenue by tackling tax avoidance and evasion.

Colombia set to host Latin American tax summit

The Colombian government is preparing to host the Latin American tax summit next week in Cartagena on Thursday, July 27, and Friday, July 28.

Colombia may be preparing the ground for alternative proposals to the OECD’s international tax reforms. This conference is the first of its kind and could mean Latin American countries will make more demands on the OECD as it tries to finalise the two-pillar solution.

In September 2022, Colombia was the first Latin American country to announce its support for a UN tax convention. A bloc of African countries later tipped the UN General Assembly vote in favour of the proposal in November.

Germany’s tax revenue down in June

Germany’s tax revenue fell by 7.3% across the board in June compared to last year, the Ministry of Finance said yesterday, July 20.

The reduction was felt by both federal and regional state governments and represents a total of €86.39 billion ($96.71 billion).

The ministry said this was partly due to tax relief measures introduced to compensate for inflation.

Total revenue for the first half of 2023 was down 2% compared with last year, standing at €399.75 billion ($346 billion).

However, experts have forecast that Germany’s total tax revenue for 2023 will be 2.9% higher than in 2022, suggesting a substantial increase in the last six months of the year. This assumes a total revenue of €838.19 billion for 2023.

The ministry also said that the decrease in revenue could be partly explained by “a special effect that increased last year’s baseline for import VAT revenue”, which once accounted for would lower this June's reduction from 7.3% to just 3.5%.

Door opens for Biden to negotiate Taiwan tax deal

The US House of Representatives passed legislation on Wednesday, July 19, that will allow President Joe Biden’s administration to negotiate a tax agreement with Taiwan.

Top US lawmakers praised the legislation as a way to increase investment between the two nations as well as reduce the risk of Chinese aggression towards Taiwan, reported Reuters.

House Foreign Affairs Committee Chairman Michael McCaul said: “In addition to the advantages we will receive from more investment from Taiwan, this is another important step in safeguarding Taiwan and maintaining peace and stability in the Indo-Pacific.”

The lack of a tax agreement has meant that businesses operating between the US and Taiwan have sometimes been hit by double taxation.

China claims Taiwan as part of its own territory and has been increasing political pressure to enforce those claims.

India brings back windfall tax on crude oil

The Indian government reinstated the windfall tax on crude oil production at ₹1,600 per tonne ($19.49) on Saturday, July 15, reported the Economic Times based in Mumbai.

Domestic crude oil production was expected to surge when the windfall tax was effectively suspended in April. Indian energy companies including Oil and Natural Gas Corporation, Oil India and Cairn Oil & Gas all stood to gain from this policy change.

However, the Indian government has reversed this decision following the rise of crude oil prices since Russia and Saudi Arabia cut back production.

India imposed the windfall tax on energy companies in July 2022 when global energy prices were soaring. This included a ₹23,250 per tonne tax on domestic crude oil production, as well as export duties of ₹6 per litre on petrol and ₹13 per litre on diesel.

Next week in ITR

ITR will be following the latest developments in PwC Australia’s tax leaks scandal.

Elsewhere, we will continue to discuss the implications of the OECD’s pillar one and pillar two announcements.

Readers can expect these stories and plenty more next week. Don’t miss out on the key developments. Sign up for a free trial to ITR.

more across site & shared bottom lb ros

More from across our site

The partnership model was looking antiquated even before the UK chancellor’s expected tax raid on LLPs was revealed. An additional tax burden may finally kill it off
The US’s GILTI regime will not be forced upon American multinationals in foreign jurisdictions, Bloomberg has reported; in other news, Ropes & Gray hired two tax partners from Linklaters
APAs should provide a pragmatic means to agree to an arm's-length outcome for an Australian entity and for the ATO, the tax authority said
Overall revenues and average profit per partner also increased in the UK, the ‘big four’ firm revealed
Increasingly complex reporting requirements contributed towards the firm’s growth in tax, it said
Sector-specific business taxes, private equity tax treatment reform and changes to the taxation of non-residents are all on the cards for the UK, authors from Herbert Smith Freehills Kramer predict
The UK’s Labour government has an unpopular prime minister, an unpopular chancellor and not a lot of good options as it prepares to deliver its autumn Budget
Awards
The firms picked up five major awards between them at a gala ceremony held at New York’s prestigious Metropolitan Club
The streaming company’s operating income was $400m below expectations following the dispute; in other news, the OECD has released updates for 25 TP country profiles
Software company Oracle has won the right to have its A$250m dispute with the ATO stayed, paving the way for a mutual agreement procedure
Gift this article