International Tax Review is part of the Delinian Group, Delinian Limited, 8 Bouverie Street, London, EC4Y 8AX, Registered in England & Wales, Company number 00954730
Copyright © Delinian Limited and its affiliated companies 2023

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

HMRC sends ‘nudge’ letters to 2,000 companies over R&D tax fraud

HM Treasury-UK budget.jpg

The action is part of a crackdown on inaccurate and fraudulent R&D tax claims, which cost the government £469 million last year.

The UK revenue service has sent letters to 2,000 businesses in response to fraudulent and mistaken claims to the research and development tax relief schemes, it has emerged.

In letters sent in January, HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) warned companies that they may face formal tax enquiries and rejected claims if their returns are found to be inaccurate for whatever reason.

Taxpayers should check their relief claims, identify any inaccuracies and make amendments as soon as possible, according to the revenue service.

The HMRC letters told companies: “We’ve seen an increase in fraudulent claims for R&D tax relief. We also believe companies in your sector are being deliberately targeted by third parties to make inaccurate R&D claims as an amendment to their company tax returns.

“As company director, it’s important you submit accurate claims for the correct amount of tax relief,” the letters added. “If we check a claim and find it’s incorrect, your company might be asked to pay back the full amount.”

Carrie Rutland, partner at advisory firm BDO’s innovations and technology team in the UK, said she expects HMRC to keep issuing these nudge letters and that the window of opportunity to address past claims could be closing.

“It’s important for all businesses to review their past R&D claims to make sure there are no potential skeletons in the company closet,” said Rutland.

“It’s always better to make a voluntary disclosure for errors before you are nudged by HMRC, as this should be treated as an ‘unprompted’ disclosure which carries a much lower penalty – if any,” she added.

In its annual report from December 2022, HMRC estimated that £469 million ($570 million) was lost through fraud and error in its two R&D schemes in tax year 2021-22. This was the equivalent of 4.9% of corporate tax R&D relief.

The UK government has responded by increasing resources for HMRC to boost compliance. For example, the revenue service has doubled the size of its specialist R&D team focused on compliance among SMEs.

HMRC sent out the ‘nudge’ letters on the weeks of January 23 and January 30 with the aim of raising awareness of the problem.

The UK government is holding a consultation on merging the R&D tax relief schemes into one simplified programme. Businesses have until March 13 to comment.

more across site & bottom lb ros

More from across our site

ITR’s latest quarterly PDF is going live today, leading on the EU’s BEFIT initiative and wider tax reforms in the bloc.
COVID-19 and an overworked HMRC may have created the ‘perfect storm’ for reduced prosecutions, according to tax professionals.
Participants in the consultation on the UN secretary-general’s report into international tax cooperation are divided – some believe UN-led structures are the way forward, while others want to improve existing ones. Ralph Cunningham reports.
The German government unveils plans to implement pillar two, while EY is reportedly still divided over ‘Project Everest’.
With the M&A market booming, ITR has partnered with correspondents from firms around the globe to provide a guide to the deal structures being employed and tax authorities' responses.
Xing Hu, partner at Hui Ye Law Firm in Shanghai, looks at the implications of the US Uyghur Forced Labor Protection Act for TP comparability analysis of China.
Karl Berlin talks to Josh White about meeting the Fair Tax standard, the changing burden of country-by-country reporting, and how windfall taxes may hit renewable energy.
Sandy Markwick, head of the Tax Director Network (TDN) at Winmark, looks at the challenges of global mobility for tax management.
Taxpayers should look beyond the headline criteria of the simplification regime to ensure that their arrangements meet the arm’s-length standard, say Alejandro Ces and Mark Seddon of the EY New Zealand transfer pricing team.
In a recent webinar hosted by law firms Greenberg Traurig and Clayton Utz, officials at the IRS and ATO outlined their visions for 2023.