All material subject to strictly enforced copyright laws. © 2022 ITR is part of the Euromoney Institutional Investor PLC group.

Grid connection costs qualify for capital allowances in Tax Appeals Commission case

Sponsored by Sponsored_Firms_deloitte.png
Grid connections represent a significant cost in the development of power generation projects

Steven Gardiner and Brian O’Sullivan of Deloitte Ireland provide an overview of a Tax Appeals Commission case which held that power station grid connection costs qualify for capital allowances.

Grid connections represent a significant cost in the development of power generation projects. A recent ruling by the Tax Appeals Commission (TAC) provided welcome clarity that this expenditure should qualify for capital allowances. 

Wear and tear allowances 

Wear and tear allowances (WTA) are a form of capital allowance or tax depreciation that is used by a taxpayer to offset their taxable profits. 

Some of the legislative requirements for entitlement to WTA include: capital expenditure has to be incurred on the provision of plant and machinery (p&m); it is in use wholly and exclusively for the purposes of a trade at the end of the chargeable period; and it belongs to them. WTA are claimed over eight years at 12.5% per annum. 

WTA are a complex tax technical area that is largely governed by case law and precedent.

The project 

In 2003, the taxpayer developed a combined cycle gas turbine power station to generate electricity.

Connection to both the electricity and gas national grids was an integral and essential requirement for the project. The power station is gas fuelled and is a significant demand user. As a power generator it exports and imports electricity via a connection to the electrical national grid. The taxpayer contracted with the electricity and gas grid operators (grid operators) and paid them for constructing these connections.

Although power generators incur the cost of the grid connections there is a statutory obligation to transfer the ownership to the grid operators to ensure continued, reliable operation of this strategically important infrastructure.

In addition, the power generators are also liable for all annual operation, maintenance and upkeep costs of the grid connections.

The issue

In addition to the p&m within the power station, the taxpayer capitalised the grid connection costs and claimed WTA. This resulted in them having significant tax adjusted losses for a number of years subsequent to the development of the project.

Some years later the Revenue Commissioners conducted an audit and on the basis that, in their opinion, the grid connections did not belong to the taxpayer, and was too remote from the provision of the p&m, determined that the taxpayer was not entitled to claim WTA. Consequently, they raised Notices of Assessment for a number of years. 

Taxpayer’s appeal

The taxpayer appealed on a number of grounds. They contended “that the connections… are machinery and plant which are integral to the commissioning and continued operation of the power station. It was submitted that these connections are in use for the trade and are wholly and exclusively used for the purposes of its trade”. It was argued that without these connections it would not be possible to operate the power station to generate electricity. 

The hearing 

Representatives for the taxpayer advised, “the connections to the national grids of gas and electricity are essential to the operation of the power station”. They also referred to the energy regulations, which obliged the taxpayer to transfer the ownership of these assets to the grid operators.

As part of their submission, the taxpayer cited a number of cases such as Ben-Odeco Ltd v. Powlson [1978] and Cooke v. Beach Station Caravans Ltd [1974]. These cases determined that, in addition to the cost of the p&m itself, incidental expenditure can also be included in the claim for capital allowances.

The ruling 

TAC ruled in favour of the taxpayer.

On the issue of the p&m belonging to the taxpayer, TAC advised “the only reason for the transfer of ownership of the said connections is to ensure the integrity and security of the electricity system in the State and that, but for that statutory and regulatory requirement, the connections would have remained in the ownership of the Taxpayer”.

On the point that the expenditure was on the provision of p&m, they advised “the electricity and gas connections… are a necessary and integral part of the taxpayer’s Power Station. The connections were necessary to bring the plant and machinery which constitutes the Power Station into operation and they continue to be necessary to allow the Power Station to operate for the intended trade purpose of generating electricity”. The grid connection costs constituted ancillary expenditure necessary for the provision of the p&m used to generate electricity and that p&m belonged to the taxpayer. 

Application

Considering the amount of power generation and other infrastructure projects that require grid connections that are in planning, design or under construction, and the significant costs involved, this ruling provides welcome clarity on the entitlement to claim WTA on this expenditure.

 

Steven Gardiner

Director, Deloitte Ireland

E: sgardiner@deloitte.ie


Brian O’Sullivan

Senior manager, Deloitte Ireland

E: brosullivan@deloitte.ie

 

More from across our site

The state secretary told the French press that the country continues to oppose pillar two’s global minimum tax rate following an Ecofin meeting last week.
This week the Biden administration has run into opposition over a proposal for a federal gas tax holiday, while the European Parliament has approved a plan for an EU carbon border mechanism.
Businesses need to improve on data management to ensure tax departments become much more integrated, according to Microsoft’s chief digital officer at a KPMG event.
Businesses must ensure any alternative benchmark rate is included in their TP studies and approved by tax authorities, as Libor for the US ends in exactly a year.
Tax directors warn that a lack of adequate planning for VAT rule changes could leave businesses exposed to regulatory errors and costly fines.
Tax professionals have urged suppliers of goods from Great Britain to Northern Ireland to pause any plans to restructure their supply chains following the NI Protocol Bill.
Tax leaders say communication with peers is important for risk management, especially on how to approach regional authorities.
Advances in compliance tools in international markets and the digitalisation of global tax administrations are increasing in-house demand for technologists.
The US fast-food company has agreed to pay €1.25 billion to settle the French investigation into its transfer pricing arrangements over allegations of tax evasion.
HM Revenue and Customs said the UK pillar two legislation will be delayed until at least December 2023, while ITR reported on a secret Netflix settlement and an IMF study on VAT cuts.
We use cookies to provide a personalized site experience.
By continuing to use & browse the site you agree to our Privacy Policy.
I agree