Since 2004, we have seen discussions about reforming China's income distribution regime, which, in Chinese terminology, consists of initial distribution and secondary distribution. The initial distribution primarily relies on market mechanisms to reward the participants (for example, enterprises, employees and investors) in the economy with financial compensations based on their contributions.
During the secondary distribution, government uses fiscal, tax and social policies to re-distribute income among the participants in the economy. The purpose of the reform is to improve efficiency in the initial distribution and enhance equality in the secondary distribution.
The specific measures mentioned in article 32 of the 5YP include:
adjustment of the IIT tax base;
revision of the progressive rate schedule;
higher personal exemption for salaries;
lower IIT burden for mid-to-low income earners;
larger IIT collections from high-income individuals; and
the establishment of an individual property tax system.
In short, the scope of IIT reform contemplated in 5YP was extensive.
Considering that the 2008 reforms in Chinese corporate income tax (CIT) took many years to prepare and implement, many were wondering how long it would take for the same degree of transformation in Chinese IIT to happen.
Encouragingly, over the last 18 months, clear actions were witnessed to address the objectives set out in the 5YP for reforming Chinese IIT. For instance, the standing committee of the National People's Congress (NPC) issued the Order of the President of the People's Republic of China No 48 on June 30 2011 (Order 48), which increased the personal exemption for salaried workers from Rmb2,000 ($318) a month to Rmb3,500 ($556) a month, and reduced the IIT liability for mid-to-low salary earners through adjustment of the tax rate schedule. These changes took effect on September 1 2011.
Order 48 marks a significant step forward for the Chinese government on IIT reform. Despite several increases in the personal exemption since the enactment of the Chinese IIT Law in 1980, the IIT rates for salaried workers have remained relatively unchanged for more than three decades. The adjustment of the tax rate schedule in conjunction with the increase in the personal exemption reflects the government's intention to accelerate the IIT reform.
Impact of Order 48
Since the introduction of the new IIT rates and the increased personal exemption for salaried workers in September 2011, the weight of IIT collection within the total tax revenue has decreased. The IIT collection amount in the first eight months of 2012 shrunk by 8.4% compared with the comparable figure for the same period of 2011. This result shows the effects of the IIT reduction for low and medium-income individuals and the monthly personal exemption increase from Rmb2,000 to Rmb3,500.
Before Order 48, a foreign national working in China was eligible to a personal exemption of Rmb4,800 a month; in contrast, a personal exemption of Rmb2,000 of was available to Chinese salaried workers.
The increase in the personal exemption threshold for Chinese salaried workers from Rmb2,000 to Rmb3,500 a month under Order 48 did not lead to any adjustment for foreign nationals working in China. In effect, Order 48 narrowed the difference between the personal exemptions for local and foreign employees. This may be an indication that in the long run, the same level of personal exemption may be employed across the board, irrespective of nationality.
Considering the CIT reform in 2008 unified the income tax rules for foreign investment enterprises and domestic enterprises, it would not be surprising if in the future the State Administration of Taxation (SAT) revisits IIT concessions for housing benefits, children's education and other allowances, which are available to foreign employees only, if they are considered to violate the principle of equity.
Despite the positive significance, measures in Order 48 only represent a marginal improvement of the existing IIT system, and certainly do not satisfy the appetite of many Chinese salaried workers who want more comprehensive IIT reform and more equitable distribution of IIT costs in the overall population.
In a report dated March 9 2012, the Standing Committee of the NPC reiterated the need for the country to:
establish a comprehensive IIT system in China; and
effectively regulate income redistribution in China through taxation.
Is China ready for a new IIT system?
Under the existing IIT system, individual income is divided into categories. Each category has a separate tax rate or rate schedule as well as its own personal exemption. Different categories are not consolidated for computing an individual's annual IIT liability, even though, for years, reformists have advocated a comprehensive IIT system that follows a mixture of the consolidated and the categorised approaches. Such a proposal has outlived three 5YPs since the 1990s and was adopted again into the 12th 5YP. However, as of now, no clear agenda for implementation is in sight.
Why is it difficult to adopt a comprehensive IIT system? The conversion into such an IIT system requires sophisticated tax collection and administration mechanisms to support it. These would involve:
setting up individual taxpayer accounts;
effective management of cash transactions;
building up a complete social credit system; and
establishing a centralised database that links an individual's tax filing status with his or her credit rating, education/employment profile, and social welfare status.
Furthermore, tougher enforcement of tax regulations and severe penalties for breaching regulations are also necessary to guide taxpayers' behaviour. China does not have the systems in place to support a comprehensive IIT arrangement. It will take some time before the necessary infrastructure and tools become available, as was pointed out by a senior official of the SAT in a recent media interview.
Besides the income consolidation issue, discussions about reforming the Chinese IIT system also concern whether IIT should be collected based on the family unit or the individual unit. Yet again, adoption of family-based reporting units may not be feasible in China at this juncture, because it would require a sophisticated system, which is not in place.
Determining tax exemptions and tax rates under a family-based joint-filing system would require collection, collation, and testing of demographic data from various sources, a process that could take a few years to complete.
From January 1 2006, individuals in China with an annual income of more than Rmb120,000 are required to file annual PRC IIT returns with their local tax authorities before March 31 of the year after the tax reporting year. Through this mandatory annual filing process for a selected group of individuals, Chinese tax authorities are building an IT system and database to prepare for IIT reform as the next step. Only targeting one segment of the population initially makes the implementation work easier and allows Chinese tax authorities to gather valuable experience and information for the program to expand to broader segments later on.
According to this historical pattern of tax reform, though a programme of filing IIT returns on a family unit basis or consolidated basis is likely to be the future direction of China's IIT reform, it is unlikely that such a programme will be rolled out to all taxpayers at once. A pilot programme may be initiated for a smaller group first, and eventually a formal programme may be promulgated to cover all individual taxpayers in China. Therefore, we do not expect a nationwide IIT reform towards a comprehensive system to happen in the next 12 months.
In the near term, the priority of the Chinese tax authorities will probably continue to be the enforcement of IIT compliance on high-income individuals to effectively regulate income redistribution through IIT.
What measures are taken to strengthen IIT compliance for high-income earners?
The IIT system is fairly effective in collecting IIT from salary income by requiring employers to be withholding agents. However, there are significant loopholes related to taxing individual income from high-earning executives, investors, and entrepreneurs. Senior business executives often derive significant portions of their incomes from bonuses, allowances, equity incentive plans and earnings received from overseas companies. Investors can realise large sums of income from disposals of property and other capital transactions. Entrepreneurs make sizeable business profits from their self-employment and independent labour services.
To strengthen the collection of IIT from senior business executives, we have learned that the SAT will focus on these areas in 2012:
Continue to strictly enforce the requirement of annual IIT filings to be performed by individuals whose annual income is more than Rmb120,000
Require that detailed monthly online filings be performed by the executives' employers
Inspect individuals who receive wages and salaries from two or more sources and consolidate the details submitted by the employers
Compare and cross-reference the salary expenses declared in the CIT return of the employer with the salary income declared in the monthly IIT withholding returns submitted by the employer
Strengthen the tax collection and management of IIT on income derived by business executives from stock options, restricted stock units, and other equity incentive plans
Investigate the IIT treatment of allowances and expense reimbursements received by business executives.
To improve the system in collecting IIT from investors and entrepreneurs, the SAT issued a circular in 2011 to strengthen IIT administration of the disposal of investment property.
For example, when an individual transfers an equity interest in a Chinese company, under the prevailing regulations, the ownership registration of the equity interest with the State Administration of Industry and Commerce or its local branches (AIC) should be updated to reflect the change in title.
When the AIC processes an application for amending the ownership registration because of a transfer of equity interest, the 2011 circular requires that the individual seller submit a tax clearance certificate in connection with the transfer to the AIC in charge. The tax clearance certificate is to prove that the individual seller has settled IIT on the property transfer. Without the tax clearance certificate, the AIC will not approve the application.
Capital transactions such as equity interest transfers by individual investors and entrepreneurs will continue to be the focus of the 2012 IIT administration and audit. The tax authorities will collect information from various government authorities on equity transactions related to listed and non-listed companies, as well as transactions on real estate, mineral resources investments, private equity funds, trusts and other investments, to verify whether the individual investors and entrepreneurs have fulfilled their IIT obligations.
The SAT hopes that heightened enforcement will lead to an increase in IIT collection from capital transactions, which can partially make up for the reduction in IIT revenue because of the tax relief measures in Order 48.
What other areas do multinational companies need to consider when sending foreign workers to China?
Besides the reforms of the IIT system, China has issued regulations that technically do not relate to IIT, but have immediate tax implications for the prevalent practice of multinational companies (MNCs) sending expatriates to China as secondees.
Economic employer
It is common practice for MNCs to dispatch foreign employees to work in their Chinese affiliates under a secondment arrangement. Normally such an arrangement seeks to characterise the dispatching entity as the legal employer and the Chinese host entity as the economic employer. The PRC tax challenge is whether these intended objectives will be accepted by the Chinese tax authorities.
If the host entity is not considered as the economic employer or the "real" employer of the expatriates, extended stays of these expatriates in China will create an establishment under PRC domestic law or permanent establishment (PE) under PRC income tax treaties.
In the past, we have observed significant inconsistencies in how local Chinese tax authorities viewed this issue. The erratic positions taken by local tax officials called for the issuance of national guidelines to promote a uniform treatment, especially in the income tax treaty context.
In response to taxpayers' appeals, the SAT issued Guoshuifa [2010] No 75 (Circular 75) about two years ago, clarifying to some extent when a PE would be constituted in a cross-border secondment. While the circular puts across a clear message that a substance-over-form approach should be adopted in determining the real employer of a foreign secondee working in China, MNCs are still struggling with ambiguity in many cases as Circular 75 is limited to situations where the secondment is between the parent company and subsidiary.
We have learned that the SAT is evaluating a draft circular to provide further guidance on the subject after Circular 75. According to the draft circular, if the conditions below are met, expatriates assigned from an overseas company to a Chinese entity will be viewed as employees of the Chinese entity and thus no service PE of the overseas company would be created in China:
Performance reviews and appraisals for the secondees will be done by the Chinese company solely, and the Chinese company shall be responsible for the result and risk associated with the performance of the secondees.
The Chinese company shall determine the numbers, qualification requirements, compensation, and working places for these secondees.
The Chinese company shall not pay any services fees or other considerations to the overseas company in relation to the secondment.
The IIT returns for the secondees have been filed and the IIT liabilities have been settled.
In case the overseas company pays certain salary and wages, social security and other expenses to the secondees, the Chinese company shall reimburse the overseas company without any mark up.
Though the draft circular is still not finalised, it sheds light on the factors that the PRC local authorities will probably scrutinise to decide whether the Chinese host entity is the real employer of the secondees. MNCs should pay close attention to these points in designing secondments to mitigate PE risks in China.
Social security
The Chinese Social Insurance Law, which came into effect on July 1 2011, establishes the basic social insurance framework for employees in China with the aim of standardising social insurance programmes in mainland China. It covers both Chinese and foreign employees.
On September 6 2011, the Ministry of Human Resources and Social Security (MHRSS) issued the Interim Measures to guide foreign employees to participate in China's social insurance scheme, which:
describe the general implementation process:
specify the consequences of non-compliance; and
prescribe the national enforcement date.
On December 2 2011, the MHRSS released a circular to further clarify issues such as the effective date, the impact of totalisation agreements on foreign employees in China, and additional administrative details.
Since this announcement, some municipal governments, for example, Beijing, have circulated local guidelines and started to enforce the Chinese social security registration requirements for foreign employees.
These cities have also actively sought to collect social insurance from foreign employees and their Chinese employers. However, the roll-out is not happening across all of China. We have noticed that authorities in many cities such as Shanghai have not yet started the social insurance programme for foreign nationals or indicated when they will issue relevant local implementation guidelines.
Despite the inconsistent implementation status in various locations, the social insurance rules are here to stay. Therefore, MNCs must take this additional cost into account when planning to second foreign employees into China in the future.
Some may argue it is unfair for China to levy social security on foreign nationals. Many foreign nationals are required or prefer to participate in social security schemes in their home countries, and mandatory contributions into the Chinese social insurance programme would result in duplicative social security payments.
From a policy perspective, asking foreign employees to make social security contributions in the local country where they work is not unique in China. Many developed countries have similar requirements. However, compared with these developed countries, China has a limited totalisation network, which allows foreign employees to apply for exemptions should they wish to continue making contributions to their home country's social security system. Therefore, the problem of duplicative contribution in China could potentially be more serious.
China has only entered into partial totalisation agreements with Germany and South Korea, which do not provide exemptions on all types of social security payments in China. China is in talks with more than a dozen countries including the US, Japan and Russia. However, the conclusion of a totalisation agreement is expected to take years. Therefore, most foreign employees working in China will probably experience double social security costs in the foreseeable future.
Keeping on top of changes
The Chinese central government once again identified income redistribution as a priority to complete in the most recent 5YP. IIT reform is instrumental to help achieve this objective. The NPC has issued Order 48 to start this reform process, but there is a still a long way to go.
To make the IIT system more effective in regulating secondary income distribution, China should migrate towards a comprehensive IIT system with features such as consolidated income reporting, and joint IIT filing on family basis. The SAT is preparing for the migration by building an information system for a selected group of the population and plans to make the transition following a phased approach.
Besides the transformation of the IIT system, the Chinese government has issued other circulars that may have tax implications for foreign employees working in China and their employers within and outside China.
Two examples discussed in this article are the economic employer issue in a cross-border secondment arrangement and the duplicative social security contribution issue for foreign employees in China. MNCs should follow these regulatory developments closely and take these additional costs into account when making plans for their PRC operations.
Vincent Pang |
||
|
|
Tax partner KPMG China 8th Floor, Tower E2, Oriental Plaza 1 East Chang An Avenue Beijing 100738, China Tel: +86 10 (8508) 7516 Fax: + 86 (10) 8518 5111 Email: vincent.pang@kpmg.com Vincent Pang is the China country leader of the international executive services practice and has been involved in providing Chinese individual income tax-related services to both multinational companies and Chinese domestic companies since 1998. He started his career with professional accounting firms in Canada in 1991 and has experience in various disciplines including tax, auditing and consulting. Due to the complexity of the China environment, Vincent's experience in corporate tax, foreign exchange regulations and other investment regulatory areas allows him to provide more comprehensive and professional views when providing clients with mobility-related advice. |
Michelle Zhou |
||
|
|
Tax partner KPMG China 50th Floor, Plaza 66 1266 Nanjing West Road Shanghai 200040 China Tel: +86 (21) 2212 3458 Fax: +86 (21) 6288 1889 Email: michelle.zhou@kpmg.com Michelle Zhou joined the KPMG international executive services practice in Sydney in 2001, relocating to the firm in China in 2005. She is in Shanghai now. Michelle has more than 10 years of experience assisting multinational clients across a broad spectrum of industries (including consumer markets, industrial markets, financial services and information, communication and entertainment) on personal income tax compliance and advisory services. In particular, she has experience of Australian, China and US expatriation taxation and has served on small, medium and large accounts during her career at KPMG. Over the years, she has expanded and maintained a large portfolio of prestigious clients, as well as established an internal executive services team at KPMG Shanghai. Michelle is a regular speaker at public seminars on personal income tax related topics. She is also the author of numerous KPMG alerts on the latest trends and developments in personal income tax, the immigration and social security framework and regulatory updates in China. |