All material subject to strictly enforced copyright laws. © 2022 ITR is part of the Euromoney Institutional Investor PLC group.

India’s SK Mishra promises uniformity to bring taxpayer certainty


INDIA TAX FORUM: Stressing on the importance of a "non-adversarial" approach promised by India’s new finance minister, SK Mishra, (Joint Secretary, Foreign Tax Division & Competent Authority) acknowledged the growing tax litigation in India and promised a “uniformity in approach" among tax officials as one of the ways to bring about certainty for taxpayers.

Delivering a keynote address at International Tax Review’s India Tax Forum last week, Mishra outlined a dozen controversies in international taxation and transfer pricing and urged industry associations and professionals to provide inputs for possible solutions.


Transfer pricing disputes

Some of the key areas highlighted by Mishra in transfer pricing included determination of margins of the tested party (such as pass-through costs), non-availability of comparables and comparability issues, limitations on application of methods to emerging complex business transactions, risk adjustments, location savings, intangibles and financial transactions.

Risk adjustments

Specifically, on the issue of risk adjustments in transfer pricing, Mishra stated "risk is the by-product of functions and assets" and commented that there is an over-emphasis on the risk concept which is not warranted. He also stated that “risk adjustments” have become more of a routine adjustment in the transfer pricing reports filed with the tax department. But, in the absence of uniform standards/guidance, even competent authorities across the world are reluctant in allowing risk adjustments, Mishra clarified.

Intangibles and location savings

Elaborating on the disputes over intangibles, he expressed serious concerns on the absence of robust documentation to justify nature of "routine" IP development in India.

He stated that only “high-technology-driven IP” is given emphasis in transfer pricing, whereas detailed examination of other valuable IP created by businesses is not carried out. To buttress his argument, he cited the recent Apple-Samsung IP dispute relating to “shape” of a device as against the technology per se.

On the issue of location savings (which has impact on outsourcing to India), Mishra referred to a recent US court ruling attributing the savings to source country.

APA and safe harbour

Mishra expressed optimism about the new APA regime in India especially given the experience of the Indian competent authority in settling more than 100 transfer pricing related disputes through the mutual agreement procedure (MAP). "APA will be easy once MAP is concluded", said Mishra. He said that more than 140 MAP disputes have been settled by India in the last two years and majority of them were with the US. He also added that in only a couple of cases, the resolution failed.

Mishra however expressed doubts on effectiveness of the proposed safe harbour guidelines in India. He explained that the acceptance of a safe harbour range to the treaty partner will be crucial to avoid double taxation.

India and OECD

Mishra strongly defended India's reservations on OECD's commentary citing that OECD was not a body of experts but comprised of representatives of governments. "How can the view of 34 developed countries override the views of the Indian government?" questioned Mishra.

He advised that the government's reservation on certain portions of OECD commentary are already provided and one should consider these comments before taking a decision on any tax issue.

Bridging the trust deficit between taxpayers and officials

Dinesh Kanabar, deputy CEO, KPMG, raised concerns over the uncertainty and especially “individual officer-driven” inconsistent conclusions in tax matters. "Where does this leave to the taxpayer?” asked Kanabar.

Responding, Mishra strongly advocated an active contribution from all stakeholders for settling disputes. He stated that based on the inputs received, a suitable advisory would be issued to ensure a "uniformity in approach" among the tax officials on similar issues.

Co-published with

more across site & bottom lb ros

More from across our site

The Malawian government has targeted US gemstone miner Columbia Gem House, while Amgen has successfully consolidated two separate tax disputes with the Internal Revenue Service.
ITR's latest quarterly PDF is now live, leading on the rise of tax technology.
ITR is delighted to reveal all the shortlisted firms, teams, and practitioners for the 2022 Americas Tax Awards – winners to be announced on September 22
‘Care’ is the operative word as HMRC seeks to clamp down on transfer pricing breaches next year.
Tax directors tell ITR that the CRA’s clampdown on unpaid taxes on insurance premiums is causing uncertainty for businesses as they try to stay compliant.
HMRC has informed tax directors that it will impose automated assessments on online sellers with inaccurate VAT returns, in a bid to fight fraud.
UK businesses need to reset after the Upper Tribunal ruled against BlackRock over interest deductions it claimed on $4 billion in inter-company loans, say sources.
Hong Kong SAR’s incoming regime for foreign income exemptions could remove it from an EU tax watchlist but hand Singapore top spot in APAC.
Congress passed legislation with $52 billion in tax credits and other incentives on July 28 to boost production at US semiconductor companies.
This week the US Senate reached a historic compromise to secure a corporate minimum tax rate, while the UK is facing tax cuts no matter who succeeds Prime Minister Boris Johnson.
We use cookies to provide a personalized site experience.
By continuing to use & browse the site you agree to our Privacy Policy.
I agree