Spain: Spanish Supreme Court confirms PE interpretation in certain business restructurings

International Tax Review is part of Legal Benchmarking Limited, 1-2 Paris Garden, London, SE1 8ND

Copyright © Legal Benchmarking Limited and its affiliated companies 2025

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

Spain: Spanish Supreme Court confirms PE interpretation in certain business restructurings

ortega.jpg

bootello.jpg

Mario Ortega Calle


Alberto Ameneiro

On June 18 2014, the Spanish Supreme Court (SC) handed down a new decision on the definition of permanent establishment (PE) in business restructurings. In the case at hand, and before the restructuring process, SpainCo had functioned as a manufacturer and distributor of products in the Spanish and Portuguese market. After the restructuring, SpainCo started to operate as a limited risk service provider of manufacturing activities for a related party established in the UK (UKCo), and provided agency services, although it did not hold the authority to conclude sales contracts in the name of UKCo. Lastly, SpainCo also rented to UKCo some space for the storage of products.

In this scenario, the SC provided its interpretation of some of the PE principles that have been at the centre of much discussion, among which are the limits contained in article 5.3 of the OECD Model Convention. In particular, the SC addressed the contentious issue of when a PE can be deemed to exist under the dependent agent provision of the treaty, on a similar basis to that seen in the famous Roche Vitamins judgment, handed down in January 2012.

The Court began its analysis by examining each of the abovementioned commercial relationships between UKCo and SpainCo to determine whether any of them constituted a PE. For this purpose, the Court conducted the fixed place of business test and analysed whether or not the activities carried out by UKCo in the leased warehouse space were covered by the exception relating to the use of facilities to carry out preparatory or auxiliary activities.

After that, the sales promotion contract was also considered. The Court held that a "dependent agent PE" may exist because the limitations stipulated in the contract (such as the refusal to accept orders by SpainCo in the name of UKCo) had not been fulfilled in practice.

Indeed, the SC, while acknowledging that SpainCo could not be considered as a dependent agent of UKCo, ruled that SpainCo's activities in combination with UKCo's operation through a fixed place of business in Spain constituted a PE.

In light of all of the above, some observers would have thought that the relationship between SpainCo and UKCo could not constitute a PE. Nevertheless, the Court concluded that the leasing of some facilities, in combination with the sales promotion activities and the provision of operative services, constituted a PE.

As mentioned, this is the second decision handed down by the Spanish Supreme Court on PEs and business restructurings, with very similar (negative) conclusions for the taxpayer. This must be taken into serious consideration by those groups of companies with operations in Spain, in order to review their structures, especially those who have introduced modifications to their production value chain or are planning to do so in the future.

Mario Ortega Calle (mario.ortega.calle@garrigues.com), Vicente Bootello (vicente.bootello@garrigues.com) and Alberto Ameneiro (alberto.ameneiro@garrigues.com)

Garrigues – Taxand, Madrid

Website: www.garrigues.com

more across site & shared bottom lb ros

More from across our site

It should be easy for advisers to be transparent about costs, Brown Rudnick partner Matthew Sharp said in response to exclusive ITR in-house data
The sprawling legislation phases out Joe Biden-era green tax incentives for businesses; in other news, the UK will reportedly maintain its DST despite US pressure
New French legislation should create a more consistent legal environment for taxing gains from management packages, say Bruno Knadjian and Sylvain Piémont of Herbert Smith Freehills Kramer
The South Africa vs SC ruling may embolden the tax authority to take a more aggressive approach to TP assessments, an adviser tells ITR
Indirect tax professionals now rate compliance as a bigger obstacle than technology and automation; in other news, Italy approved a VAT cut on art sales
AI-powered tax agents are likely to be the next big development in tax technology, says Russell Gammon of Tax Systems
FTI Consulting’s EMEA head of employment tax and reward tells ITR about celebrating diversity in the profession, his love of musicals, and what makes tax cool
Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney and US President Donald Trump have agreed that the countries will look to conclude a deal by July 21, 2025
The firm’s lack of transparency regarding its tax leaks scandal should see the ban extended beyond June 30, senators Deborah O’Neill and Barbara Pocock tell ITR
Despite posing significant administrative hurdles, digital services taxes remain ‘the best way forward’ for emerging economies, says Neil Kelley, COO of Ascoria
Gift this article