All material subject to strictly enforced copyright laws. © 2022 ITR is part of the Euromoney Institutional Investor PLC group.

India: Ruling on seconded employees creating Service PE in India

nayak.jpg

aastha.jpg

Rajendra Nayak


Aastha Jain

Recently, the Delhi High Court (HC) ruled on the tax implications arising from the secondment of employees to India in a case involving Centrica India Offshore Private Limited (Taxpayer). Taxpayer is a company incorporated in India and is a subsidiary of a UK Company (UK Parent). UK Parent has two other subsidiaries in UK and Canada (collectively the Group Entities) engaged in the business of supplying gas and electricity to consumers across the UK/Canada. Group Entities outsourced their back office support functions to third party service providers (Vendors) in India. Group Entities engaged the Taxpayer under a service agreement (SA) to act as their local interface with Vendors and to ensure that Vendors complied with the quality guidelines. Further, under a secondment agreement, Group Entities seconded some employees (assignees) to assist the Taxpayer in fulfilling its role under the SA. The salary of the assignees was disbursed overseas by Group Entities and thereafter recovered from the Taxpayer. HC adjudicated on the issue of taxability of payments made by the Taxpayer to Group Entities.

The HC adopted a substance over form approach and held that Assignees continued to remain employees of Group Entities during the secondment period for the following reasons:

  • Taxpayer was not formally obliged to pay salary to Assignees. Further, Assignees could recover their salary only from Group Entities.

  • Taxpayer had no right to terminate legal employment of Assignees with the Group Entities.

  • Employment with Group Entities was permanent. Assignees were not 'released' from it and they were to return to the Group Entities after completion of the secondment.

  • The Assignees participated in retirement and social security plans of Group Entities.

  • Legal employment with Group Entities could not be disregarded as they were not conduits and the relationship was not a false facade.

Accordingly, payments made by the Taxpayer were for services rendered by the Group Entities through Assignees and it qualified as fees for technical services (FTS) under the India-UK treaty. Further, as the Assignees were imparting their technical expertise and 'making available' know-how to Taxpayer's employees for future consumption, payments qualified as 'fees for included services' under the India-Canada treaty. The HC accorded that the 'make available' condition in the UK treaty is distinct from the rest of the FTS provisions and need not be satisfied. Furthermore, the HC relied on the Indian Supreme Court's decision in the case of Morgan Stanley and held that Assignees constituted a Service PE for Group Entities in India.

In line with other decisions of Indian Courts, this decision endorses a substance over form approach for determination of employer, though HC has overlooked some established principles in favour of certain factors of employment. Further, HC's interpretation of the 'make available' clause under the UK treaty as well as its conclusion on Service PE could be prone to an alternative view. While the views adopted by the HC are debatable, litigation on account of it cannot be ruled out.

Rajendra Nayak (rajendra.nayak@in.ey.com) and Aastha Jain (aastha.jain@in.ey.com)

EY

Tel: +91 80 6727 5275

Website : www.ey.com/india

More from across our site

Japan reports a windfall from all types of taxes after the government revised its stimulus package. This could lead to greater corporate tax incentives for businesses.
Sources at Netflix, the European Commission and elsewhere consider the impact of incoming legislation to regulate tax advice in the EU – if it ever comes to pass.
This week European Commission officials consider legal loopholes to secure minimum corporate taxation, while Cisco and Microsoft shareholders call for tax transparency.
The fast-food company’s tax settlement with French authorities strengthens the need for businesses to review their TP arrangements and documentation.
The full ALP model will be adopted through a new TP regime, which is set to boost the country’s investments and tax certainty.
Tax professionals have called on the UK government to reconsider its online sales tax as it would affect the economy at the worst time.
Tax professionals have called on companies to act urgently to meet e-invoicing compliance targets as the EU plans to ramp up digitisation.
In the wake of India’s ambitious 25-year plan for economic growth, ITR has partnered with leading tax commentators to discuss what the future will look like for India and for the rest of the world.
But experts cast doubt on HMRC's data and believe COVID-19 would have increased the revenue shortfall.
EY’s plan to separate its auditing and consulting businesses might lessen scrutiny from global regulators, but the brand identity could suffer, say sources.
We use cookies to provide a personalized site experience.
By continuing to use & browse the site you agree to our Privacy Policy.
I agree