All material subject to strictly enforced copyright laws. © 2022 ITR is part of the Euromoney Institutional Investor PLC group.

UK to make Skandia ‘accounting’ changes; Netherlands says ruling does not apply to it

On February 10 2015 the Dutch Ministry of Finance announced that it will not apply the Skandia judgment, while the UK says businesses will have to make changes to comply with the judgment by 2016.

Skandia was a Swedish European Court of Justice (ECJ) case concerning VAT grouping rules which caused alarm for taxpayers when it appeared that changes may have to be made to rules throughout Europe leaving companies with bigger cross-border VAT bills.

While no changes to the UK’s grouping rules will be necessary, businesses will need to account for VAT on intra-group transactions from the start of next year.

“The implication of the Skandia judgment is that an overseas establishment of a UK-established entity is part of a separate taxable person if the overseas establishment is VAT-grouped in a member state that operates similar ‘establishment only’ grouping provisions to Sweden,” said a briefing note by UK tax authority HMRC.

The VAT grouping rules of the UK and the Netherlands differ from the Swedish rules, leading taxpayers in both states to hope that no changes would be necessary. The HMRC update goes on to detail the changes businesses will have to make to the way they treat services provided to companies within the same VAT group provided to such establishments.

- Services provided by the overseas VAT-grouped establishment to the UK establishment will normally be treated as supplies made in the UK under place of supply rules, and subject to the reverse charge if taxable

- Services provided by the UK establishment to the overseas VAT-grouped establishment will normally be treated as supplies made outside the UK under place of supply rules. Therefore they will need to be taken into account in ascertaining input tax credit for the UK establishment. If the supplies are reverse charge services, they should be reported on the trader’s European Sales Listing of such supplies

The implications are not as severe as initially feared, when a slight mistranslation of a key paragraph in the judgment caused huge confusion for taxpayers, particularly in the financial sector, which would have been hit particularly hard.

The Netherlands, in an informal communique published on Tuesday [February 10 2015] confirmed that it would not apply the Skandia judgment, meaning taxpayers will be able to continue their operations unchanged.

Most other EU member states, namely those with similar grouping rules to Sweden, have decided to implement the judgment in full.

“The reason the Ministry of Finance has decided not to apply the Skandia judgment is because the VAT group regime in the Netherlands is different to the VAT group regime in Sweden,” said an update authored by Meijburg & Co duo Irene Reiniers and Gert-Jan van Norden.

“[HMRC’s] position is largely the same as that of the Netherlands,” the note added. “However, unlike the Netherlands, HMRC takes account of the scope of the foreign VAT group.”

“If it is limited to local establishments of the VAT group, as is the case in Sweden, then the Skandia judgment will apply, according to the HMRC.”

There are doubts, however, as to whether the minor interpretive changes planned by the UK will be sufficient to appease the European Commission.

“There’s a chance that HMRC will be challenged over this change as it appears to be going against the generally accepted need for it to rely only on UK law rather than argue that EU law has direct effect,” said Robert Killington, technical secretary of the VAT practitioners group.

A challenge by the Commission could have implications for the Netherlands as well as the UK.

More from across our site

The state secretary told the French press that the country continues to oppose pillar two’s global minimum tax rate following an Ecofin meeting last week.
This week the Biden administration has run into opposition over a proposal for a federal gas tax holiday, while the European Parliament has approved a plan for an EU carbon border mechanism.
Businesses need to improve on data management to ensure tax departments become much more integrated, according to Microsoft’s chief digital officer at a KPMG event.
Businesses must ensure any alternative benchmark rate is included in their TP studies and approved by tax authorities, as Libor for the US ends in exactly a year.
Tax directors warn that a lack of adequate planning for VAT rule changes could leave businesses exposed to regulatory errors and costly fines.
Tax professionals have urged suppliers of goods from Great Britain to Northern Ireland to pause any plans to restructure their supply chains following the NI Protocol Bill.
Tax leaders say communication with peers is important for risk management, especially on how to approach regional authorities.
Advances in compliance tools in international markets and the digitalisation of global tax administrations are increasing in-house demand for technologists.
The US fast-food company has agreed to pay €1.25 billion to settle the French investigation into its transfer pricing arrangements over allegations of tax evasion.
HM Revenue and Customs said the UK pillar two legislation will be delayed until at least December 2023, while ITR reported on a secret Netflix settlement and an IMF study on VAT cuts.
We use cookies to provide a personalized site experience.
By continuing to use & browse the site you agree to our Privacy Policy.
I agree