Turkey: A milestone in Turkish tax law: European Court of Human Rights standards

International Tax Review is part of Legal Benchmarking Limited, 4 Bouverie Street, London, EC4Y 8AX

Copyright © Legal Benchmarking Limited and its affiliated companies 2025

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

Turkey: A milestone in Turkish tax law: European Court of Human Rights standards

gunduz.jpg

Zeki Gündüz

Turkish tax law is the subject of the most important court decision to be published in recent times. This decision is the first decision to approach European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) standards, which have been specified in literature and practised for some time now at the Constitutional Court level, and the first to make reference to ECHR property rights. The decision was made after the plaintiff, who lost his case in the courts of first and last instance, took a mistake related to the description of revenue type to the Constitutional Court by way of individual application. The facts of the case are as follows.

The plaintiff made contribution payments by way of the foundation affiliated with the plaintiff and established for the purpose of providing benefits to customers. These contribution payments were considered to be wages in the tax inspection made by tax inspectors. During the first and last instance court stage, the plaintiff claimed that the tax assessment against the "principle of tax legality" and also property rights can only be limited by law.

After the dismissal of the cases contesting the fines assessed, the plaintiff proceeded to the Constitutional Court on the grounds of violation of property rights and right to due process, by way of individual application.

The Constitutional Court's conclusions regarding the merits of the case were as follows.

  • Referring to Protocol Appendix 1 of the ECHR as well as article 35 of the Constitution implies that property rights are not absolute rights and can be limited if it is in the public interest.

  • Intervention is permissible when it is in the public interest, but should be in compliance with laws, and should be proportional. The scope of these matters should be identified and the lawfulness of this intervention should be investigated (these measures were established by referring to ECHR cases).

  • According to ruling cases of the ECHR, compliance with law is the first point which should be examined in an intervention aimed at property rights. Namely, the intervention should be made according to law and the rules related to domestic law should be accessible and predictable.

  • It was highlighted that article 35 of the Constitution is more protectionist than Protocol Appendix 1 of the ECHR, and takes a harder line regarding the principle of tax legality and taxation means statutorily. It was mentioned that accepting the regulations that do not have the force of law also fulfils the principle of legality by interpreting the principle of the limitation of property rights by law extensively is impossible in accordance with article 35 of the Constitution.

It is understood that ECHR standards are implemented effectively and in detail. This decision can be seen as the beginning of a new age and as an important milestone regarding freedom in terms of taxpayer rights under Turkish tax law. This decision should establish taxpayer confidence.

Zeki Gündüz (zeki.gunduz@tr.pwc.com)

PwC Turkey

Tel: + 90 212 326 6080

Website: www.pwc.com.tr

more across site & shared bottom lb ros

More from across our site

Countries which care about fair taxation of tech multinationals and equitable global distribution of wealth should back the UN’s tax framework, writes economist Abdelmalek Riad
The cuts disproportionately affected staff in certain positions, the report also found; in other news, MHA announced the €24m acquisition of Baker Tilly South East Europe
The plan aims to improve the efficiency, transparency, and effectiveness of direct tax administration in India
Meanwhile, South Africa’s finance minister has accepted a court decision on suspending a VAT increase and US President Donald Trump mulls a 100% tariff on foreign films
Jaime Carey speaks about the benefits of his tax background, DEI values, the use of AI for a smarter legal practice, and other priorities that will define his presidency
Historically low levels of attrition over consecutive years made a ‘difficult decision’ necessary, PwC has reportedly said
WTS Global is also vetting new potential member firms in Algeria, Cote D’Ivoire and Benin, Kelly Mgbor tells ITR in an exclusive interview
The scope of qualifying pillar two tax credits could reportedly be broadened; in other news, hundreds of IRS appeals staff are to resign
For many taxpayers, the prospect of long-term certainty that a bilateral APA offers can override concerns about time, cost and confidentiality
Levine, who served under the Joe Biden administration, led the US’s negotiations on the OECD’s two-pillar solution
Gift this article