All material subject to strictly enforced copyright laws. © 2022 ITR is part of the Euromoney Institutional Investor PLC group.

Germany: Change-in-ownership rules referred to the Federal Constitutional Court (again)

intl-updates-small.jpg
Linn

Alexander Linn

Earlier this year (see July update), Germany's Federal Constitutional Court held that the German change-in-ownership rules relating to loss carry-forwards partially infringe the German Constitution, and must be amended with retroactive effect. The judgment, however, only dealt with transfers of more than 25% and up to 50% of the shares in a company that has loss carry-forwards. According to the rules, such transfers result in a pro rata forfeiture of the tax loss and interest carry forwards, while a transfer of more than 50% of the shares results in a complete forfeiture of all available carry-forwards.

While the court has held that the rules are unconstitutional for transfers between 25% and 50%, the court did not provide an opinion on the constitutionality of the rule resulting in a full forfeiture of loss carry-forwards following a transfer of more than 50% of the shares. Already by that time, a separate procedure on transfers of more than 50% was pending before the Federal Tax Court. Before that case was decided by the Federal Tax Court, however, the Fiscal Court of Hamburg (case 2 K 245/17) now has referred a separate case to the Constitutional Court.

The details of the case have not yet been published. In any case, the German Federal Constitutional Court will now have to decide on the commercially much more important element of the rule. Experience has proven that only a limited number of transactions resulted in a partial forfeiture of loss carry-forwards following a transfer between 25% and 50% of the shares (especially since all transfers to the same purchaser within a five-year period are added up when testing the rule). The majority of cases at stake involved transfers of more than 50% of the shares, resulting in a full forfeiture of the loss carry-forwards. On the one hand, the full forfeiture of loss carry-forwards is a more severe consequence than a partial forfeiture, so it could be argued that the potential infringement of the Constitution is even more obvious for transfers between 25% and 50%. On the other hand, one main argument for the unconstitutionality used by the Constitutional Court when deciding on the rule for partial loss forfeitures was the lack of control gained over the loss carry-forwards by the purchaser. While the transfer of a majority shareholding involves some element of control over the loss carry-forwards of the entity, such control cannot be assumed upon a transfer between 25% and 50%. If this difference will be decisive for the Constitutional Court when deciding on this new case remains to be seen.

Taxpayers should ensure that tax assessment notices for the 2008-2015 period that are not considered preliminary, pending a decision of the Constitutional Court, should be kept open in order to be able to benefit from a potentially favourable court decision.

Alexander Linn (allinn@deloitte.de)

Deloitte

Tel: +49 89 29036 8558

Website: www.deloitte.de

More from across our site

ITR is delighted to reveal all the shortlisted firms, teams and practitioners – winners will be announced on August 25
Multinational enterprises run the risk of hefty penalties if the company in question fails to register for VAT when providing electronic services in South Africa.
Tax directors have urged companies to ensure they have robust tax risk management controls when outsourcing tax functions.
Japan reports a windfall from all types of taxes after the government revised its stimulus package. This could lead to greater corporate tax incentives for businesses.
Sources at Netflix, the European Commission and elsewhere consider the impact of incoming legislation to regulate tax advice in the EU – if it ever comes to pass.
This week European Commission officials consider legal loopholes to secure minimum corporate taxation, while Cisco and Microsoft shareholders call for tax transparency.
The fast-food company’s tax settlement with French authorities strengthens the need for businesses to review their TP arrangements and documentation.
The full ALP model will be adopted through a new TP regime, which is set to boost the country’s investments and tax certainty.
Tax professionals have called on the UK government to reconsider its online sales tax as it would affect the economy at the worst time.
Tax professionals have called on companies to act urgently to meet e-invoicing compliance targets as the EU plans to ramp up digitisation.
We use cookies to provide a personalized site experience.
By continuing to use & browse the site you agree to our Privacy Policy.
I agree