US Inbound: Tax Court decision raises attorney-client privilege questions

International Tax Review is part of Legal Benchmarking Limited, 1-2 Paris Garden, London, SE1 8ND

Copyright © Legal Benchmarking Limited and its affiliated companies 2025

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

US Inbound: Tax Court decision raises attorney-client privilege questions

fuller.jpg

forst.jpg

Jim Fuller


David Forst

The IRS made a transfer pricing adjustment in its examination of Eaton Corporation. As it often does in transfer pricing disputes, the IRS also asserted that a transfer pricing penalty was due. Eaton disputes the adjustment and the penalty. The case is docketed in the US Tax Court. In a surprising development, the court held that in asserting the standard reasonable-cause defence to the penalty, Eaton had put at issue material otherwise protected by attorney-client privilege that would reveal the expertise and knowledge and state of mind of those who acted on Eaton's behalf regarding its transfer pricing. The court stated that a reasonable cause/good faith defence under section 6664(c) is dependent upon a review of all the pertinent facts and circumstances, and that Eaton's communications with its attorneys and tax practitioners may be the only probative evidence of the state of mind or knowledge of the persons who acted on Eaton's behalf.

Accordingly, the court held that Eaton had waived attorney-client privilege and work-product protections regarding the documents in dispute.

This does not seem appropriate: Congress cannot have intended in enacting the penalty rules that attorney-client privilege must be waived as the price of asserting that a penalty should not apply. The attorney-client privilege is a common law privilege that is deeply ingrained in the US legal system.

While there may or may not be a connection with Eaton, Illinois Tool Works' subsequently conceded that in its pending Tax Court case the reasonable cause defence to penalties had no application. Illinois Tool Works also involves international tax issues, although not transfer pricing.

Inbound taxpayers (and other taxpayers) should be guided by this development in determining their transfer pricing and developing their transfer pricing documentation, as well as in considering other tax matters. This Tax Court holding also likely will increase the IRS's interest in asserting penalties in future transfer pricing and other tax disputes.

Jim Fuller (jpfuller@fenwick.com) andDavid Forst (dforst@fenwick.com)

Fenwick & West

Tel: +1 650 335 7205; +1 650 335 7274

Website: www.fenwick.com

more across site & shared bottom lb ros

More from across our site

Tax auditors themselves had not been aware of the new TP ‘transaction matrix’ requirements, ITR hears as five German partners share their client experiences
Its features include a built-in AI assistant as well as expert insights and commentary from Deloitte specialists
AI is rapidly finding its way into tax advisory services. But how can AI be deployed responsibly, reliably, and in compliance with legal standards?
Specified taxpayers will have to apply a 19% VAT rate on services offered by third parties through their platforms; in other news, Donald Trump imposed 30% South African tariffs
A ‘quiet revolution’ in HMRC’s compliance strategy has caused Adam Craggs to rethink how to advise clients, he tells ITR
If the Reform leader becomes UK prime minister then he may follow the direction of the US in at least one significant way
Trump declared a new national emergency in issuing the order; in other news, Grant Thornton Germany is up for sale and the subject of interest from both its UK and US counterparts
The judgment, which saw Denmark's Supreme Court rely on OECD TP guidance, sets aside more than 15 years of consistent administrative practice, experts have told ITR
Belgium’s new coalition government has gone ahead with a new exit tax regime that could land it in the courts
Brazil’s government has not officially framed the bill as a countermeasure amid trade tensions with the US, but the move is being considered as part of Brazil’s strategic response, one expert tells ITR
Gift this article