Hong Kong: Courts rule on taxability of property investments

International Tax Review is part of Legal Benchmarking Limited, 1-2 Paris Garden, London, SE1 8ND

Copyright © Legal Benchmarking Limited and its affiliated companies 2026

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement


Hong Kong: Courts rule on taxability of property investments

intl-updates-small.jpg
lu-lewis.jpg

ng.jpg

Lewis Lu

Curtis Ng

Many readers will be familiar with the famous conclusion of Justice Rowlatt in Cape Brandy Syndicate v IRC, [1921] 12 TC 358 that: "In a taxing act, one merely has to look at what is clearly said. There is no room for any intendment. There is no equity about a tax." And Lord Tomlin's statement in the Duke of Westminster case (Duke of Westminster v IRC, 19 TC 490) that: "This so-called doctrine of "the substance" seems to me to be nothing more than an attempt to make a man pay notwithstanding that he has so ordered his affairs that the amount of tax sought from him is not legally claimable." This approach to interpreting tax law has recently been under threat from the 'tax fairness' agenda.

So it was refreshing to the see Hong Kong courts uphold the Inland Revenue Department's (IRD's) request to charge HK$26.8 million ($3.4 million) of tax when it is not clear from the stated facts that any commercial profit arose to the taxpayer group (Commissioner of Inland Revenue v Perfekta Enterprises Limited (HCIA 1/2016)). The taxpayer (Perfekta) was a manufacturer who had acquired land for industrial use in the 1960s and 1970s. In 1994, it ceased its manufacturing activities. In preparation for this it sought permission to vary the terms of the lease and entered into an agreement with a developer in respect of which it received an initial payment of HK$165 million. The Hong Kong Court of First Instance found that this marked a change of intention and that the income received should be taxable as trading profit. The court also denied any deduction for the value of the land on the grounds that deductions were only allowed "to the extent to which they are incurred during the basis period". This appears to cast further doubt on the applicability of the Sharkey v Werner, 36 TC 275, principle in Hong Kong.

The court placed heavy emphasis on the legal documents surrounding the transaction. Although the development activity had taken place in a subsidiary, a reference in the board minutes to this being "for internal purposes" and a clause voiding the transfer of land if the subsidiary and the developer did not sign a new development agreement allowed the courts to find that the taxpayer retained an interest in the development. The board minutes and the witness statements conflated the activities of the company and the group, which has allowed the court to follow suit.

The board of review had held that the land was re-invested into the subsidiary and that the initial payment was an equalisation payment. The court refused to endorse this view in the absence of any explicit statement of this intent in the documents.

So, despite all the talk of 'tax fairness', precision in the drafting of legal documents and the ordering of transactions remains critical. It seems clear that the taxpayer could have ordered its affairs to ensure that no tax was payable. It has sought leave to appeal, but for now it remains the case that there is no equity about a tax.

Lewis Lu (lewis.lu@kpmg.com) and Curtis Ng (curtis.ng@kpmg.com)

KPMG China

Tel: +86 (21) 2212 3421

Website: www.kpmg.com/cn

more across site & shared bottom lb ros

More from across our site

KPMG's UK head of tax policy discusses what the Budget means for businesses, whether pillar two has survived its US carve-out, and why taxing wealth could become the next global debate
The appointments of Thomas Gaughan and Daniel Martinez further signal that the private client advisory market is booming
The rebrand, which MHA said would make its connection to the Baker Tilly network ‘clear’, will take effect in February
The stars of Weil’s heavyweight tax practices are up for grabs, but recruiting firms will need to be patient to secure a package deal
Meta has overtaken Amazon as the ‘Silicon Six’ business with the worst tax conduct, according to the Fair Tax Foundation
Awards
It was also a memorable night for Baker McKenzie and its associated firms, after picking up 19 awards, including the coveted Asia-Pacific Tax Law Firm of the Year
Stocche Forbes Advogados, Utumi Advogados and Lobo de Rizzo Advogados have reached Tier 2 as competition intensifies in the region’s largest tax market
Ben Webster’s arrival represents a significant expansion of Withers’ London tax litigation practice, as the private client firm eyes further international growth
The combination swiftly builds on RSM’s addition of a new Lithuanian firm to its international network, signalling a European build-out
Tax teams must look beyond pillar two’s headline rules as R&D incentives and the US side-by-side deal create new strategic choices for multinationals, says Marta Pankiv of Tricentis
Gift this article