Rajendra Nayak Ganesh Pai The Mumbai Tribunal in the case of Airlines Rotables Ltd, UK, the taxpayer, adjudicated on the issue of whether maintenance of stock of goods, belonging to the taxpayer, by its Indian customer results in the taxpayer having a permanent establishment (PE) in India, under the India UK tax treaty. The taxpayer a UK company, entered into an agreement with an Indian aircraft operator, the customer, for providing certain support services for the customer's aircraft. The agreement required the taxpayer to repair the component when it became operationally unserviceable and to replace the component during the interim period. To ensure adequate availability of the components, the taxpayer maintained stock of such replacement components at the operational bases of the customer in India, as well as in the UK at the taxpayer's main depot. The customer held the component stock only as a bailee (delivery of goods without transfer of ownership) at all times. The issue in dispute was whether the maintenance of the component stock constitutes a PE of the taxpayer in India under the UK treaty. Under the UK Treaty, a PE can be constituted, among other things, through a fixed place of business where the business of the foreign enterprise is wholly or partly carried on (Basic Rule) or through a dependent agent acting on behalf of the foreign enterprise in India, maintaining a stock of goods from which he regularly delivers on behalf of the foreign enterprise (Agency Rule).
August 31 2010