Deal making in the M&A market is at a standstill until there is more business certainty. A few megadeals were announced in Q1 2020 and Dealogic reports showed that Q1 had the lowest volume of deal-making activity since 2013. Tax directors across businesses have noticed M&A activity is moving at a much slower pace at this stage of the pandemic.
Despite the global slowdown in M&A activity in the short-term, taxpayers are bullish about businesses continuing deal making in 2020 because they have long-term liquidity and M&A activity was strong in countries such as the Netherlands and Australia before the pandemic.
“The parties still want to do the deal, but they want to understand what the impact will be and commit themselves carefully,” said one head of tax at a multinational retail company.
Advisors said that an increased focus on tax risk from buyers and lenders across industries is an early M&A-related tax trend in 2020. Buyers are more conservative of tax risks in their investments following significant business disruptions, and many businesses are inquiring about insurance for debt restructuring and distressed sales to protect value.
“For example, purchasers have sought to insure tax risk where previously they might have been more bullish because if the risk crystallised then the quantum would be too damaging,” said Richard Taylor-Whiteway, head of tax at Brockwell Capital. “We’re also seeing this from the lender side, where they are pushing for high quantum risks to be insured in order to get comfortable with providing acquisition finance.”
Some businesses have walked away from deals in 2020 because the value of the acquisition fell significantly following disaster prevention and recovery measures undertaken by the target company in March and April amid the pandemic.
“Some purchasers have exercised the material adverse change (MAC) clause as a result of coronavirus where a deal is already signed, but not completed,” added Taylor-Whiteway.
A material adverse change clause gives the buyer the right to walk away from the acquisition before closing if circumstances significantly reduce the value of a target company. This clause has led to some big deals failing in early 2020.
Discontinuing deals under COVID-19 conditions
There are examples of deals folding because the target company could not fulfil part of the takeover agreement while mitigating COVID-19-related business disruptions. Some buyers are utilising their right to walk away to renegotiate their original deal knowing there may be a lower price point.
A deal for Victoria’s Secret is coming undone because the business furloughed staff, cut executive salaries, and missed its April rent payments. A $5 billion deal between Boeing and Embraer was discontinued too. Boeing claimed Embraer had not met some aspects of the original agreement and refused to move forward with it.
“It sounds more like they [Boeing] need cash now, so they’re finding an excuse to not go ahead,” said one head of tax at an automation company. “Embraer is going to court for compensation.”
Advisors expect more businesses to either scrap or adjust M&A activity in the short-term while uncertainty is high because of COVID-19 concerns.
However, in the long-term, large businesses will look more favourably at the M&A market because deal making is cheaper after share price drops and business reorganisations to navigate the crisis. Some taxpayers are reorganising to focus on key production points in their supply chain and adjust operations toward supporting those main businesses.
Taxpayers expect to see more deal making in Q3
Large taxpayers are just looking for some market certainty – either when the economic situation cannot get any worse or there is a clear route to returning to a relatively normal business environment – before advancing with more deals this year.
Taxpayers expect some easing on lockdowns across countries where they have operations that are key to their supply chains to help advance deals that slowed down in 2020.
“The crisis will lead to some reorganisations, there are opportunities for new acquisitions in my view,” said the head of tax at the automation company. “Specifically, when they [businesses] are trying to join forces to survive the fallout from the whole crisis.”
Tax risk management was a bigger concern for buyers in global deal making during the first few months of 2020, which promoted the use of corporate tax insurance as a requirement to protect the value of a deal. Now, buyers who have stalled or cancelled their deals are taking the opportunity to re-evaluate investment models that predate the pandemic to renegotiate on price.
The M&A market may have widely slowed down, but it has not stopped because of the pandemic and more deal making is expected in Q3 if business certainty improves.