Court springs PE debate back into life

October 19 2011

In two separate judgments Delhi High Court ruled on the tax liability of Rolls Royce and Rolls Royce Singapore due to their operations in India. Common issue in both the matters was exposure to a permanent establishment (PE) in India and quantum of profits to be attributed to operations carried out by the PE in India. Sunil Jain of J Sagar & Associates investigates.

Unlock this content.

The content you are trying to view is exclusive to our subscribers.

To unlock this content:

Take a Free Trial or Login

Topics

Feature India Quarterly November 2011-January 2012 (September 2011)

more across site & shared bottom lb ros

More from across our site

Direct Tax

MHA records 12% revenue rise a year on from London IPO

The UK advisory firm has seen its global revenues expand by £27.2m following its listing and acquisition of Baker Tilly South-East Europe

Sam Sholli, July 21 2026

Direct Tax

KPMG Australia’s new CEO vows to improve culture following scandal

Tax-trained John Sams, previously the firm’s CFO and COO, was appointed after a rigorous process, KPMG said

Tom Baker, July 21 2026

Transfer Pricing

Pay attention to tax when taking IP across borders in Africa

From Mauritius substance rules to Kenyan SEP tax and South African anti-avoidance measures, businesses must navigate growing scrutiny of cross-border IP structures in Africa

The tax team at Bowmans, July 21 2026

Direct Tax

Beyond the headlines: Lessons from pillar two’s first and farcical filing deadline

ITR spoke to multinationals, advisers and software providers about a June 30 deadline defined by faulty portals, high compliance costs and hard lessons

Tom Baker, July 20 2026

Direct Tax

Compliance frustration onerous pillar two

A taxing week: Pillar two revenue shortfall a gut-punch for MNEs

After years of onerous pillar two prep, businesses will be galled in seeing tax revenues outweighed by compliance costs

Tom Baker, July 17 2026

Direct Tax

The EY US dispute: why secondment structures need fresh Indian review

Tax advisers should revisit India secondment arrangements after the EY US ruling strengthened the Centrica precedent and raised fresh withholding concerns

Aditi Goyal, July 16 2026

Direct Tax

Pillar two revenues lower than anticipated, OECD admits

Despite the shortfall, effective tax rates of multinationals have seen a ‘statistically significant rise’

Sam Sholli, July 15 2026

Direct Tax

Behind the hire: Stuart Alter on developing Milbank’s fund formation practice

After joining Milbank from Akin Gump, the fund tax specialist discusses sponsor demand, practice building, and the tax challenges facing asset managers

Tom Baker, July 15 2026

Direct Tax

KPMG Australia set to axe hundreds of jobs amid scandal: AFR

Partner payouts could also be reduced by a fifth, it has been reported

Sam Sholli, July 14 2026

Direct Tax

US trade body criticises ‘inconsistent’ EU pillar two exemption

There is no logical reason not to extend an exemption from EU CFC rules to multinationals headquartered in side-by-side jurisdictions, USCIB said

Sam Sholli, July 14 2026