Germany: EGC rules German exception to change-in-ownership rule qualifies as unlawful state aid

International Tax Review is part of Legal Benchmarking Limited, 1-2 Paris Garden, London, SE1 8ND

Copyright © Legal Benchmarking Limited and its affiliated companies 2025

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

Germany: EGC rules German exception to change-in-ownership rule qualifies as unlawful state aid

Linn
Braun

Alexander Linn

Thorsten Braun

On February 4 2016, the European General Court (EGC) issued a decision upholding the 2011 decision of the European Commission that the 'restructuring exception' in Germany's rules relating to the carryforward of tax losses by companies in financial difficulties constituted illegal state aid under EU law.

Under the change-in-ownership rules, a direct or indirect share transfer of more than 25% and up to 50% (or of more than 50%) of the shares in a company that has loss carryforwards results in a pro rata (or full) forfeiture of the carryforwards. One of the few exceptions to this rule was the restructuring exception, which granted relief for built-in gains and for certain acquisitions of businesses that are in distress, subject to a number of conditions.

The European Commission regarded the relief for distressed businesses as unlawful state aid and requested the German Government not to apply the rule in existing and open cases. The government objected but lost its case before the EGC for procedural reasons. The case against the European Commission then was brought to the EGC by several taxpayers in separate cases of which two have now been decided. Both taxpayers had obtained binding rulings from the German tax authorities confirming their entitlement to future loss offsets despite harmful changes in ownership. The rulings were withdrawn after the European Commission made its request to the German government.

The EGC held that the general rule requires the forfeiture of loss relief on a change-in-ownership and the exception confers a selective advantage on the beneficiary without regard to individual circumstances and, therefore, prefers certain (distressed) companies over their competitors. The court rejected the argument that the change-in-ownership provisions were intended to prevent the abusive practice of buying tax loss companies, whereas the exception was designed to assist distressed companies, because a rescue attempt was not the only non-abusive share acquisition in a loss-making company. The decision of the EGC was appealed by at least one of the taxpayers so that the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) will have the final word on the matter (case ref. C-203/16 P).

Alexander Linn (allinn@deloitte.de) and Thorsten Braun (tbraun@deloitte.de)

Deloitte

Tel: +49 89 29036 8558 and +49 69 75695 6444

Website: www.deloitte.de

more across site & shared bottom lb ros

More from across our site

DLA Piper’s co-head of tax for the US and Latin America tells ITR about her fervent belief in equal access to the law, loving yoga, and paternal inspirations
Tax expert Craig Hillier agrees with the comparison of pillar two to using a sledgehammer to crack a nut
The amount is reported to be up 57% from the £5.6bn that the UK tax agency believes was underpaid in the previous year
The US president also unveiled a new 50% levy on copper imports; in other news, a UK wealth tax proposal has been criticised by the Institute for Fiscal Studies
Wim Wuyts, who had been head of the specialist tax network since 2017, is moving on to a new role with WTS’s Belgian member firm
MNEs are increasingly using algorithmic tools in TP. Sahasranshu Dash argues that data ethics should therefore plug directly into the TP design process
The Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales also queried whether HMRC resources could be better spent scrutinising larger entities
Grant Thornton’s Austria tax head likens his practice to an escape room, shares his football coaching ambitions, and explains why tax is cool
Awards
ITR is delighted to reveal all the shortlisted nominees for the 2025 EMEA Tax Awards
Awards
ITR is delighted to reveal all the shortlisted nominees for the 2025 Asia-Pacific Tax Awards
Gift this article