New Zealand: Court of Appeal considers double tax relief article in DTA with China

International Tax Review is part of Legal Benchmarking Limited, 1-2 Paris Garden, London, SE1 8ND

Copyright © Legal Benchmarking Limited and its affiliated companies 2025

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

New Zealand: Court of Appeal considers double tax relief article in DTA with China

Sponsored by

sponsored-firms-russel-mcveagh.png
intl-updates

The New Zealand Court of Appeal has overturned a High Court decision allowing a New Zealand taxpayer foreign tax credits for tax spared (under Chinese law) to Chinese companies treated as controlled foreign companies under New Zealand's CFC rules.

The New Zealand Court of Appeal has overturned a High Court decision allowing a New Zealand taxpayer foreign tax credits (FTCs) for tax spared (under Chinese law) to Chinese companies treated as controlled foreign companies (CFCs) under New Zealand's CFC rules.

Background

Ms Lin (a New Zealand tax resident) was attributed, under New Zealand's CFC rules, a share of the income derived by certain Chinese companies in which she held interests. The New Zealand Inland Revenue had allowed Ms Lin FTCs for Chinese tax actually paid by the CFCs under a provision of New Zealand law allowing a credit, for tax paid by the CFC, against New Zealand tax payable on attributed CFC income. However, Inland Revenue denied her claim for FTCs for Chinese tax spared under Chinese law (tax spared).

Ms Lin successfully challenged Inland Revenue's FTC denial in the High Court. (See 'New Zealand: High Court considers DTA tax sparing provisions' in the July 2017 edition of International Tax Review for our summary of the High Court proceedings.) Inland Revenue appealed the High Court decision to the Court of Appeal.

Court of Appeal decision

The question was whether the Chinese tax spared to the CFCs was "Chinese tax paid [which was deemed to include the tax spared]… in respect of income derived by a resident of New Zealand from sources in the People's Republic of China". The interpretation accepted by the High Court was that because the income of the CFC (on which Chinese tax was paid) was attributed to Ms Lin under New Zealand's CFC rules, tax paid by the CFC was tax paid 'in respect of' the income derived by Ms Lin. That is, it was enough that the tax was payable by the CFC on income that was attributed to Ms Lin under New Zealand's CFC rules.

The High Court had also relied on, by analogy, the OECD commentary relating to partnerships on the basis New Zealand's CFC regime effectively treats CFCs as fiscally transparent. The Court of Appeal dismissed that approach as involving a "largely diversionary focus on extraneous materials and analogies with other legal structures, at the expense of a close textual analysis" (Commissioner of Inland Revenue v Lin [2018] NZCA 38, at [23]). Instead, the Court of Appeal considered that the meaning of Article 23 was clear and (in the absence of any contrary intention) only allows credits for taxes actually payable (or deemed payable, in the case of tax spared) by the New Zealand tax resident.

The Court of Appeal concluded that the 'income' of the CFC was not 'derived' by Ms Lin in China, and the tax paid or spared to the CFC was not payable, paid by or spared to Ms Lin. Rather, the tax imposed, on two different persons, is 'in respect of' two different income streams.

Wider implications

Previously, the New Zealand Court of Appeal (in a precedent applied by the High Court in the Lin case, but not referred to in the Court of Appeal judgment) had held that DTAs had an 'international currency' and that their language 'should be construed on broad principles of general acceptation and having appropriate regard to the commentary and any travaux preparatoires' (Commissioner of Inland Revenue v JFP Energy [1990] 3 NZLR 536 at 540.) The Court of Appeal in Lin has opted for a more literal approach, opining that DTAs are to be interpreted according to the same principles as apply to private contractual instruments and that each DTA 'must be construed discretely, in accordance with its own particular terms' (At [20]). In this respect, the court's decision could have implications going beyond the particular issue concerning the scope of Article 23 of the DTA with China.

brown.jpg
woolley.jpg

Brendan

Brown

Matt

Woolley

Brendan Brown (brendan.brown@russellmcveagh.com) and Matt Woolley (matt.woolley@russellmcveagh.com)

Russell McVeagh

Tel: +64 4 819 7748 and +64 4 819 7345

Website: www.russellmcveagh.com

more across site & shared bottom lb ros

More from across our site

Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney and US President Donald Trump have agreed that the countries will look to conclude a deal by July 21, 2025
The firm’s lack of transparency regarding its tax leaks scandal should see the ban extended beyond June 30, senators Deborah O’Neill and Barbara Pocock tell ITR
Despite posing significant administrative hurdles, digital services taxes remain ‘the best way forward’ for emerging economies, says Neil Kelley, COO of Ascoria
A ‘joint understanding’ among G7 countries that ‘defends American interests’ is set to be announced, Scott Bessent claimed
The ‘big four’ firm’s inaugural annual report unveiled a sharp drop in profits for 2024; in other news, Baker McKenzie and Perkins Coie expanded their US tax benches
Representatives from the two countries focused on TP as they met this week to evaluate progress under a previously signed agreement – it is understood
The UK accountancy firm’s transfer pricing lead tells ITR about his expat lifestyle, taking risks, and what makes tax cool
Dolphin Drilling intends to discuss the final liability amount and manner of settlement with HM Revenue and Customs
Winning the case against the 20% VAT imposition was always going to be an uphill challenge for the claimants, UK tax advisers argue
A ‘paradigm shift’ in Chile’s tax enforcement requires compliance architecture built on proactive governance, strategic documentation and active monitoring of judicial developments
Gift this article