US Treasury comes under fire over OECD tax talks
International Tax Review is part of Legal Benchmarking Limited, 4 Bouverie Street, London, EC4Y 8AX
Copyright © Legal Benchmarking Limited and its affiliated companies 2024

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

US Treasury comes under fire over OECD tax talks

Congress will make or break Biden’s tax plan

US lawmakers criticised the OECD plans for a minimum corporate tax rate and new taxing rights under the two-pillar solution, with one saying they make ‘no sense’.

The House Ways & Means Committee singled out the OECD proposals to reform international tax rules in a hearing last week on July 19, slamming the US Treasury negotiations in particular.

Michael Plowgian, deputy assistant secretary for international tax affairs at the Treasury, faced tough questions from the committee about the undertaxed payments rule (UTPR).

Ways & Means Committee Chairman Jason Smith asked: “Was Congress consulted prior to Treasury agreeing to a UTPR surtax that would allow foreign governments to tax the US operations of US companies?”

In response, Plowgian said the Treasury did receive input from Congress on the UTPR during the negotiations.

But Smith said he disagreed: “I have followed this issue very closely over the past three years, and I don’t think that’s the case. I know that Treasury has never consulted with Republican members prior to a decision.”

The UTPR is a key part of the global anti-base erosion rules to establish a global minimum corporate tax system under the two-pillar solution. Even though the US has minimum corporate tax rates in place, the country has not enacted pillar two so far.

Tax surrender

The hearing did not get any easier for Plowgian as Pennsylvania Representative Mike Kelly, who chairs the Ways & Means Sub-committee on Tax, criticised the agreement for its cost to the US.

“It’s $120 billion in US tax revenues to foreign countries. This makes absolutely no sense,” said Kelly.

The Republican congressman went on to claim that the OECD tax work is effectively controlled by Europe.

“Europe controls one third of the seats on the Steering Committee, and the broader Inclusive Framework includes over 30 tiny former European colonies,” said Kelly.

“The bottom line is the deck is stacked against America at the OECD,” he argued. “That is why it has never made sense for Treasury to negotiate behind closed doors with a group of 140 nations on a ‘one-country, one-vote’ basis.”

Plowgian stressed that pillar two is about levelling the playing field for US companies, but this did not convince Republicans on the committee.

Georgia Representative Drew Ferguson said: “We are not about levelling the playing field with the rest of the world. We’re about being number one day in and day out.

“We’re either going to be number one in the world or we’re not,” he added.

Many tax experts are increasingly concerned that US politics could derail the OECD’s efforts to secure a multilateral agreement on tax reform. If the two-pillar solution fails, US companies may have to live with the threat of unilateral taxes in Europe and elsewhere.

The hearing came at a critical time for the OECD’s work on pillar one, the other part of the solution. The Paris-based organisation hopes to settle the technical aspects of new taxing rights and profit allocation rules to finalise an agreement by the end of the year.

more across site & bottom lb ros

More from across our site

Sharma, managing director for A&M in the United Arab Emirates, tells ITR about intense time pressures, mimicking Jurgen Klopp and what makes tax cool
AI will speed up some of the most laborious TP processes without making human input redundant, argues Hank Moonen, CEO of TaxModel
Firms with a broad geographic reach are more likely to win work, especially from global companies with high turnovers, according to survey data of nearly 29,000 corporate counsel
Australian businessman Gordon Merchant used EY’s advice to offset an A$85 million capital gain, according to the Federal Court
Griggs has been drafted in ahead of schedule as the incumbent Tim Ryan departs for Citigroup; while the Netherlands plans to scrap a 15% share buyback tax
Authorities must ensure that Russian firms do not use transfer pricing schemes to increase profits made from oil sold in different markets, advocacy organisations have argued
Fallet, a partner at law firm Mauger Muniz Advogados in Brazil, tells ITR about his passion for tax law, the leaders who inspired him, and what makes tax cool
The former chief operating officer will assume the role on July 1
Ahead of next week's Indirect Tax Forum in London, ITR spoke with Christian Van Der Valk of Sovos about how different governments and companies are embracing e-invoicing
Konrad Jeczewski has alleged he was threatened with negative reviews before being made redundant by EY Australia
Gift this article