International Tax Review is part of the Delinian Group, Delinian Limited, 8 Bouverie Street, London, EC4Y 8AX, Registered in England & Wales, Company number 00954730
Copyright © Delinian Limited and its affiliated companies 2023

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

Davos panel exposes disagreements on two-pillar tax reform

Tax panel, Davos, Jan 2023.PNG
Speakers on the 'Is Global Tax Reform Stalling?' panel

The panel, the only one dedicated to tax at the World Economic Forum, comprised government ministers and other officials.

Speakers on the only panel dedicated to tax at last week’s World Economic Forum described the global agreement on international tax reform, commonly known as BEPS 2.0, as a step in the right direction but didn’t hold back in their criticism of the deal.

The panel, comprising government ministers and other officials, was hosted live in Davos, Switzerland, on Thursday, January 19.

Mathias Cormann, secretary general of the OECD, which facilitated the negotiations, was forced to defend aspects of the package from charges that its scope was too narrow and that it did not go far enough on a global minimum corporate tax rate.

Cormann said he hoped the jurisdictions that had signed up to the agreement, which now number 138, would conclude the drafting of the multilateral convention required to implement the package’s pillar one by the middle of this year so that it could be put into place on schedule around the world in 2024.

“There are still various areas where there are technical discussions and public consultations,” he said.

“For example, on issues like how we treat withholding taxes. Those who pay taxes in market jurisdictions say withholding taxes are taxes they have paid and they should be taken into account. Others say withholding taxes are not in scope and if they are part of the equation, we should adjust amount A. It becomes very technical very quickly.”

Amount A refers to the formula-based share of residual profit allocated to market jurisdictions.

Zainab Shamsuna Ahmed, Nigeria’s minister of finance, budget and national planning, said her country could not sign up to the agreement in its current form but would be interested in joining if improvements were possible.

“Most of the digital enterprises in our countries are the medium-sized ones. They’re not the very, very large ones,” Ahmed said.

“The outcome of this means there will be discriminatory taxes within our jurisdiction, so, if we sign up, we will not be able to tax these small and medium-sized businesses while we are taxing similar Nigerian companies operating in the same market.”

Gabriel Zucman, director of the EU Tax Observatory, said he was a critic of the agreement because the minimum corporate tax rate of 15% imposed by pillar two was too low.

“This agreement is the first time where countries are going to agree on a minimum tax rate,” he said. “It’s going to make a real difference, especially pillar two, because many companies pay less than 15%, at least in some of the countries in which they book profits.

“That being said, it is also very insufficient and it’s also conceptually and philosophically flawed. It isn’t sufficient because a tax rate of 15% is way too low,” he added.

Faisal Alibrahim, the minister of economy and planning in Saudi Arabia, said his country broadly supported the deal: “There are some details that need to be sorted out, but it is underpinned by the pillars of fairness. It’s all about making sure that value and taxation are close to each other.”

The WEF finished on Friday, January 20.

 


more across site & bottom lb ros

More from across our site

Lawmakers have up to 120 days to decide the future of Brazil’s unique transfer pricing rules, but many taxpayers are wary of radical change.
Shell reports profits of £32.2 billion, prompting calls for higher taxes on energy companies, while the IMF has warned Australia to raise taxes to sustain public spending.
Governments now have the final OECD guidance on how to implement the 15% global minimum corporate tax rate.
The Indian company, which is contesting the bill, has a family connection to UK Prime Minister Rishi Sunak – whose government has just been hit by a tax scandal.
Developments included calls for tax reform in Malaysia and the US, concerns about the level of the VAT threshold in the UK, Ukraine’s preparations for EU accession, and more.
A steady stream of countries has announced steps towards implementing pillar two, but Korea has got there first. Ralph Cunningham finds out what tax executives should do next.
The BEPS Monitoring Group has found a rare point of agreement with business bodies advocating an EU-wide one-stop-shop for compliance under BEFIT.
Former PwC partner Peter-John Collins has been banned from serving as a tax agent in Australia, while Brazil reports its best-ever year of tax collection on record.
Industry groups are concerned about the shift away from the ALP towards formulary apportionment as part of a common consolidated corporate tax base across the EU.
The former tax official in Italy will take up her post in April.