Managing Tax Disputes Summit: Mismatches in global TP audits laid bare

International Tax Review is part of Legal Benchmarking Limited, 1-2 Paris Garden, London, SE1 8ND

Copyright © Legal Benchmarking Limited and its affiliated companies 2025

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

Managing Tax Disputes Summit: Mismatches in global TP audits laid bare

Taxdisputes_panel.jpg
L to R: Derya Bresser; Carolina del Campo; Brad Rolph

Speakers at ITR’s Managing Tax Disputes Summit said taxpayers can still face lengthy TP audits, despite strong documentation preparation

Taxpayers may have strong transfer pricing documentation in place but authorities’ aggressiveness could still lead to lengthy audits, according to experts at ITR’s Managing Tax Disputes Forum yesterday, September 27, in Amsterdam.

In Spain, for example, taxpayers can expect a TP audit to last for 27 months on average.

“It’s common, especially in TP, that they [tax authorities] open for three years and close for adjustment,” explained Carolina del Campo, partner in TP and tax governance at law firm Cuatrecasas based in Madrid, during the panel.

“If you don’t do it, they would normally open a new tax audit,” she added.

Spanish law demands taxpayers to prepare TP documentation including the master and local file, while larger groups must also follow country-by-country reporting requirements.

TP adjustments arising from audits are common, meaning preparing ahead of that adjustment before tax authorities make any investigation is even more crucial.

Most importantly, TP audits in Spain are not only targeted at multinationals but also at smaller firms with domestic transactions.

“They [tax authorities] are making an exchange of information for TP matters, such as asking about the TP policy and are incorporating that information in the audit,” said del Campo.

“From the beginning, you need to find a strategy. Try to look at tools available,” she added.

Going after ‘everyone’

Brad Rolph, partner and national leader of TP at consulting firm Grant Thornton in Canada, stressed the Canada Revenue Agency’s (CRA) aggressiveness towards corporations’ TP documentation.

“Canada goes after everyone,” said Rolph.

The CRA’s request for TP adjustments depends on each particular case and individual transaction, according to Rolph.

TP audits in Canada will most likely require a company’s TP documentation based on a query sheet.

“They have a standard form and would ask you a standard form of question. Some auditors like to find the information required – they will try to do a field audit as much as they possibly can,” explained Rolph.

However, the Canadian TP laws also lack specific regulations, according to Rolph. While the CRA recognises OECD guidelines, the laws do not incorporate the guidance itself.

Since OECD reports are not formally recognised by the Canadian courts, corporations are solely required to keep all records of non-arm’s-length transactions.

“It’s the law that matters and not the OECD guidelines,” said Rolph.

But tax authorities’ level of aggressiveness also depends on their resources, according to Rolph.

As opposed to the CRA, the Internal Revenue Service lacks resources to go after smaller firms when it comes to TP audits, meaning companies within this scope are less likely to be targeted by the US tax authority.

The US has strong TP laws in place, requiring taxpayers to maintain a range of information known as the principal and background documents. This can include anything from a description of the company’s organisational structure to an explanation of comparables used.

ITR’s Global Transfer Pricing Forum Europe is also taking place in Amsterdam, on September 28 and 29, and we will be bringing you more coverage from that event.

more across site & shared bottom lb ros

More from across our site

The firm has appointed Deloitte’s former tax leader for Thailand to lead the new operation, which builds on considerable Asian investment in recent months
The Donald Trump administration could use legislation from 1930 if the Supreme Court blocks its tariffs; in other news, China has updated its VAT refund procedures
Braun gives ITR an exclusive insight into WTS Digital’s UK launch of its AI product, which can free up more than 1,500 hours per month by reducing routine tasks
Long tells ITR about her varied role, why curiosity is a key characteristic for the tax professional, and what she’d be doing if she wasn’t working in tax
The choice facing governments is not whether to adopt AI in taxation, but how to do so in a way that upholds the principles of tax fairness, writes Neil Kelley
As ITR’s client data reveals discontent with German tax advisers’ cost management, Grant Thornton’s local TP head insists it’s a two-way street
Uncertainty isn’t always a bad thing, but it’s easy to see how the Trump administration’s IRS commissioner merry-go-round may serve to undermine business confidence
The EU defended its ‘sovereign right’ to impose the tax in the face of US tariff threats; in other news, the US deputy Treasury secretary resigned after just five months
Ascoria’s chief revenue officer shares her career wisdom garnered from the disparate worlds of tax technology, electric cables, radio DJing and more
Businesses no longer have a choice when it comes to tax technology transformation. Pavlo Boyko of TMF Group says the question is simply: sink or swim?
Gift this article