International Tax Review is part of the Delinian Group, Delinian Limited, 8 Bouverie Street, London, EC4Y 8AX, Registered in England & Wales, Company number 00954730
Copyright © Delinian Limited and its affiliated companies 2023

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

IFA 2022: Pillar two about ‘strengthening sovereignty’

Leader concept. Headman. Chess king cast shadow in form of lion

The departing OECD director said countries’ sovereignty is crucial to pillar two while speakers questioned current tax policies.

Countries must not fear losing their sovereignty when implementing pillar two, but policies need to be revised for the OECD tax framework to be efficient, according to panellists at the IFA Congress in Berlin last week.

Pascal Saint-Amans, departing director at the OECD’s Centre for Tax Policy and Administration, said that countries had “lost their sovereignty” in the world of globalisation due to unfair tax competition.

However, they could regain their power through more robust tax laws.

“The tax paradox is to strengthen the tax sovereignty. To do that, they [countries] have to give up a bit of their sovereignty,” he said during the IFA panel on September 7.

Mechanisms must be put in place to prevent profit shifting and for governments to retain their power of collecting revenue, but tax incentives make it difficult to do so, according to Saint-Amans.

“There is a wealth of debate and questions that countries will have to face. It’s about strengthening sovereignty and removing the ability of some countries to be aggressive and offer tax tools,” he explained.

US outlook

Despite regulations including the global intangible low-taxed income (GILTI) rule in the US, which aims to tax income earned by controlled foreign companies (CFCs), there remains a sovereignty and compliance issue.

CFC rules are also designed to prevent profit shifting by forcing taxpayers to declare their foreign earnings.

During the same panel, Manal Corwin, principal-in-charge of KPMG’s Washington national practice and America’s regional tax policy leader for KPMG International, said she considers this to be a crucial issue within BEPS.

“The US was suggesting strengthening CFC rules – in the end, the BEPS action plan was a way to get that. CFCs are the province of domestic law,” she said.

“At the end of the day, you end up with something in which countries are looking to collect their own tax. There is a tension with the fact that countries regularly use tax policies to drive outcomes, desirable outcomes,” added Corwin.

This approach “neutralises” the effectiveness of tax policies to achieve these desirable outcomes, according to Corwin.

“The origin and pathway were because of sovereignty and the fact that CFC and tax rates are the problem of domestic law,” she said.

Lisa Wadlin, US-based head of tax at Netflix, also claimed that the US considers GILTI not to be sufficient – or that it leaves leeway for others to tax income.

Pillar two would impose a 15% tax on multinationals with revenues above €750 million ($747 million) – a “high” threshold from a US perspective, said Wadlin.

The implementation of pillar two would also call into question the effectiveness and role of other tax policies currently in place, such as the CFC regime, she added.

ITR also reported on progress made around pillar two, as discussed at the IFA Congress, in this latest article.

more across site & bottom lb ros

More from across our site

Shareholders are set to vote on whether the asset management firm will adopt public CbCR, amid claims of tax avoidance.
US lawmakers averted a default on debt by approving the Fiscal Responsibility Act, but this deal may consolidate the Biden tax reforms rather than undermine them.
In a letter to the Australian Senate, the firm has provided the names of all 67 staff who received confidential emails but has not released them publicly.
David Pickstone and Anastasia Nourescu of Stewarts review the facts and implications of Ørsted’s appeal at the Upper Tribunal.
The Internal Revenue Service will lose the funding as part of the US debt limit deal, while Amazon UK reaps the benefits of the 130% ‘super-deduction’.
The European Commission wanted to make an example of US companies like Apple, but its crusade against ‘sweetheart’ tax rulings may be derailed at the CJEU.
The OECD has announced that a TP training programme is about to conclude in West Africa, a region that has been plagued by mispricing activities for a number of years.
Richard Murphy and Andrew Baker make the case for tax transparency as a public good and how key principles should lead to a better tax system.
‘Go on leave, effective immediately’, PwC has told nine partners in the latest development in the firm’s ongoing tax scandal.
The forum heard that VAT professionals are struggling under new pressures to validate transactions and catch fraud, responsibilities that they say should lie with governments.