All material subject to strictly enforced copyright laws. © 2022 ITR is part of the Euromoney Institutional Investor PLC group.

IFA 2022: Carbon pricing is the next big project akin to BEPS

Stacking gold coins and money bag of tree with growing put on the wood on the morning sunlight in public park, Saving money and loan for business investment concept.

OECD delegates Kurt van Dender and Pascal Saint-Amans said that carbon pricing will be the next big project on the intergovernmental organisation’s agenda.

OECD delegates Pascal Saint-Amans (director of the centre for tax policy and administration) and Kurt van Dender (head of the tax and environment unit) said during an IFA panel that carbon pricing policies, including carbon taxes, are set to be the next project on a scale equal to the BEPS actions plan.

An emissions trading system, excise taxes, and fossil fuel taxes are all instruments that provide clear pricing indicators. Carbon prices have doubled since the COVID-19 pandemic started, but pricing variations across countries are large, according to van Dender.

The panel had a bigger public turnout than some of the other IFA sessions because many countries are setting zero-carbon emissions goals based on the Paris Agreement, which are translating into tax obligations in the mid- to long-term scenarios for large businesses.

Most attendees are in favour of a carbon price. Almost 86% of the audience agreed that a widely accepted international standard is required at this late stage of climate change.

Carbon policymaking

Other panellists at the carbon pricing session, held on Wednesday, September 7, include Tatiana Falcão, international tax lawyer and coordinator at the coalition for climate action at the World Bank in Brazil; Ian Parry, environmental fiscal policy and climate change expert at the IMF in Washington, D.C.; and David Boublil, deputy head of the indirect tax unit at the European Commission in Brussels.

All said the international challenge is designing a wider standard for carbon pricing. Panellists covered what it means to price carbon, the constitutive elements of a carbon price, border adjustment mechanisms to manage local carbon prices, and the types of multilateral approaches to coordinate the pricing of carbon internationally.

Carbon pricing plays a role in climate change mitigation policy, and the basic design details are critical. Carbon taxes are a natural pricing instrument, and trading systems can set a price floor alongside other regulatory measures.

Countries have taken different approaches to address the risks of climate change via tax policy. Taiwan adopted a carbon tax, the EU has an emissions trading system, and the US has a separate regulatory system.

Other carbon pricing approaches are being developed and implemented in Europe and North and South America. Panellists said the most readily available mechanisms across countries are carbon taxes, emissions trading systems, and carbon border adjustment mechanisms.

Carbon leakage

The various carbon pricing approaches have affected the trade of cement, iron and steel, fertilisers, and electric power for several large companies, from Apple to Deere. Industries focusing on the trade of these resources have a high risk of carbon leakage in their supply chains.

So far, however, regulations have not been strong enough to stem carbon leakage, as companies can still shift production to countries with low carbon options that also allow refundable credits to offset costs. Subsidies, rate reduction, exemptions, special regimes, and tradable performance standards all lower the cost of carbon pricing.

Carbon leakage is the biggest motivator for border adjustment mechanisms.

Carbon prices rose in countries where they were already high in recent months, such as Canada, France, and the UK, but not much in other G20 countries. Argentina, Indonesia, and the US are outliers as low performers. Alongside this trend, the price shock of the Russia-Ukraine also affected carbon pricing progress in most countries, and price support fell after the event.

To achieve more multilateral carbon pricing, Germany and other countries are creating climate clubs – bloc efforts to align carbon pricing adjustment mechanisms with each other.

The OECD’s efforts to lead and enhance policymaking on such climate change actions are slower than delegates expected, but more resources will go to international carbon pricing after the organisation finishes its work on the two-pillar solution to address tax challenges in the digital economy.

more across site & bottom lb ros

More from across our site

Ramesh Khaitan speaks to reporter Siqalane Taho about tax morality, transfer pricing regulations, Indian tax developments, and the OECD’s two-pillar solution.
Join ITR and KPMG China at 10am BST on October 19 as they discuss the personal, employment, and corporate tax-related implications of employees working from overseas.
Tricentis and Boehringer Ingelheim, along with a European Commission TP specialist, criticised the complexity of pillar one rules and their scope at an ITR event.
Speakers at ITR’s Managing Tax Disputes Summit said taxpayers can still face lengthy TP audits, despite strong documentation preparation
Gig economy companies in New Zealand will need to fully account and become liable for the goods and services tax of underlying suppliers on their platforms, under new proposals.
Join ITR and Thomson Reuters at 2pm (UAE) / 11am (UK) on October 13 as they discuss how businesses can prepare for Tax Administration 3.0 and future-proof against changes such as e-invoicing and increasing digitisation.
ITR has partnered with global TP leaders from Deloitte to discuss transfer pricing controversy around the globe, and to share advice on how to navigate an increasingly uncertain and risky TP landscape.
Sources say they are not satisfied with pillar one protections in the marketing and distribution safe harbour, even though it was designed to give businesses greater tax certainty.
Political support for qualified majority voting is at a peak as unanimity rules continue to block the European Council from passing a directive on pillar two.
The winners of the ITR Americas Tax Awards have been announced for 2022!
We use cookies to provide a personalized site experience.
By continuing to use & browse the site you agree to our Privacy Policy.
I agree