UK Supreme Court Prudential case could mean significant loss of business for accountants
International Tax Review is part of the Delinian Group, Delinian Limited, 4 Bouverie Street, London, EC4Y 8AX, Registered in England & Wales, Company number 00954730
Copyright © Delinian Limited and its affiliated companies 2024

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

UK Supreme Court Prudential case could mean significant loss of business for accountants

prudential-reduced.jpg

The UK Supreme Court is delivering its judgement in Prudential’s case against HM Revenue & Customs (HMRC) tomorrow. The court will decide whether legal professional privilege (LPP) should cover communications between taxpayers and accountants as well as lawyers.

Prudential argued its case at the hearing in November where it defended the non-disclosure of documents relating to legal advice on tax matters it had received from accountancy firm PwC on the basis that they were protected by LPP.

HMRC demanded to see the documents because they related to a marketed tax avoidance scheme Prudential had entered. The revenue authority said advice from accountants is not covered by LPP.

The Supreme Court was asked to consider:

  • whether under common law, LPP applies to communications between a client seeking and an accountant giving advice on tax law;

  • the nature of the principles underlying LPP, the purpose of LPP and whether its application to advice on tax law from accountants would promote that purpose;

  • the relevance of the Human Rights Act 1998 and the European Convention on Human Rights which Prudential contends prohibit HMRC from refusing to allow LPP for the legal advice from accountants on tax law;

  • the scope of LPP under common law;

  • whether only parliament should decide whether or not LPP should apply to legal advice on tax law from accountants; and

  • the Court of Appeal’s decision in Wilden Pump Engineering Co v Fusfeld which held that LPP did not apply to patent agents, though the Supreme Court is not bound by this decision.

The Supreme Court’s ruling will affect taxpayers and advisers.

If HMRC wins its case, lawyers will have a competitive advantage over accountants when advising clients on tax law.

This will hit taxpayers since, depending on the importance placed on LPP, they may be pushed towards seeking tax legal advice from lawyers rather than accountants even if an accountancy firm has greater expertise, simply to ensure LPP.

Read a full analysis of the ruling on ITR Premium's Tax Disputes section here. 

Further reading

Prudential loses legal privilege challenge

Supreme Court agrees to hear Prudential’s challenge to LPP

Canadian Federal Court rules on solicitor-client privilege

Why tax authorities need to respect client privilege

more across site & bottom lb ros

More from across our site

Barbara Voskamp is bullish on hiring local talent to boost DLA Piper’s Singapore practice, and argues that ‘big four’ accountants suffer from a stifled creativity
Chris Jordan also said that nations have a duty to scrutinise the partnership structures of major firms, while, in other news, a number of tax teams expanded their benches
KPMG has exclusive access to the tool for three years in the UK, giving it an edge over ‘big four’ rivals
But the US tax agency’s advice is consistent with OECD guidance and shouldn’t surprise anyone, other experts tell ITR
A survey of more than 25,000 in-house counsel reveals that diversity initiatives are a high priority when choosing external counsel
The report is aimed at helping 'low-capacity countries', the OECD has claimed
The UK tax agency appears to be going after easier, lower value targets, one lawyer has claimed
Criminal experts have told ITR that the case of Ulf Johannemann emphasises the fine line between tax avoidance and tax evasion
The ATO workers were among nearly 57,000 people who were duped into claiming fake GST refunds, while Kuwait signed a double taxation treaty with the UAE
However, ICAP may not provide the legal certainty of an APA and tax authorities will have limited capacity, experts argue
Gift this article