COMMENT: The dangers of US tax disputes
International Tax Review is part of Legal Benchmarking Limited, 4 Bouverie Street, London, EC4Y 8AX
Copyright © Legal Benchmarking Limited and its affiliated companies 2024

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

COMMENT: The dangers of US tax disputes


If you enter into a tax dispute in the US, you are probably going to lose. A study has found that the odds are stacked against taxpayers whose battles with the Internal Revenue Service go all the way to the Supreme Court.

The report titled "Corporate Shams", which was published by two tax scholars at US universities, found that the IRS won more than six times out of 10 in high court battles where it claimed companies abused the tax code.

But the worrying statistic from the report is that the government won 68% of the time when it argued that taxpayers allegedly misread the tax code rather than abused it.

This prompts two questions: Is the US tax code open to being misread, that is, too complex? Or are taxpayers and their advisers not up to scratch?

But the likely answer is that there are inconsistencies in the way judgments are made and there are clearly grey areas in the tax code that can be exploited by both government and corporate lawyers.

So what this means is that taxpayers need to be aware of these discrepancies and opportunities for exploitation. And unless they have an encyclopaedic knowledge of the tax code, a lot of the time they have to rely on tax advisers to bring these discrepancies and opportunities to their attention.

Alerting clients to these possibilities is one thing. Explaining how to make the most of them is another. It is where the skill of the adviser comes in. For them to serve their client properly, a tax adviser requires not only knowledge of the tax code but also the awareness of and the ability to spot when and why the tax authorities might try to attack different types of tax planning. That entails a comprehensive understanding of the law and the pitfalls awaiting careless advice.

May's International Tax Review cover story features firms that understand the need to deliver such planning advice consistently well. The feature reveals the results of the 2012 global Tax Planning Survey. The poll ranks the leading tax planning firms in 56 jurisdictions and rewards firms that have been particularly active and creative in the global tax planning market.

Analysis of the results shows that even if you get your tax planning correct, you are still at risk. While the majority of tax planning methods and techniques are perfectly legal, they are still not immune from the attention of wider society. Gone are the days of taxpayers legitimately utilising losses to reduce their effective tax rate, two phrases are repeated the world over: "fair share" and "spirit of the law". While they are both ambiguous phrases, taxpayers are being forced to think twice about the tax planning they undertake.


Risky business: How bad tax planning could get your company in trouble

How to win a US dispute

more across site & bottom lb ros

More from across our site

With corporate tax rates already exceeding 15%, India will need to think creatively to extract additional revenue through new pillar two rules, local partners tell ITR
France continues to be a hot spot for tax lateral partner moves, according to ITR+’s Talent Tracker
Losses for HM Revenue and Customs and the Australian Taxation Office, cum-ex fraud and a 'mysterious funder' all feature in ITR’s list of 2024’s most significant tax cases so far
New requirements for advisers to inform clients of any relevant matters that might impact their relationship have raised concerns from a raft of professional bodies
The fallout from PwC China’s Evergrande audit has reportedly hit the firm hard; in other news, the US and Turkey look to reform their corporate tax rates
Canada risks inflaming US trade relations in a presidential election year and increasing costs for consumers, according to local experts
Dudbridge, ForrestBrown director and head of its advisory practice, FB Consulting, tells ITR about the joys of tax advisory work, what he finds most exciting about the role and what makes tax cool
A UK court rejected Tills Plus’s claim for R&D tax credits due to a lack of technological advancement
View the Social Impact EMEA Awards 2024 shortlist and join us on September 12 at The Waldorf Hotel in London
The announcement is due to be made during the country’s Union Budget statement next week, according to reports
Gift this article