India: Ruling on characterisation of surplus on sale of debentures
International Tax Review is part of the Delinian Group, Delinian Limited, 4 Bouverie Street, London, EC4Y 8AX, Registered in England & Wales, Company number 00954730
Copyright © Delinian Limited and its affiliated companies 2024

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

India: Ruling on characterisation of surplus on sale of debentures



Rajendra Nayak

Aastha Jain

The Delhi High Court (HC) in a recent case of Zaheer Mauritius [WP(C) 1648/2013 & CM No. 3105/2013], ruled on whether gains arising on sale of Compulsory Convertible Debentures (CCD) can be regarded as interest under the Indian Tax Laws (ITL) as well as under the India-Mauritius tax treaty (the Treaty). Zaheer Mauritius (Taxpayer) was a Mauritius company, which invested in 35% equity holding of a joint venture Indian company (JV Co) which was a subsidiary of another Indian company (JV Partner). Taxpayer also had invested in CCDs of JV Co. These investments were held as capital asset by Taxpayer. A shareholder's agreement was entered between JV Partner and Taxpayer, providing for a call and put option in relation to investment made by Taxpayer in JV Co. It was agreed that the purchase price of the CCDs would depend on the period of holding and an internal rate of return. Consequently, JV Partner purchased certain shares and entire CCDs held by Taxpayer in JV Co by exercising the call option, which resulted in surplus to the Taxpayer.

On an application, the Authority for Advance Rulings (AAR) ruled that gains arising on sale of CCDs is in the nature of interest under the ITL as well as under the Treaty, on the basis that JV Co and JV Partner are one and the same entity. Further, the transaction designed as purchase of CCD is a sham and it is in effect interest payments made by JV Partner in the capacity of a debtor to Taxpayer. Aggrieved, Taxpayer filed a Petition with the HC.

The HC stated that merely because an investment agreement provides for exit options to an investor by assuring a minimum return, it would not change the nature of the investment made. The transaction involving CCDs and understanding between Taxpayer and JV Co represented a genuine commercial venture and there was no reason to ignore the legal nature of CCDs or to lift the corporate veil to treat the underlying JV Co and JV partner as a single entity thereby meriting characterisation of part of the transfer price as interest. Characterisation of the surplus on sale of CCDs as capital gains depends entirely on whether the debentures are capital assets in the hands of its holder, irrespective of whether the investment in CCD is a loan arrangement or is in the nature of equity. As Taxpayer held the CCDs in JV Co as capital asset, the HC decided that gains arising from transfer of such CCDs would be capital gains, not taxable in India by virtue of the Treaty.

This HC decision reiterates the principles laid by the Indian Supreme Court in the case of Vodafone International Holdings BV [6 SCC 613 (2012)], wherein it was held that the transaction as a whole must be looked at and one cannot start with a presumption that the transaction is a tax saving device.

Rajendra Nayak ( and Aastha Jain (


Tel: +91 80 6727 5275


more across site & bottom lb ros

More from across our site

But the US tax agency’s advice is consistent with OECD guidance and shouldn’t surprise anyone, other experts tell ITR
A survey of more than 25,000 in-house counsel reveals that diversity initiatives are a high priority when choosing external counsel
The report is aimed at helping 'low-capacity countries', the OECD has claimed
The UK tax agency appears to be going after easier, lower value targets, one lawyer has claimed
Criminal experts have told ITR that the case of Ulf Johannemann emphasises the fine line between tax avoidance and tax evasion
The ATO workers were among nearly 57,000 people who were duped into claiming fake GST refunds, while Kuwait signed a double taxation treaty with the UAE
However, ICAP may not provide the legal certainty of an APA and tax authorities will have limited capacity, experts argue
ITR+ has launched the Talent Tracker, an interactive database that collates reported partner moves across the legal tax market
The tool is available to more than 2,000 PwC tax professionals and is designed to boost client service
The ‘big four’ firm has already communicated its intention to pay off the strategic failure to its partners
Gift this article