All material subject to strictly enforced copyright laws. © 2022 ITR is part of the Euromoney Institutional Investor PLC group.

Canada: SCC upholds tax preparer penalties, says they are not criminal in nature

Wong-Sabrina-100
Schmid-Evan-100

Sabrina Wong

Evan Schmid

On July 31 2015 the Supreme Court of Canada (SCC) issued its decision in Guindon v Canada, 2015 SCC 41. The substantive legal issue before the SCC was whether the penalty under section 163.2(4) of the Canadian Income Tax Act (ITA) was a criminal sanction such that procedural protections in the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms (Charter) should be engaged and the penalties vacated.

The SCC upheld significant penalties assessed on Ms Guindon by the Minister of National Revenue. These penalties can be imposed on persons, including lawyers and accountants, who knowingly, or in circumstances amounting to culpable conduct, make or participate in the making of, a false statement that could be used by another person for tax purposes. Following this decision, it is clear that these penalties are constitutionally valid and can be used as an alternative to the criminal sanctions in the ITA (with a lower standard of proof and without the constitutional protections guaranteed to a person charged with an offence).

Decision

Ms. Guindon is a lawyer with no expertise in income tax law. She was assessed for penalties totalling C$546,747 ($420,000) for making false statements concerning the tax status of a charitable programme for which she provided a tax opinion. This programme, which was a sham, resulted in participants claiming C$3,972,747 in unwarranted tax credits. She argued that the tax preparer penalty was criminal in nature, and accordingly that she was entitled to procedural protections in the Charter.

The SCC found that the penalty is not a criminal sanction because it is neither criminal in nature nor imposes a true penal consequence.

The court determined that the process by which the penalty is imposed is administrative in nature. The fact that the conduct could also result in criminal sanctions under the ITA does not alter the provision's administrative nature.

The SCC also concluded that the large penalty imposed on Ms Guindon was not a "true penal consequence", as the magnitude of the penalties under ITA section163.2(4) was tied to the legislative objective of deterring non-compliance with the relevant provisions of the ITA, was fixed without regard to other general criminal sentencing principles and was appropriate given the actions of Ms Guindon. In this light a sizeable penalty was justified to ensure that "the penalty is not simply considered a cost of doing business".

Sabrina Wong (sabrina.wong@blakes.com) and Evan Schmid (evan.schmid@blakes.com), Toronto
Blake, Cassels & Graydon

Tel: +1 416 863 2645 and +1 416 863 4341

Website www.blakes.com

More from across our site

Tax professionals have called on the UK government to reconsider its online sales tax as it would affect the economy at the worst time.
Tax professionals have called on companies to act urgently to meet e-invoicing compliance targets as the EU plans to ramp up digitisation.
In the wake of India’s ambitious 25-year plan for economic growth, ITR has partnered with leading tax commentators to discuss what the future will look like for India and for the rest of the world.
But experts cast doubt on HMRC's data and believe COVID-19 would have increased the revenue shortfall.
EY’s plan to separate its auditing and consulting businesses might lessen scrutiny from global regulators, but the brand identity could suffer, say sources.
Multinationals are asking world leaders to put a scale on carbon pricing to tackle climate change at the 48th G7 summit in Germany, from June 26 to 28.
The state secretary told the French press that the country continues to oppose pillar two’s global minimum tax rate following an Ecofin meeting last week.
This week the Biden administration has run into opposition over a proposal for a federal gas tax holiday, while the European Parliament has approved a plan for an EU carbon border mechanism.
12th annual awards announce winners
Businesses need to improve on data management to ensure tax departments become much more integrated, according to Microsoft’s chief digital officer at a KPMG event.
We use cookies to provide a personalized site experience.
By continuing to use & browse the site you agree to our Privacy Policy.
I agree