Ireland: Moscovici in Ireland to discuss CCCTB

International Tax Review is part of Legal Benchmarking Limited, 1-2 Paris Garden, London, SE1 8ND

Copyright © Legal Benchmarking Limited and its affiliated companies 2025

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

Ireland: Moscovici in Ireland to discuss CCCTB

omeara.jpg
long.jpg

Catherine O’Meara

Olivia Long

EU Commissioner Pierre Moscovici appeared before the Irish Government Committee on Finance (the committee) on January 24 2017 to answer questions on the re-launch of the common consolidated corporate tax base (the CCCTB).

It was clear from the meeting that the proposal has limited support from the parliamentarians present who represented both government and opposition parties. This is not surprising. In December 2016, the Irish government issued a reasoned opinion in respect of the proposed CCCTB on the basis that it breached the EU principle of subsidiarity.

The main objections raised by the committee were that:

  • The proposal falls within an area of national competence and impacts Ireland's tax sovereignty. Commissioner Moscovici disagreed: "I argue to the contrary, that EU coordination on tax matters reinforces rather than threatens national sovereignty." He also noted that the proposal would only be adopted if accepted by all member states, including Ireland and that the requirement for unanimity in tax matters protects Ireland's tax sovereignty;

  • The proposal would require Ireland to abolish two of its three rates of tax that apply to companies (trading profits are taxed at 12.5%, passive income is taxed at 25% and gains on disposals of capital assets are taxed at 33%). This would represent a further encroachment into Ireland's tax sovereignty and could potentially result in a €450 million ($479 million) loss of tax revenue. Commissioner Moscovici agreed that the three rate regime was incompatible with the CCCTB proposal, however, he believed that Ireland's tax sovereignty will still be protected because Ireland will be permitted to set the rate;

  • It is anticipated that, if adopted, the CCCTB would narrow Ireland's tax base and ultimately reduce Irish corporation tax revenues. Commissioner Moscovici noted that, so far, the European Commission has only undertaken an impact assessment of the proposal on the EU as a whole. Under that assessment, corporation tax revenue on an EU-wide basis would increase by 1.2%. He acknowledged that no country-by-country assessment has yet been undertaken by the Commission and this could be addressed; and

  • The allocation key included in the proposal is expected to result in taxable profits reducing in countries with net export economies (such as Ireland) and increasing in countries with large domestic markets (such as France). In response to this, the Commissioner noted that the allocation key is based on a "tried and tested formula", which has been used in the US. He noted that it was difficult for taxpayers to manipulate and he considers that it is "the best proposal for all member states, large and small."

Commissioner Moscovici's appearance before the committee did not seem to allay the concerns of those present and seems unlikely to change the Irish position on the CCCTB. Commissioner Moscovici acknowledged this is in his closing remarks to the committee referencing their "shall we say, special spirit or fighting spirit". In closing, he asked the committee to "take the proposal on the table as a proposal, and examine it with good faith".

Catherine O'Meara (catherine.omeara@matheson.com) and Olivia Long (olivia.long@matheson.com)

Matheson

Tel: +353 1 232 2000

Website: www.matheson.com

more across site & shared bottom lb ros

More from across our site

The threat of 50% tariffs on Brazilian goods coincides with new Brazilian legal powers to adopt retaliatory economic measures, local experts tell ITR
The country’s chancellor appears to have backtracked from previous pillar two scepticism; in other news, Donald Trump threatened Russia with 100% tariffs
In its latest G20 update, the OECD also revealed tense discussions with the US where the ‘significant threat’ of Section 899 was highlighted
The tax agency has increased compliance yield from wealthy individuals but cannot identify how much tax is paid by UK billionaires, the committee also claimed
Saffery cautioned that documentation requirements in new government proposals must be limited if medium-sized companies are not exempted from TP
The global minimum tax deal is not viable without US participation, Friedrich Merz has argued
Section 899 of the ‘one big beautiful’ bill would have spelled disaster for many international investors into the US, but following its shelving, attention turns to the fate of the OECD’s pillars
DLA Piper’s co-head of tax for the US and Latin America tells ITR about her fervent belief in equal access to the law, loving yoga, and paternal inspirations
Tax expert Craig Hillier agrees with the comparison of pillar two to using a sledgehammer to crack a nut
The amount is reported to be up 57% from the £5.6bn that the UK tax agency believes was underpaid in the previous year
Gift this article