All material subject to strictly enforced copyright laws. © 2022 ITR is part of the Euromoney Institutional Investor PLC group.

Latest developments in financial transactions transfer pricing: The Swiss view


The concept of the arm's-length principle is not new but the breadth of its interpretation today has changed considerably since it was first officially set out in Article 9 (Taxation on Income: Associated Enterprises) of the OECD's 1998 Model Tax Convention on Income and on Capital.

Views on the interpretation of the arm's-length principle differ across various countries and organisations and this is indeed also the case for issues relating to financial transactions.

The latest 2017 OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines extensively elaborate on transactions relating to goods and services, intangible property and business restructurings, but the OECD is yet to publish its final guidance on financing transactions (originally anticipated in the summer of 2017). As things stand, the new OECD Guidelines provided some helpful insights on financial transactions, but to a large extent the guidance arguably raises more questions than it answers and leaves much open to interpretation.

Nevertheless, some common themes are emerging, with a strengthening focus on substance and risk. This focus extends further to encompass options realistically available, actual ability to control and bear risk, and arm's length behaviour of transacting parties notwithstanding the contractual terms of the transaction.

Practical considerations

In light of the above, it is important to consider the latest concepts impacting transfer pricing of financial transactions. We briefly outline these below.

Implicit support (or passive association)

The concept of passive association has been around for many years but the explicit acknowledgement of this concept within the latest OECD Guidelines removes substantial doubt around the application of this concept and illustrates that implicit support should be taken into account when determining the creditworthiness of a borrower.

The nuances surrounding the exact level of implicit support and the impact that this might have on credit ratings can be complex and require a revamp of numerous transfer pricing methodologies that have been used by multinationals in the recent past.

Substance light entities (cash boxes)

Substance light entities have been the focus of the OECD initiative on many different fronts, and substance light lenders have fallen in with the rest. As such, a lack of functionality and control over financial risk by the lender could theoretically result in a reallocation of the associated financial return.

The concepts of risk free return and risk adjusted return that were put forward by the OECD leave a lot up to interpretation, but the key theme regarding substance light entities remains clear and is already having a substantial impact on typical financing structures.

Accurate delineation of transactions

The actual behaviour of parties to a transaction has long been the focus of tax authorities. However, the explicit references made to this concept within the new OECD Guidelines could have a material impact on financial transactions. An extended application of this principle could substantially impact the arm's-length terms of various financing arrangements, covering a broad range of considerations.

The way forward

Despite varying economic views and expertise in these areas we all humbly await the new OECD guidance on financial transactions, in the hope that this will provide a global consensus and bridge the disconnect between the approaches of various tax authorities.






Christian Jacob ( and George Galumov (


Tel: +41 58 279 6391 and +41 58 279 8142


more across site & bottom lb ros

More from across our site

Speakers at ITR’s Managing Tax Disputes Summit said taxpayers can still face lengthy TP audits, despite strong documentation preparation
Gig economy companies in New Zealand will need to fully account and become liable for the goods and services tax of underlying suppliers on their platforms, under new proposals.
Join ITR and Thomson Reuters at 2pm (UAE) / 11am (UK) on October 13 as they discuss how businesses can prepare for Tax Administration 3.0 and future-proof against changes such as e-invoicing and increasing digitisation.
ITR has partnered with global TP leaders from Deloitte to discuss transfer pricing controversy around the globe, and to share advice on how to navigate an increasingly uncertain and risky TP landscape.
Sources say they are not satisfied with pillar one protections in the marketing and distribution safe harbour, even though it was designed to give businesses greater tax certainty.
Political support for qualified majority voting is at a peak as unanimity rules continue to block the European Council from passing a directive on pillar two.
The winners of the ITR Americas Tax Awards have been announced for 2022!
US technology company Cisco Systems hopes shareholders will reject a proposal to make its CbCR public, while the UK approves an extradition case connected to the ‘cum-ex’ scandal.
Tax leaders have warned that the latest UK interest rate increases could land a further blow on MNEs, which are already struggling.
Panellists said OTP can improve corporations’ forecasting and data usage, with one describing improvements as 'night and day'.
We use cookies to provide a personalized site experience.
By continuing to use & browse the site you agree to our Privacy Policy.
I agree