All material subject to strictly enforced copyright laws. © 2022 ITR is part of the Euromoney Institutional Investor PLC group.

Mumbai tribunal affirms territorial nexus as essential in determining attributable profits

Sponsored by

logo.png
India map 600 x 375

The Mumbai Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (tribunal) has held that a territorial nexus is necessary for determining profits attributable to operations carried out in India. Agency commission accrued, or arising, outside of India is not taxable under domestic laws.

Under the provisions of the Income-tax Act of 1961, income that has arisen directly or indirectly from a business connection is considered taxable in India. In business cases where not all operations are carried out in India, the income deemed taxable is considered 'reasonably attributable' to operations carried out in India. The applicability of this provision has been upheld in several judicial precedents.

In the case dealt with by the tribunal, the taxpayer is a foreign company (tax resident of Hong Kong) and is appointed by a television channel as an agent to:

  • Sell advertising air-time on the channels;

  • Distribute the channels in the territories where the channels are broadcast; and

  • Procure syndication revenues from the content on the channels.

In a particular year, the taxpayer earned agency commission on advertising services in India, as well as outside India. However, at that particular time, India did not have a tax treaty with Hong Kong.

It appears that the foreign company had a business connection in India and income attributable to the business operations. As a result, the taxpayer was compensated with an amount equal to the profit earned by the channel companies and overseas entities that had merged into an Indian group entity.

Profit attribution was determined on sound transfer pricing (TP) principles and by applying a global profitability percentage.

The tax authorities accepted the TP methodology and profit margin. However, the tax authorities made an adjustment on the amount taxable by the taxpayer (i.e. commission received towards services rendered outside India). It was also argued that under the Act, certain offshore income earned by a non-resident (i.e. by way of interest/royalty/fees for technical services) is taxable in India, irrespective of the place of rendition of the services or the presence of a business connection in India.

Subsequently, the tribunal rejected the position of the tax authorities. In this case, reliance on the provisions relating to the taxation of certain offshore income was not applicable to the agency commission earned by the taxpayer.

The tribunal held that the income taxable in India will only be part of the income as 'reasonably attributable' to the operations carried out in India. The income which could be said to be taxable in India should have a 'territorial nexus'.

Since the commission fee was paid to the taxpayer outside India for services rendered outside India, the tribunal held that it was not attributable to operations in India and hence not taxable in India.

more across site & bottom lb ros

More from across our site

The UN’s decision to seek a leadership role in global tax policy could be a crucial turning point but won’t be the end of the OECD, say tax experts.
The UN may be set to assume a global role in tax policy that would rival the OECD, while automakers lobby the US to change its tax rules on Chinese materials.
Companies including Valentino and EveryMatrix say the early adoption of EU public CbCR rules could boost transparency of local and foreign MNEs, despite the short notice.
ITR invites tax firms, in-house teams, and tax professionals to make submissions for the 2023 ITR Tax Awards in Asia-Pacific, Europe Middle East & Africa, and the Americas.
Tax authorities and customs are failing multinationals by creating uncertainty with contradictory assessment and guidance, say in-house tax directors.
The CJEU said the General Court erred in law when it ruled that both companies benefitted from Italian state aid.
An OECD report reveals multinationals have continued to shift profits to low-tax jurisdictions, reinforcing the case for strong multilateral action in response.
The UK government announced plans to increase taxes on oil and gas profits, while the Irish government considers its next move on tax reform.
War and COVID have highlighted companies’ unpreparedness to deal with sudden geo-political changes, say TP specialists.
A source who has seen the draft law said it brings clarity on intangibles and other areas of TP including tax planning.