Update on new UK CFC rules

International Tax Review is part of Legal Benchmarking Limited, 1-2 Paris Garden, London, SE1 8ND

Copyright © Legal Benchmarking Limited and its affiliated companies 2025

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

Update on new UK CFC rules

The new UK controlled foreign company (CFC) rules are due to come into effect for accounting periods starting on or after January 1 2013. Lorna Smith and Liz Hughes of Grant Thornton UK emphasise the importance of assessing significant people functions (SPF).

The new rules were originally published in December 2011 however there has recently been additional guidance issued by HM Revenue & Customs (HMRC). As the new rules represent a significant change in approach, HMRC is holding a series of road shows during the autumn on the new CFC regime and the patent box. The road shows will be attended by HMRC's customer relationship managers and tax specialists.

In our earlier article, we introduced some important concepts that will be familiar to transfer pricing practitioners.

For example, some taxpayers may be required to identify whether there are any SPFs carried out in the UK in relation to the business of the CFC. This concept was first introduced in the OECD 2010 Report on the Attribution of Profits to Permanent Establishments.

SPFs are not defined further within the CFC legislation and so reliance will be placed on the definitions in the 2010 report.

Broadly, under the new rules, any non-UK resident company that is controlled by a UK company will be a CFC. Although there are a number of exemptions that may apply, if there are any SPFs that are carried out in the UK, which relate to the business carried out by the CFC, it may be necessary to treat the SPF of the CFC as if it is a UK branch of the CFC and attribute profits of the CFC to the branch.

Hence, the importance of the OECD report: firstly in determining what is an SPF and then how to attribute profits to the hypothesised branch. However, where the activities in the UK are already remunerated on an arm's-length basis, it is possible that no additional charge will arise.

SPFs are people who carry out fundamental business functions that lead to the assumption of risk, the ownership of assets or the on-going management of those assets and risks.

The first step in this process is to determine what are the key functions and risks in the business. What constitutes a key function or risk may be different depending on the business involved. For example, for companies in the pharmaceutical industry, research and development (R&D) may be important, whilst for fast moving consumables, marketing and brand development may be vital.

Once the key assets and risks have been identified, work needs to be performed to identify who performs those key functions, undertakes activities that lead to the assumption of risk, or manages those assets and risks.

Those people may not be the most senior or well paid in the organisation. They should, however, be the people that make active decisions regarding those assets and risks.

For example, in the pharmaceutical company it may be the person who decides whether to abort a project or to extend further funding to it, or interprets the results of the research.

This may not be the same person who is responsible for R&D at board level, nor the person who works in the laboratory performing the R&D.

To identify SPFs, and in particular if there is a UK-based SPF, a functional and factual analysis of the UK company and the CFC should be carried out.

In considering the application of the new CFC rules in a group, an important information source will be the group's transfer pricing documentation, which should already include such functional analysis, although it may require supplementing to analyse the issue in the particular circumstances of the CFC.

Grant Thornton UK held a client webinar on 18 September 2012 at which Liz Hughes, a Director in the Transfer Pricing team, outlined the SPF concept as it applies to CFCs.

more across site & shared bottom lb ros

More from across our site

Over two-thirds of survey respondents back the continuation of the UK’s digital services tax, research commissioned by the Fair Tax Foundation also found
Given the US/G7 pillar two deal, the OECD is in danger of being replaced by the UN as the leading global tax reform forum
Cinven’s latest investment follows its acquisition of a stake in Grant Thornton UK in December; in other news, a barrister listed by HMRC as a tax avoidance promoter has alleged harassment
CIT base narrowing measures remain more prevalent than increased CIT rates, the report also highlighted
ITR's parent company, LBG, will acquire The Lawyer, a leading news, intelligence and data-driven insight provider for the legal industry, from Centaur Media
KPMG UK’s Graeme Webster and KPMG Meijburg & Co’s Eduard Sporken outline the 20-year evolution of MAPAs, with DEMPE analyses becoming more prevalent and MAPA requirements growing stricter
Rishi Joshi, of the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India, warns of potential judicial overreach as assets are recharacterised to bypass a legislative exclusion
Only 2% of in-house survey respondents said they were ‘heavy’ users of AI for TP, Aibidia’s report also found
There was a ‘deeply embedded culture within PwC that routinely disregarded formal confidentiality obligations,’ the chairman of Australia’s Tax Practitioners Board said
Jennifer Best was most recently the acting commissioner of the IRS’s large business and international division
Gift this article