Joaquim Barbosa

International Tax Review is part of Legal Benchmarking Limited, 1-2 Paris Garden, London, SE1 8ND

Copyright © Legal Benchmarking Limited and its affiliated companies 2025

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

Joaquim Barbosa

Chief justice, Supreme Federal Court of Brazil

Joaquim Barbosa

Brazilian taxpayers and investors the world over had all eyes on the Supreme Federal Court in April, as it decided a dispute over the country’s controlled foreign company (CFC) rules which had lasted more than a decade. The case was Direct Action for Declaration of Unconstitutionality no. 2588, brought by the National Confederation of Industries, and dealt with the constitutionality of Brazil’s CFC rules.

Minister Barbosa is the chief justice of the Supreme Federal Court and brought his own interpretation into the judgment.

The taxpayers were arguing that Article 74 of Brazilian Provisional Measure 2,158-34/2001 (the CFC rules), which says that profits earned by controlled and associated companies abroad should be considered available for the Brazilian controller or associated company at the date on the balance sheet in which they have been assessed, was unconstitutional. They argued that the rules do not properly reflect the point at which non-distributed profits of foreign subsidiaries are made available to Brazilian shareholders, and so disregard the constitutional concept of income for taxation purposes.

In an earlier consideration of the issue, which resulted in an incomplete judgment with only nine of the eleven justices issuing decisions, Barbosa held that the action was well-founded in part. According to Barbosa, when interpreted in accordance with the Federal Constitution of 1988, Article 74 may only apply to the taxation of legal entities domiciled in Brazil whose controlled or related companies are located in tax havens.

And in April when the case was finally concluded, it was Barbosa’s interpretation that was adopted by a majority of six.

The Global Tax 50 2013

« Previous

Danny Alexander

View the complete list

Next »

Piet Battiau

more across site & shared bottom lb ros

More from across our site

Jaap Zwaan’s arrival continues a recent streak of A&M Tax investing in the region; in other news, the US and Japan struck a deal that significantly lowered tariff rates
In a world where international tax concepts rely on human activity, Leonard Wagenaar poses existential questions about the future of such ideas when AI is ever-present
France v Axa provides a practical illustration of how the burden of proof is applied in TP matters under French law, ITR also heard
In an exclusive interview with ITR, Ian Gary calls for a central public CbCR database and bemoans the US’s lack of involvement in international tax transparency
Reckitt Benckiser is to divest its Essential Home business, which includes more than 70 brands, to private equity firm Advent International
In the first of a new series of weekly opinion pieces, ITR Editor Tom Baker reflects on the OECD’s attempts to sanitise the US’s brazen pillar two negotiations
The threat of 50% tariffs on Brazilian goods coincides with new Brazilian legal powers to adopt retaliatory economic measures, local experts tell ITR
The country’s chancellor appears to have backtracked from previous pillar two scepticism; in other news, Donald Trump threatened Russia with 100% tariffs
In its latest G20 update, the OECD also revealed tense discussions with the US where the ‘significant threat’ of Section 899 was highlighted
The tax agency has increased compliance yield from wealthy individuals but cannot identify how much tax is paid by UK billionaires, the committee also claimed
Gift this article