Date set for Canadian St Michael Trust Corp showdown

International Tax Review is part of Legal Benchmarking Limited, 1-2 Paris Garden, London, SE1 8ND

Copyright © Legal Benchmarking Limited and its affiliated companies 2026

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement


Date set for Canadian St Michael Trust Corp showdown

canada.jpg

The Supreme Court of Canada is preparing itself for a March 13 hearing of the St Michael Trust Corp dispute on the tax residence of a trust.

$450 million of capital gains realised by Barbados-constituted trusts are at stake. The Canada Revenue Agency says that the trusts owe Canadian income tax on the gains realised as residents of Canada. Yet, were these trusts resident in Canada or the Barbados? Memoranda of fact and law are filed.

The taxpayer's argument is simple and seductive. The tax residence of a trust should be determined with reference to the residence of the trustee and not based on a central management and control (CMC) test because a trust is not a separate person like a corporation but a legal relationship. The taxpayer asserts that this interpretation is consistent with the language in the Canadian Income Tax Act.

Nonetheless, the Crown won the battles in the two courts below. It argues that Canadian tax law will be consistent and fair if the CMC test is applied to trusts. The CMC test is fact-driven and flexible unlike the arbitrary and rigid interpretation of the taxpayers. The test determines residence correctly, especially if the trustee actually exercises no powers over the trust property. In this case the Crown asserts that the evidentiary record points to two Canadian individual residents having made all substantive decisions relating to dispositions of shares owned by the Barbados trusts. The Crown has acknowledged that the trusts were properly constituted with no allegation of sham-a point argued in other Canadian cases.

The Crown further argues that another statutory anti-avoidance rule (section 94) deemed the trusts to be Canadian residents. In the alternative, the Crown asserts that the Canadian general anti-avoidance rule(GAAR) should be applied to prevent an abusive interpretation of the Canada-Barbados tax convention. Neither of these arguments prevailed in the lower courts. Given the court's GAAR decision in Copthorne on December 16 2011, it is unlikely that new legal principles will emerge in this regard.

No doubt tax advisers around the Commonwealth will be watching with great interest and will be interested in the precedential value of the decision outside of Canada.

Ed Kroft QC (ed.kroft@blakes.com) of Blake, Cassels & Graydon.

more across site & shared bottom lb ros

More from across our site

The stars of Weil’s heavyweight tax practices are up for grabs, but recruiting firms will need to be patient to secure a package deal
Meta has overtaken Amazon as the ‘Silicon Six’ business with the worst tax conduct, according to the Fair Tax Foundation
Awards
It was also a memorable night for Baker McKenzie and its associated firms, after picking up 19 awards, including the coveted Asia-Pacific Tax Law Firm of the Year
Stocche Forbes Advogados, Utumi Advogados and Lobo de Rizzo Advogados have reached Tier 2 as competition intensifies in the region’s largest tax market
Ben Webster’s arrival represents a significant expansion of Withers’ London tax litigation practice, as the private client firm eyes further international growth
The combination swiftly builds on RSM’s addition of a new Lithuanian firm to its international network, signalling a European build-out
Tax teams must look beyond pillar two’s headline rules as R&D incentives and the US side-by-side deal create new strategic choices for multinationals, says Marta Pankiv of Tricentis
As funds work becomes more complex, Proskauer is betting that embedded tax expertise can strengthen its wider offering
The recently founded AI platform stands out in a crowded marketplace thanks to a compelling vision and friends in the right places
Advisers expect consumption tax reform to stay on course, but debt pressures could push the government towards tougher enforcement and incentive reviews
Gift this article