On February 12 2004 Advocate General (AG) Kokott issued her opinion in the Weidert and Paulus case (C-242/03). According to the AG, the fact that Luxembourg grants an income tax investment allowance for investments in shares of domestic companies but not for investments in shares of non-resident companies violates the free-movement-of-capital principle (article 56 of the EC Treaty) because it puts investors in shares of foreign companies and foreign companies seeking Luxembourg investors at a disadvantage. Such a restriction cannot be justified by coherence of the Luxembourg tax system or by article 58 of the EC Treaty, which prohibits arbitrary discrimination or disguised restrictions on the free movement of capital.
March 01 2004