Two decisions from the House of Lords, the UK's highest court, have failed to give definitive guidance on tax avoidance in the UK. In the Scottish Provident case, which the Inland Revenue won, the law lords ruled on November 25 2004 that a court may need to consider a series of transactions when applying a tax law. But in a separate ruling on the same day, the Inland Revenue lost a verdict to Barclays Mercantile which confirmed that business purpose may not be necessary to enjoy a tax benefit. See the February 2005 issue for full-length feature.
December 01 2004