ITR Pillar Two Forum: New regime to supplant state aid pushback on favourable rulings

International Tax Review is part of Legal Benchmarking Limited, 4 Bouverie Street, London, EC4Y 8AX

Copyright © Legal Benchmarking Limited and its affiliated companies 2025

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

ITR Pillar Two Forum: New regime to supplant state aid pushback on favourable rulings

JamesAndersenPillar2.JPG
James Anderson, of Skadden, speaking at the ITR Pillar Two Forum 2024

The head of Skadden’s European tax practice said the recent Apple CJEU ruling could be the last of its kind as pillar two develops

Pillar two offers more tools for regulators and other countries against global group tax rate management, and could mark the end of an era in state aid enforcement, a speaker at the ITR Pillar Two Forum said on Thursday, September 19.

James Anderson, head of the European tax practice at law firm Skadden in London, said Apple’s recent court defeat over state aid rules might appear irrelevant to pillar two but could in fact be the “high watermark” of such activity due to the arrival of the new tax regime.

In a major victory for the European Commission, the Court of Justice of the EU ruled on September 10 that Apple had to repay Ireland €13 billion ($14.5 billion) in unpaid taxes, in a long-running battle over two tax decisions relating to transfer pricing arrangements.

“It’s almost speaking to a redundant law from the competition world that won’t need to be applied to tax rulings any more,” said Anderson, who argued that the new pillar two regime including its undertaxed profits rule gives authorities more tools to play with.

Anderson and his colleague Jisun Choi, also a partner at Skadden, were speaking in a session called ‘What does the future hold for pillar two?’ at ITR’s inaugural event focusing on the new rules.

One of their key topics was the impact on M&A deals, a potentially complex side-effect of pillar two. The partners walked through several M&A scenarios and considerations, including modelling, due diligence and separation planning.

They also assessed whether private equity houses will have an advantage over multinational trade buyers or sellers, with Choi saying they possibly will.

She added that joint ventures (JVs) will be “particularly tricky” because a typical JV is not deemed to be as such within the meaning of the GloBE rules.

Anderson said that some entities may look for workarounds to pillar two by setting up as funds rather than corporates, as funds are not within scope if the fund or manager is regulated. He admitted, however, that this is “beset with difficulty, extremely complicated and fraught with PR issues”.

On the future of pillar two, Anderson likened the new regime to a “living beast” with a new set of rules or administrative changes every six months. When asked to predict what the next 25 years might look like, he said that a global enforcement regime for the tax levied rules – rather than just a set of principles for each country to apply – was likely.


more across site & shared bottom lb ros

More from across our site

The US law firm’s tax counsel tells ITR about inspirations from a ‘legendary’ German tax scholar, perfecting riesling wine and what makes tax cool
Wopke Hoekstra also swore the EU would ‘hit back harder’ if faced with a trade war; in other news, a UK watchdog has launched an investigation into an audit completed by MHA
Other reasons included the complexity of reporting, resource constraints and interactions with tax administrations
Despite this boost for investors, the OECD also said that extensive reliance on income-based instruments across economies is concerning
A recent UK First-tier Tribunal decision highlights the broad application of an anti-avoidance rule to deny tax relief, say Robert Waterson and Matthew Cummings of Eversheds Sutherland
The world’s largest legal market is typically alive with activity, with tax firms jostling for position ahead of the World Tax Rankings and ITR Awards
Public funding will allow the firm to invest in lateral hires, technology and further bolt-on acquisitions, MHA said
William Paul is being replaced as IRS chief counsel just two months after starting, it is understood
Wopke Hoekstra implored US officials to ‘truly look into the facts’; in other news, the EU Council has reached a political agreement on DAC9
The US president’s flippant approach to international trade will cause chaos for corporations, but there are opportunities for intrepid tax advisers
Gift this article