All material subject to strictly enforced copyright laws. © 2022 ITR is part of the Euromoney Institutional Investor PLC group.

Indian GAAR committee submits recommendations to government

indian-flagsmall.jpg

The committee charged with providing the Indian government with recommendations on the implementation of the general anti-avoidance rules (GAAR) has submitted its findings, including recommendations regarding the threshold for triggering GAAR and its application for foreign institutional investors.

The guidelines propose that rather than applying to the entire transaction, GAAR should be applicable only to the part that is considered an impermissible avoidance arrangement.

To ensure consistency and avoid indiscriminate application, the guidelines suggest a monetary threshold should be put in place for GAAR to be invoked. However, no threshold was specified.

The committee also proposes implementing time limits for completing the GAAR process so that resolution can be achieved in a timely manner. The committee “feels there should be absolute certainty about the time limits during which the various actions under the GAAR provisions are to be completed” and therefore advocates a 60 day response time for each stage of the process.

It also stated that “no action shall be taken by the Commissioner after the period of six months from the end of the month in which the reference was received by the Commissioner”.

The following special recommendations were made in relation to the treatment of foreign institutional investors (FIIs):

  • The committee recommends that the GAAR provisions not apply to FIIs when their tax treatment is based on Indian domestic law and not on a beneficial tax treaty.

  • However, GAAR should not be invoked against non-resident investors of the FII regardless of whether the FII has claimed any tax treaty benefits.

The committee had discussions with the Asia Securities Industry & Financial Markets Association and Capital Markets Tax Committee of Asia, during which the groups proposed that capital markets transactions be exempt from GAAR and that a flat tax on FII’s gains be introduced. Both of these proposals were rejected, with the committee saying they were not permissible under the Income Tax Act.

Mixed reactions

There have been mixed reactions to the draft guidelines, with Mukesh Butani, partner at BMR, saying they do not contain anything surprising, but that there are “some misses and some good [recommendations]”.

“The recommendations appear to permit scenarios of tax mitigation, which are distinguished from tax avoidance transactions,” said a PwC alert, which also welcomed the fact that application would not be retroactive. “It is also a positive recommendation that GAAR should apply only to income accruing or arising on or after April 1 2013.”

Butani believes there is still a need for further progress on the issue, though, before GAAR may be implemented.

“Let’s say this is a decent first draft,” he said. “There is a lot of work [still] to be done.”

He said more consultation is required, and that there needs to be clarification as to the capacity of GAAR to override treaty provisions.

“The guidance needs wider debates,” said Butani. “A fundamental issue is that the treaty provisions should not be overridden by GAAR. If they are, there should be specific instances.”

This issue could also have implications for the India-Mauritius tax treaty, though uncertainty remains with regards to this.

“Since the amended GAAR provisions shift the onus to prove tax evasion to the authorities, the government may want to negotiate a limitation of benefits clause with Mauritius instead of negotiations of a wholesome manner,” said Amit Singhania, principal associate at Amarchand & Mangaldas.

While the authorities would find it useful in increasing the number of tools they have at their disposal, whether a renegotiation is necessary – or likely – is still in doubt.

“The need for revision of the treaty is not required now, as the tax authorities – after the introduction of GAAR – will have enough powers to deny treaty benefit to taxpayers that fail to prove the substance of the transaction,” said Singhania.

The final guidelines may be slightly different from those outlined by the committee, with the next steps including a two week period for response.

“There is a 15 day window for reaction. It would be debated by the Department of Revenue before issuance,” said Butani.

The draft GAAR guidelines will also be discussed at International Tax Review's third annual India Tax Forum in Delhi on September 5 & 6.

Confirmed speakers include: RN Dash, ex-Director General of Income Tax (International Taxation), Government of India; Girish Srivastava, ex-Director General of Income Tax (International Taxation), Government of India; Mohan Parasaran, Senior Advocate, Supreme Court of India and Additional Solicitor General of India; Prashant Bhatnagar, head of India tax, Procter & Gamble; and R Mani, head of India tax, Tata

The foremost Indian tax specialists will tackle this issue and more. It is a unique opportunity to hear their views, increase your understanding of the upcoming changes and how best to prepare for the future.

More from across our site

The state secretary told the French press that the country continues to oppose pillar two’s global minimum tax rate following an Ecofin meeting last week.
This week the Biden administration has run into opposition over a proposal for a federal gas tax holiday, while the European Parliament has approved a plan for an EU carbon border mechanism.
Businesses need to improve on data management to ensure tax departments become much more integrated, according to Microsoft’s chief digital officer at a KPMG event.
Businesses must ensure any alternative benchmark rate is included in their TP studies and approved by tax authorities, as Libor for the US ends in exactly a year.
Tax directors warn that a lack of adequate planning for VAT rule changes could leave businesses exposed to regulatory errors and costly fines.
Tax professionals have urged suppliers of goods from Great Britain to Northern Ireland to pause any plans to restructure their supply chains following the NI Protocol Bill.
Tax leaders say communication with peers is important for risk management, especially on how to approach regional authorities.
Advances in compliance tools in international markets and the digitalisation of global tax administrations are increasing in-house demand for technologists.
The US fast-food company has agreed to pay €1.25 billion to settle the French investigation into its transfer pricing arrangements over allegations of tax evasion.
HM Revenue and Customs said the UK pillar two legislation will be delayed until at least December 2023, while ITR reported on a secret Netflix settlement and an IMF study on VAT cuts.
We use cookies to provide a personalized site experience.
By continuing to use & browse the site you agree to our Privacy Policy.
I agree