In a July 4 opinion, the court ruled that the double taxation avoidance agreement (DTAA) between India and Germany did not restrict disclosure of information about tax abusers in public court proceedings.
This issue is of particular importance in light of the fact that in 2009 the German government provided India with the names of 15 Indian individuals and trusts that were allegedly hiding assets in tax accounts in LGT bank of Lichtenstein.
German opposition parties argued for the names to be released, arguing that it the public had the right to the information.
The Indian government, including Prime Minister Manmohan Singh, argued that it could not reveal the names of the individuals to the public since Germany only shared the information on a confidential basis.
In a recent public interest litigation (PIL) brought before the Indian Supreme Court, the petitioners urged the court to release the names.
Although the most important and widely reported aspect of the PIL involved the creation of a special investigation team to look into unaccounted money that Indians are hiding in foreign banks, the Supreme Court also used this opportunity to comment on DTAAs and exchange of information agreements in the treaty between Germany and India.
“While the petitioners had demanded the names of such individuals, they were not provided with the names on the reasoning that it’s not in accordance with the provisions of article 26 of the tax treaty and it’s proscribed by the tax treaty from disclosing such information,” said Ganesh Pai, manager at Ernst & Young in Bangalore.
“The provisions of article 26 of the India German DTAA (tax treaty) provides for the tax authorities of both the states to exchange information which is necessary for carrying out the purposes of the tax treaty,” said Pai.
”Further, it provides that any information received shall be treated as secret, which however, can be disclosed to persons and authorities, including courts and administrative bodies involved in assessment, collection, and enforcement, with respect to the taxes covered under the tax treaty and the same can also be disclosed in public court proceedings and judicial proceedings,”Pai added.
The court rejected the idea that the phrase “public court proceedings” in article 26 refers only to specific tax proceedings, and instead found that an appropriate reading of the treaty would show that the disclosure is also appropriate in other types of litigation, including the present case before the Supreme Court.
“The fact that such treaties are drafted by diplomats, and not lawyers, leading to sloppiness in drafting also implies that care has to be taken so as to not render any word, phrase, or sentence redundant, especially where the same would lead to a manifestly absurd situation, particularly from a constitutional perspective,” said Pai. “These observations by the [Supreme Court] should be useful in interpreting tax treaties in general.”
The Supreme Court’s clarification of the interpretation of tax treaties will no doubt be useful in the future, as the individuals involved with the Lichtenstein banks only represent a small portion of the black money problem.
Indians have hundreds of billions of dollars hidden away offshore in tax haven jurisdictions such as Switzerland, according to R Vaidyanathan, professor of finance at the Indian Institute of Management. Efforts to review DTAAs with these countries have been lagging.
Under the India-Switzerland DTAA that is now in effect, information on the Swiss bank accounts of Indian residents may not be disclosed until the Indian government first comes up with evidence of criminality tied to these banking transactions.