All material subject to strictly enforced copyright laws. © 2022 ITR is part of the Euromoney Institutional Investor PLC group.

US Inbound: Altera decision reversal withdrawn

The court has withdrawn its decision

The Ninth Circuit reversed, and then withdrew its reversal of, the Tax Court's unanimous 'reviewed by the court' decision in Altera Corp. v. Commissioner, 145 T.C. 91 (2015), and held in a 2-1 decision that Treas. Reg. § 1.482-7(d)(2), requiring related entities to share the cost of employee stock compensation (the 2003 Regulation) was a valid regulation.

The decision, and more so the court's opinion itself, came as major surprises, as did the court's subsequent withdrawal of its opinion.

The Ninth Circuit, in holding for the IRS, would have permitted the IRS to take the US off the § 482 arm's-length standard, which has long been the transfer pricing standard in the US and most foreign countries. It sanctioned a transfer pricing result based on internal analyses only and without regard to what unrelated parties do. So, while the IRS got the result it wanted in Altera, the rationale of the decision conflicts with the US government's rigorous defence of the arm's-length standard in the BEPS proceedings. Indeed, the decision highlights the inherent contradiction in the IRS's position – it wants a non-arm's length result, but under the cover of a purported application of the arm's-length standard. The IRS cannot have it both ways, as the decision made clear.

One of the judges in the majority, Judge Reinhardt, passed away four months before the case was officially decided and the opinions filed. A footnote stated that he fully participated in the case and formally concurred in the majority opinion prior to his death. However, it is not clear whether he had read the final opinion or the strong dissenting opinion by Judge O'Malley.

In a surprising post-decision development, a new judge was appointed to the court's three-judge Altera panel to replace Judge Reinhardt. The court's decision had already been published and its opinion filed only two weeks earlier. The new judge was presumably appointed to the panel in case there was need for a re-hearing. The second surprising post-decision development came a week later when the court announced that its opinion was being withdrawn "to allow time for the reconstituted panel to confer on this appeal". This second post-decision development was welcome, given the negative reaction of the tax community, the apparent conflict with the Ninth Circuit's earlier decision in Xilinx, and the conflict the opinion created with transfer pricing law in the rest of the US. Re-argument in the case is scheduled for October 16 2018.

The result, if sustained by the reconstituted Ninth Circuit panel, will likely result in two transfer pricing systems in the US: East of Rockies (arm's length) and West of Rockies (an anything goes 'internal dealings/ignore comparables/commensurate with income' system). We wonder what the IRS will do in its Advance Pricing Agreement Program and under Treas. Reg. § 1.6662-4 regarding the tax return transfer pricing documentation requirements. Will there be two standards, one for EOR and the other for WOR? It would also be interesting to hear the Treasury's explanations to foreign countries regarding the US's tax treaties (all of which adopt the arm's-length standard), and, better yet, its explanations to the Senate regarding the numerous pending tax treaties. It is the IRS itself, so far, that has won (or forced) the case that led to the two different US transfer pricing systems.

This will undoubtedly open up vast new transfer pricing opportunities, for example, to inbound (foreign-based) taxpayers with US subsidiaries. Only time will tell what the future holds.

more across site & bottom lb ros

More from across our site

Incoming amendments to the treaty could increase costs on non-resident Indian service providers.
Experts say the proposed minimum tax does not align with the OECD’s pillar two regime and risks other countries pulling out.
The Malawian government has targeted US gemstone miner Columbia Gem House, while Amgen has successfully consolidated two separate tax disputes with the Internal Revenue Service.
ITR's latest quarterly PDF is now live, leading on the rise of tax technology.
ITR is delighted to reveal all the shortlisted firms, teams, and practitioners for the 2022 Americas Tax Awards – winners to be announced on September 22
‘Care’ is the operative word as HMRC seeks to clamp down on transfer pricing breaches next year.
Tax directors tell ITR that the CRA’s clampdown on unpaid taxes on insurance premiums is causing uncertainty for businesses as they try to stay compliant.
HMRC has informed tax directors that it will impose automated assessments on online sellers with inaccurate VAT returns, in a bid to fight fraud.
UK businesses need to reset after the Upper Tribunal ruled against BlackRock over interest deductions it claimed on $4 billion in inter-company loans, say sources.
Hong Kong SAR’s incoming regime for foreign income exemptions could remove it from an EU tax watchlist but hand Singapore top spot in APAC.
We use cookies to provide a personalized site experience.
By continuing to use & browse the site you agree to our Privacy Policy.
I agree