International Tax Review is part of the Delinian Group, Delinian Limited, 8 Bouverie Street, London, EC4Y 8AX, Registered in England & Wales, Company number 00954730
Copyright © Delinian Limited and its affiliated companies 2023

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

Italy: Intercompany charges, cost inherence and deductibility

Sponsored by


In general terms, inherence can be described as the relationship between the cost and the enterprise, where the cost has a specific relevance to the determination of income; this is a result of its connection not to a specific revenue, but rather to an activity potentially able to produce income. Based on this assumption, in order to consider a cost deductible (i.e. inherent), the taxpayer is required to demonstrate clearly the connection with the activity, providing the tax authority with "sufficient" documentation.

The Italian Supreme Court recently ruled on this topic (decision no. 20113/18) regarding the deductibility of costs associated with the construction of swap bodies (casse mobili). The ruling involved Italian company ITA Co, which specialises in the manufacture of semi-trailers, containers, fittings for vehicles, ISO and special containers. The local tax authorities disregarded the deductions of costs incurred by ITA related to the construction of swap bodies, citing a lack of inherence. The adjustment filed by the tax authorities was challenged by the taxpayer, first before the local Court of First Instance, then before the Regional Tax Court (Commissione Regionale della Lombardia – sez. Distaccata di Brescia). In line with the latter's decision, the Supreme Court upheld the taxpayer's arguments and rejected those put forward by the tax authorities.

The case can be summarised as follows. ITA conducts all activities (and bears the related costs) necessary to build swap bodies. Then, it sells the finished products to a leasing company (or LCo). The LCo leases the swap bodies to a company controlled by ITA. The swap bodies are then rented by ITA, which gives them to its clients as a gratuitous loan for the period necessary to provide them with new swap bodies, which are regularly purchased and paid for. The price paid by the end client is sufficient to remunerate the initial rent under the gratuitous loan.

The Supreme Court stressed that – in line with the current jurisprudence – the judgment on the inherence of the cost refers to the corporate object of the enterprise "in the sense that it is deductible if it is functional to the single social activities or, in any case, if it brings to the enterprise a useful, objectively determinable and adequately documented".

Under this view, the inherence does not in essence integrate a link between costs and revenues, but is essentially related to the correlation between costs and company activity, even if only potentially capable of generating taxable income. Regarding intragroup relations, the inherence of the cost, within the limits of reasonableness and proportionality, is connected to the concepts of coherence and economic utility "interpreted as indexes of the existence or not of the inherence rather than essential requirements".

In conclusion, the inherence of the costs paid by a company belonging to a multinational group must be evaluated according to the criterion of coherence and the economic usefulness of the entire activity carried out by the group. Therefore, the application of these criteria must essentially bring out the advantages gained by all the companies belonging to the group and not only those gained by a single company.

more across site & bottom lb ros

More from across our site

‘Go on leave, effective immediately’, PwC has told nine partners in the latest development in the firm’s ongoing tax scandal.
The forum heard that VAT professionals are struggling under new pressures to validate transactions and catch fraud, responsibilities that they say should lie with governments.
The working paper suggested a new framework for boosting effective carbon rates and reducing the inconsistency of climate policy.
UAE firm Virtuzone launches ‘TaxGPT’, claiming it is the first AI-powered tax tool, while the Australian police faces claims of a conflict of interest over its PwC audit contract.
The US technology company is defending its past Irish tax arrangements at the CJEU in a final showdown that could have major political repercussions.
ITR’s Indirect Tax Forum heard that Italy’s VAT investigation into Meta has the potential to set new and expensive tax principles that would likely be adopted around the world
Police are now investigating the leak of confidential tax information by a former PwC partner at the request of the Australian government.
A VAT policy officer at the European Commission told the forum that the initial deadline set for EU convergence of domestic digital VAT reporting is likely to be extended.
The UK government shows little sign of cutting corporate tax, while a growing number of businesses report a decline in investment as a result of the higher tax burden.
Mariana Morais Teixeira of Morais Leitão overviews Portugal’s new tax incentive regime designed to boost the country’s capital-depleted private sector.