India: Delhi’s High Court maintains that overseas GE entities have a PE in India

International Tax Review is part of Legal Benchmarking Limited, 4 Bouverie Street, London, EC4Y 8AX

Copyright © Legal Benchmarking Limited and its affiliated companies 2025

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

India: Delhi’s High Court maintains that overseas GE entities have a PE in India

Sponsored by

logo.png
tax-court-case-320x215

Delhi High Court (HC) has confirmed the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal's decision that various overseas entities of the GE Group had a fixed place, permanent establishment (PE), and a dependent agent PE in India.

The entities in question had sold their products to customers in India on a principal-to-principal basis, and the title to such products passed to customers outside India. However, expatriate employees and employees of an Indian entity participated in the negotiation of contracts (including in areas relating to warranty, pricing, delivery, etc.). As a result, an issue arose regarding whether this could trigger a taxable presence for the overseas entities.

There are several important aspects that are considered in this decision, specifically with regards to the scope of the preparatory and auxiliary exclusion, as well as the situations in which a dependent agency PE can be constituted.

Fixed place permanent establishment

The High Court upheld the factual findings of the Tribunal, noting that the office space of the overseas entities liaison office in India was at the disposal of the overseas entities. This was based on the finding that specific chambers/rooms and secretarial staff were allotted to GE staff, and were used by them for their work.

The High Court also concluded that the core sales activity was conducted from these premises and, therefore, the business of the overseas entities could be said to have been carried out from such premises.

More importantly, the High Court rejected the contention of GE that the activities in India were of a preparatory and auxiliary character. It noted that considering the highly specialised and technically customised equipment manufactured by the GE entities, the activities of identifying and approaching the customer, communicating available options to the customer, discussing technical and financial terms, and price negotiations were core activities. It went on to conclude that the discharge of vital responsibilities relating to the finalisation of commercial terms, as well as having a prominent involvement in the contract finalisation process, would lead to the overseas entities continuing business in India through its fixed place of business.

The High Court also rejected GE's contention that since the expatriate employees and employees of the Indian entity did not have the authority to conclude contracts, the activities could not be anything other than preparatory and auxiliary in nature. It held that the existence of such authority was not relevant in determining whether the activities were preparatory or auxiliary in nature.

Agency permanent establishment

The High Court also upheld the finding of the Tribunal that the activities in India constituted a dependent agent PE for the overseas entities. In this regard, the court relied on the Italian decision in Ministry of Finance (Tax Office) v. Philip Morris (GmbH), Core Suprema di Cassazione (No. 7682/02 of May 25 2002). The case concluded that the participation of representatives (or employees) of a resident company that is in a phase of concluding a contract between a foreign enterprise and a customer, can fall within the concept of 'authority to conclude contracts', even in the absence of a formal power of representation.

Attribution of profits

The High Court also upheld the attribution of profits to the PE at 3.5% of the total value of supplies made to the customers in India.

more across site & shared bottom lb ros

More from across our site

Countries which care about fair taxation of tech multinationals and equitable global distribution of wealth should back the UN’s tax framework, writes economist Abdelmalek Riad
The cuts disproportionately affected staff in certain positions, the report also found; in other news, MHA announced the €24m acquisition of Baker Tilly South East Europe
The plan aims to improve the efficiency, transparency, and effectiveness of direct tax administration in India
Meanwhile, South Africa’s finance minister has accepted a court decision on suspending a VAT increase and US President Donald Trump mulls a 100% tariff on foreign films
Jaime Carey speaks about the benefits of his tax background, DEI values, the use of AI for a smarter legal practice, and other priorities that will define his presidency
Historically low levels of attrition over consecutive years made a ‘difficult decision’ necessary, PwC has reportedly said
WTS Global is also vetting new potential member firms in Algeria, Cote D’Ivoire and Benin, Kelly Mgbor tells ITR in an exclusive interview
The scope of qualifying pillar two tax credits could reportedly be broadened; in other news, hundreds of IRS appeals staff are to resign
For many taxpayers, the prospect of long-term certainty that a bilateral APA offers can override concerns about time, cost and confidentiality
Levine, who served under the Joe Biden administration, led the US’s negotiations on the OECD’s two-pillar solution
Gift this article