The transfer pricing reforms focus mainly on the documentation that the tax authorities may request to verify the arm’s-length nature of intercompany prices.
The documentation falls into two categories: some documents are to describe the intercompany transactions and others explain the calculation of arm’s-length prices. Detailed clarification of the required documentation will be welcomed by taxpayers who have in the past struggled to know what would be requested during audit.
Documents describing the intercompany transactions will include many elements of a functional and risk analysis that are familiar internationally, as well as specific disclosures as to financial results for the transactions for both the Japanese taxpayer and its foreign related parties. Documents supporting the calculation of arm’s-length prices should describe, for example, the method(s) applied, selection of comparables and adjustments made.
At the moment, the tax authorities are allowed to impose an estimated or presumptive tax assessment, which could include the use of undisclosed comparable prices to make a transfer pricing adjustment, when documentation is not submitted.
This presumptive tax assessment has proved problematic in the past, so advance preparation of documents supporting the taxpayers' arm's-length approach is recommended to avoid having to argue the presumptive assessments.
While documentation has been requested in National Tax Agency (NTA) audits, advisers warn the specification of these requirements could signal a more aggressive stance on intercompany pricing by Japanese authorities.
Unresolved issues in the transfer pricing regulations and documentation requirements that are still under discussion include the identification of controlled parties, how ranges of arm’s-length calculation results could be applied, the hierarchy of transfer pricing methods, selecting comparable prices from multiple potential comparable transactions, the use of secret comparables and improvements to the advance pricing agreement process.