US Inbound: Obama Budget proposals: Tax corporate distributions as dividends

International Tax Review is part of Legal Benchmarking Limited, 1-2 Paris Garden, London, SE1 8ND

Copyright © Legal Benchmarking Limited and its affiliated companies 2025

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

US Inbound: Obama Budget proposals: Tax corporate distributions as dividends

fuller.jpg

forst.jpg

Jim Fuller


David Forst

We discussed some of the new Obama Budget proposals last month. The Budget also has a category of proposed changes entitled 'tax corporate distributions as dividends'. These proposals are not targeted solely at international transactions, but can be important internationally. We will discuss two. Unless or until these proposals become law, they may present planning opportunities. One of these proposals focuses on a planning opportunity to permit corporate distributions to be tax-free to the company's shareholders. The plan involves having the corporation distribute stock in a subsidiary or subsidiaries having a high basis but minimal value. The goal is to reduce earnings and profits before making a large distribution to shareholders in the subsequent tax year.

Assume, for example, a foreign-owned US corporation (P) owns all of the common and preferred stock of a US subsidiary (S). P has $1 billion in accumulated earnings and profits. The preferred stock has a value of $10 million, but a basis of $1 billion because of previous dividend-equivalent redemptions in which P received $990 million in cash. Under current law, if an actual or deemed redemption of stock is treated as equivalent to a dividend, the shareholder's basis in any remaining shares of the corporation is increased by the shareholder's basis in the redeemed stock. Thus, the remaining preferred stock has a high basis, even though it has a low value.

If P distributes its $10 million of S preferred stock to its foreign shareholder, P would permanently eliminate any earnings and profits equal to the adjusted basis of the distributed stock ($1 billion). In the following year, P could distribute its accumulated cash of $990 million to its foreign shareholder and avoid dividend characterisation, and any resulting US withholding tax.

Under the Obama Budget proposal, a corporation's distribution of stock of another corporation would reduce the distributing corporation's earnings and profits by the greater of the stock's fair market value or the corporation's basis in the stock. For this purpose, the distributing corporation's basis in the distributed stock would be determined without regard to any adjustments as a result of actual or deemed dividend-equivalent redemptions by S and without regard to any other distributions or transactions undertaken with the view to create and distribute high-basis S stock.

The second of the Obama dividend proposals addresses another avenue through which the earnings and profits of a US corporation may be distributed to its foreign shareholders without being characterised as a dividend. In this case, the cash-rich corporation with earnings and profits funds a second, related corporation that does not have earnings and profits. Funding transactions could include capital contributions, loans, or distributions to the distributing corporation.

Under the proposal, to the extent the funding corporation has funded the other corporation with a principal purpose of avoiding dividend treatment, the amount would be treated as a dividend from the funding corporation.

Jim Fuller (jpfuller@fenwick.com) and David Forst (dforst@fenwick.com)

Fenwick & West

Tel: +1 650 335 7205; +1 650 335 7274

Website: www.fenwick.com

more across site & shared bottom lb ros

More from across our site

The US’s GILTI regime will not be forced upon American multinationals in foreign jurisdictions, Bloomberg has reported; in other news, Ropes & Gray hired two tax partners from Linklaters
APAs should provide a pragmatic means to agree to an arm's-length outcome for an Australian entity and for the ATO, the tax authority said
Overall revenues and average profit per partner also increased in the UK, the ‘big four’ firm revealed
Increasingly complex reporting requirements contributed towards the firm’s growth in tax, it said
Sector-specific business taxes, private equity tax treatment reform and changes to the taxation of non-residents are all on the cards for the UK, authors from Herbert Smith Freehills Kramer predict
The UK’s Labour government has an unpopular prime minister, an unpopular chancellor and not a lot of good options as it prepares to deliver its autumn Budget
Awards
The firms picked up five major awards between them at a gala ceremony held at New York’s prestigious Metropolitan Club
The streaming company’s operating income was $400m below expectations following the dispute; in other news, the OECD has released updates for 25 TP country profiles
Software company Oracle has won the right to have its A$250m dispute with the ATO stayed, paving the way for a mutual agreement procedure
If the US doesn't participate in pillar two then global consensus on the project can’t be a reality, tax academic René Matteotti also suggests
Gift this article