|
Anyone involved in mandatory e-filing received mixed responses from HMRC |
Having reached the end of the first year of mandatory iXBRL e-filing of tax computations and statutory accounts to HMRC, you know whether you are celebrating or commiserating. Certainly, various corporate tax filers have discovered a number of problems with the new regime; almost all related to the iXBRL accounts part of the new process.
|
Steve Jeffels: In Europe you need to share compliance tools |
There have been a number of practical issues with implementing new software or upgrading systems with many users having to spend significant amounts of time in dealing with this. In a survey conducted by Thomson Reuters with the Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales (ICAEW), more than 67% of respondents said that the transition had been difficult or worse than expected and half said they were spending an average of over seven hours extra per set of accounts. This additional time is spent ensuring that tagging is correct, valid, appropriate and sufficient as well as dealing with exceptions and validation issues. The new requirements also presented companies with a steep learning curve. So what have we learnt from year one?
Conversion solutions should ease making decisions when it comes to applying tags without disrupting the existing accounting process. If you have to use a tagging solution on accounts generated by a production solution then a change of direction is worth considering. In the large corporate environment applying a rigorous judgement and review in the first cycle of tagging may be the only way to have confidence in the tags applied. If, however, these initial judgements can be captured across multiple sets of accounts, robustly re-applied to other companies and other years, then the incremental time cost is very low, as is the additional review time cost.
When iXBRL was first launched, there were suggestions of mandatory filing from Companies House as well as the imminent retirement of UK GAAP. Both were seen as disrupters to the iXBRL roll out and were part of the reasoning behind the soft landing period. UK GAAP's retirement date has since been extended and has now been pushed back to 2015 or later. HMRC has also announced that the deferral of the use of the full tagging list will continue beyond the initial two years of managing the transition.
As products have developed and companies have begun to understand the actual reality of iXBRL filing during the first year, it now seems to be the right time to look towards planning and implementing changes for future iXBRL compliance. In 18 months time, we will all need to be preparing for the move to IFRS, considering Companies House filings and possible changes to the taxonomies. We can expect to see this approach replicated in other parts of the world. Ireland has already announced plans to adopt iXBRL filing in 2013 and the Netherlands are mandating accounts filing in iXBRL from 2014. If you are in a European group then sharing compliance tools into other territories will reduce ownership costs and save on training.
To download a copy of Smoothing your path to compliance visit: thomsonreuters.com/content/tax_accounting/pdf/abacus/ixbrl_white_paper.pdf