Tax havens seek greater international cooperation

International Tax Review is part of Legal Benchmarking Limited, 1-2 Paris Garden, London, SE1 8ND

Copyright © Legal Benchmarking Limited and its affiliated companies 2026

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement


Tax havens seek greater international cooperation

The worldwide drive against the use of tax havens and opaque banking systems to evade taxation, led by the OECD, has manifested itself in many forms. Andrew Watt, tax investigations consultant, analyses the latest of these forms.

When it comes to the agreement between the Swiss Confederation (Switzerland) and the UK on Cooperation in the Area of Taxation, there is a widespread misconception that this process began with the April 2009 G20 meeting in London, chaired by the then Prime Minister Gordon Brown. In fact nothing could be further from the truth and before considering the salient points of the agreement it is important to understand the sequence of some of the more significant events which gave rise to it.

In April 2000 the Committee on Fiscal Affairs (CFA) of the OECD published a report on Improving Access to Bank Information for Tax Purposes which among other recommendations set out an ideal standard of access to bank information, namely, that "all member countries should permit access to bank information, directly or indirectly, for all tax purposes so that tax authorities can fully discharge their revenue-raising responsibilities and engage in effective exchange of information with their treaty partners". In the ensuing 12 years, this, to some somewhat alien concept, has led to a number of improvements, including:

  • Prohibition of numbered accounts;

  • Establishment of customer identification (KYC) requirements;

  • Access to bank information for criminal investigation purposes;

  • Measures to improve systems for exchanging information between fiscal authorities;

  • Strategies to encourage the voluntary disclosure of unreported income;

  • Review of any domestic requirement that prevents tax authorities from obtaining information requested by a tax treaty partner.

Needless to say these significant changes did not happen overnight and indeed a number of jurisdictions such as Switzerland have been dragging their feet in implementing them in their entirety. In the same year as the CFA report was published, the Financial Action Task Force, which functions alongside the OECD, produced a list of Non-Cooperative Countries and Territories. The motivation for this was the compelling need to combat terrorist financing and money laundering. And at the same time the OECD drew up a list of uncooperative tax havens which at the time included the UK Crown Dependencies. Over the years since then, the harmful tax practices, the lack of banking transparency and inadequate arrangements for the exchange of information have largely been addressed and there are no countries on the black-list.

This concerted effort to combat the money-laundering offence of tax evasion, which can impact on companies as well as individuals, has led to a number of initiatives such as:

  • The launch in 2005 of the European Savings Directive (EUSD) under which EU member states share information about interest paid by their banks to individual EU-resident account holders. Several countries which are not members of the EU have nevertheless subsequently been persuaded to take part in this initiative.

  • Two amnesties in the US resulting in some 30,000 disclosures.

  • Criminal action by the Internal Revenue Service (IRS), leading to the prosecution and imprisonment of Swiss bank officials for aiding and abetting tax evasion by US citizens.

  • The handing over to the IRS, by a leading Swiss bank, of the names of 4,500 US account holders.

  • The serving by the IRS, in December 2011, of ultimatums to 11 Swiss banks requiring information about US taxpayers with accounts in Switzerland.

  • Two opportunities offered to UK taxpayers to disclose hidden offshore accounts – the Offshore Disclosure Facility in 2007 and the New Disclosure Opportunity in 2009. These were not amnesties since they required payment of the tax and interest in full albeit with a much reduced penalty. The initiatives prompted over 50,000 disclosures giving a total yield to the Exchequer in excess of £600 million ($940 million).

  • The Liechtenstein Disclosure Facility (LDF) which truly is an amnesty and comprises an agreement between the UK and the Principality of Liechtenstein under which taxpayers – both individuals and companies – who have offshore accounts, not just in Liechtenstein, not opened by way of a UK bank branch or agency can come forward up to March 31 2015 and pay tax only for the 10 years to April 5 2009 even if the account was opened before April 6 1999.

  • The introduction of OECD model tax information exchange agreements which have been adopted by many of the countries and territories previously on the OECD black-list.

  • The introduction into many double tax treaties of Article 26 from the OECD model tax convention concerning the Exchange of Information on Tax Matters.

Apart from those officially inspired moves to root out tax evasion there have also been at least two incidents involving the theft of bank account data from Liechtenstein and Swiss banks which was subsequently sold to various fiscal authorities including those in Germany, France and the UK. The information has provided a mass of information leading to widespread criminal and civil tax investigations which will take many years to complete. There are also good grounds for believing that the acquisition of such sensitive date was at least partly responsible for the LDF and the recent tax cooperation agreements between Switzerland and Germany and the UK respectively.

The agreement between Switzerland and the UK was initialled on August 2011 but is unlikely to come into force until January 1 2013 after it has been enacted by both parties. Article 1 of the agreement commits both parties to cooperate in achieving the following:

  • "the tax regularisation of relevant assets held in Switzerland by or for relevant persons", and

  • "the effective taxation of the income and gains on relevant assets held in Switzerland…"

The agreement states that the "enduring effect is equivalent to the outcome that would be achieved through an agreement to exchange information about individuals on an automatic basis". Notwithstanding the relentless pressure which has been brought to bear over the last decade on jurisdictions with opaque banking systems, who would have believed that Switzerland would ever have allowed its long and jealously-guarded commitment to the utmost banking secrecy to be penetrated in this fashion?

After the agreement comes into force, UK taxpayers with investments in Switzerland will suffer a withholding tax of 48% for interest and other income, 40% for dividend income, and 27% for capital gains.

The commitment to tax previously untaxed assets held by UK taxpayers in Switzerland is without doubt the most surprising and controversial feature of the agreement. This will be achieved by the deduction of a one-off flat-rate payment from funds held in Swiss accounts or deposits which will then be paid anonymously to the UK Exchequer. The rate at which such a tax will be charged will range between 19% and 34% depending on how long the assets have been held untaxed in Switzerland. It will be based on relevant capital held at December 31 2010 and December 31 2012 and calculated in accordance with a complex formula set out in the agreement. The arrangement is controversial because it means that those who have committed serious tax fraud in the UK will be deemed to have regularised the past without their identity being known to HM Revenue & Customs (HMRC). Those who came forward under previous disclosure arrangements such as the ODF and the NDO and paid tax for up to 20 years along with interest and penalties may be forgiven for feeling that justice has not been administered equitably.

On the other hand there are dangers for those with untaxed funds in Switzerland who may be tempted to regard themselves as being totally off the hook by virtue of the anonymous payment. They will not be exempt from future investigation and should such an investigation uncover untaxed funds held elsewhere which have not been declared it is almost certain that this will lead at least to the imposition of more stringent penalties and quite possibly to criminal investigation. Nor will the one-off payment fully discharge all liabilities where the taxpayer is under investigation at May 31 2013 or where before that date he had been subject to a serious civil investigation during which the Swiss assets were not disclosed or if he had been involved in any of the disclosure facilities mentioned earlier.

Furthermore the agreement does not give an unequivocal guarantee that those with untaxed funds in Switzerland who comply fully with the terms of the agreement will not be subject to future criminal investigation in relation to these funds. This will be particularly so if the assets represent the proceeds of crime other than crime connected to a tax-related offence or represent the proceeds of crime connected to a tax-related offence which is punishable by two years or more imprisonment or are the proceeds of criminal attacks and systemic fraud against the UK tax and benefit regimes.

The agreement applies only to individuals resident in the UK who hold assets in Switzerland whether directly or through a trust or domiciliary company – i.e. a company or entity with no commercial activity – in which they have a beneficial interest. The assets include all bank accounts, cash and precious metals accounts, portfolios of stocks, shares and securities, options, debts and forward contracts, insurance wrappers and structured products held at banks, brokers and asset managers. Assets excluded from the one-off tax (but not from taxation should they have been financed from untaxed income) include the contents of safe deposit boxes, real property and chattels.

Those who are likely to be affected and who are resident and domiciled in the UK have three options which they must now actively consider. However, they will have five months from the date the agreement comes into force in which to make their choice. They can:

  • Suffer a one-off payment for the past and withholding taxes for the future;

  • Disclose to HMRC that they are fully compliant in the UK;

  • Make a voluntary disclosure of irregularities via the Swiss tax authority to HMRC and possibly choose to register under the LDF. It is very likely that this will prove to be the most cost-effective method of regularising the past but careful consideration needs to be given before a decision is made to go down this path; or

  • Move the assets out of Switzerland. In due course the Swiss tax authorities will provide HMRC with details of the top 10 destinations to which funds have been transferred. These jurisdictions can expect to come under pressure from the UK to enter into similar arrangements at some time in the near future. Swiss banks are now putting difficulties in the way of those who wish to draw out their funds in cash.

The commentary on the agreement by the Swiss Bankers' Association says "In principle the Agreement is not applicable to so-called "non-UK domiciled individuals". This is demonstrably not so. For example, anyone who is not domiciled in the UK who has diverted untaxed funds earned in the UK to a Swiss bank has a liability which ought to be addressed.

Individuals who are not domiciled in the UK will have to provide the Swiss paying agent with a certificate produced by a lawyer, accountant or tax adviser who is a member of a relevant professional body confirming that they are not UK domiciled, that their domicile status is not under challenge by HMRC and that they claimed the remittance basis for 2010/11 and 2011/12. They can then:

  • Suffer the one-off payment;

  • Disclose to HMRC all untaxed remittances of non-UK income and gains to the UK and all UK income which has not been taxed and pay tax at 34%;

  • Disclose to HMRC that they are fully compliant in the UK; or

  • Move the assets out of Switzerland.

It will be possible for those not UK-domiciled to opt out of the one-off payment but those who do so must be aware that if they are subsequently found to have done so wrongly they will suffer significant penalties and quite possibly face criminal investigation.

Clearly this Agreement has irrevocably changed the landscape for those who have sought to evade taxes in the UK and indeed around the world. It contains an enhanced exchange of information provision under which HMRC will be able to make up to 500 enquiries a year about UK taxpayers believed to have funds in Switzerland without specifying the bank in which the finds may be held.

Governments everywhere are desperate to increase their tax revenues and other countries are now clamouring for similar deals with Switzerland, which has indicated its willingness to cooperate.

Andrew Watt, (andrewswatt@hotmail.com) is a tax investigations consultant, and former managing director at Alvarez & Marsal Taxand UK.

more across site & shared bottom lb ros

More from across our site

Increasingly complex reporting and tax requirements were cited by the firm as an enduring driver of demand
A&M Tax is continuing its global expansion drive as it builds a broader full-service offering to challenge the big four
KPMG's UK head of tax policy discusses what the Budget means for businesses, whether pillar two has survived its US carve-out, and why taxing wealth could become the next global debate
The appointments of Thomas Gaughan and Daniel Martinez further signal that the private client advisory market is booming
The rebrand, which MHA said would make its connection to the Baker Tilly network ‘clear’, will take effect in February
The stars of Weil’s heavyweight tax practices are up for grabs, but recruiting firms will need to be patient to secure a package deal
Meta has overtaken Amazon as the ‘Silicon Six’ business with the worst tax conduct, according to the Fair Tax Foundation
Awards
It was also a memorable night for Baker McKenzie and its associated firms, after picking up 19 awards, including the coveted Asia-Pacific Tax Law Firm of the Year
Stocche Forbes Advogados, Utumi Advogados and Lobo de Rizzo Advogados have reached Tier 2 as competition intensifies in the region’s largest tax market
Ben Webster’s arrival represents a significant expansion of Withers’ London tax litigation practice, as the private client firm eyes further international growth
Gift this article