It is no secret that the administration needs to increase tax revenues to address the record-level deficit. Furthermore, as recently noted by Ed Kleinbard, the former chief of staff of the Joint Committee on Taxation (JCT): “[t]ransfer pricing is the inevitable place for governments to look for revenue.”
Despite sweeping changes to international corporate tax introduced in the administration’s May 2009 proposals (potentially raising as much as $210 billion over 10 years), those proposals contained only three transfer pricing “clarifications”, which are actually substantial changes to existing law.
First, the definition of intangible property for sections 367(d) and 482 was changed to include workforce in place, goodwill, and going concern value. This expanded definition is clearly intended to discourage certain outbound business restructuring transactions.
Other clarifications were made to value multiple transferred intangible properties on an aggregate basis where that produced a more reliable result and to value intangible property based upon its highest and best use.
In September 2009, the JCT – reacting to assertions that misuse of transfer pricing rules continues to erode the US tax base – supplemented the administration’s proposals. The JCT suggested that broader reform of existing transfer pricing rules might be necessary, and issued several transfer pricing-specific proposals of its own, with a clear focus on intangibles:
Methodology: discourages the use of the comparable uncontrolled transaction method unless there are exact comparables; encourages the use of income-based methods.
Cost-sharing arrangements: suggests narrowing the applicability of the framework articulated in Treasury regulation section 1.482-7 to situations where comparable arrangements exist between unrelated parties. (Per Xilinx v Commissioner, 125 TC 37 (2005), 567 F 3d 482 (9th Cir 2009), the IRS’s position is that there are no comparable arrangements between unrelated parties).
Periodic adjustments implementing the commensurate with income rule: advocates eliminating exceptions to the periodic adjustment rules, automatically triggering periodic adjustments when there’s a significant gap between projected and actual profits.
Omissions in the administration and JCT proposals are also informative. Although some academics have recently advocated formulary apportionment as a means of simplifying and equalising the corporate tax landscape, there is no evidence that formulary apportionment is under serious consideration.
The legislative proposals are consistent with the administrative trend of placing transfer pricing under increasingly strict scrutiny, especially transfers of intangible property. This trend is especially evident when taking into account the large and midsize business division’s goal of hiring of 700 international specialists, and the IRS’s aggressive examination of Tier 1 issues, which include the “transfer of intangibles offshore” and cost-sharing. Furthermore, the IRS has created the Transfer Pricing Council, comprised of members from across all of the agency’s service lines, to look for gaps in transfer pricing guidance and provide direction to resolve cases. In addition to its internal enforcement efforts, the US will continue to cooperate with international organisations such as the OECD and the Joint International Tax Shelter Information Centre (JITSIC) to achieve consistent global enforcement.
Steven Wrappe, Principal, Ernst & Young LLP - International Tax Services/Transfer Pricing - New York steven.wrappe@ey.com
The views expressed herein are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Ernst & Young LLP